FDR- the Icon Hero of the Left

[gipper]

FDR was a disaster. His stupid economic policies prolonged the Great Depression, causing terrible suffering for millions of Americans. He forced farmers to destroy their products, when Americans were starving...them lied us into war.

 

[JakeStarkey]

Laney and Muhammed would have supported FDR's internment policies in 1942.

 

[Votto]

Laney and Muhammed would have supported FDR's internment policies in 1942.

As would Hitler and Stalin

So what is your point?

 

[gipper]

Laney and Muhammed would have supported FDR's internment policies in 1942.

As would Hitler and Stalin

So what is your point?

He never has one.

 

[JakeStarkey]

Laney and Muhammed would have supported FDR's internment policies in 1942.

As would Hitler and Stalin

So what is your point?

You would have supported it as well, Votto.

 

[Moonglow]

California had already started the process FDR made it a federal issue..Yet the majority of Americans would have preferred them dead....

 

[Votto]

Laney and Muhammed would have supported FDR's internment policies in 1942.

As would Hitler and Stalin

So what is your point?

You would have supported it as well, Votto.

No, that is where you are wrong. I'm more of a libertarian and not a partisan hack like yourself

The fact of the matter is, YOU are the one supporting a man who supported it.

 

[Camp]

Military Commander with the task of defending the western US coast against Japanese attack and espionage was in favor of and asked for the Japanese internment program. FDR's hands were tied so to speak. He would have had to go against his military commanders on the internment issue.

 

[Votto]

Military Commander with the task of defending the western US coast against Japanese attack and espionage was in favor of and asked for the Japanese internment program. FDR's hands were tied so to speak. He would have had to go against his military commanders on the internment issue.

Bull.

German Americans were allowed to go free.

This was only stooped in racism.

Really, Dims have not changes. They now want brown folk to come to America so they will outnumber the white folk, in the hopes of getting more votes, as if any of this makes any sense.

Dims are the biggest racists in human history.

 

[Camp]

Military Commander with the task of defending the western US coast against Japanese attack and espionage was in favor of and asked for the Japanese internment program. FDR's hands were tied so to speak. He would have had to go against his military commanders on the internment issue.

Bull.

German Americans were allowed to go free.

Are you claiming Gen. DeWitt is fictional and no east coast Germans were imprisoned?

 

[rightwinger]

Yup, we all remember FDR's slaves working on the WH's plantation.

Jake,

The Japanese Americans were put into prison camps for being Japanese...

Now Jake if Trump did this to Muslim Americans you would scream like crazy about how Trump is evil but FDR is a hero to you.

Also during Roosevelt tenure as President he sent Jewish people fleeing death camps back to Europe and yet you scream about how Trump is a damn Nazi for deporting illegals...

So if FDR is a great hero of America then you have very low standards because the reality is FDR was a racist bigot from upstate New York from a very rich family, but hey Trump is a Nazi and FDR is a hero to those like you...

That was 1942 America

We were racist

Wrong is wrong no matter what era it was!

You do not take American citizens and put them into prison camps!

Simple as that and seeing you have no problem with what FDR did mean you should not have any problem with Trump and his work against Muslim Americans and illegals...

We did a lot of wrong things in 1942

Ask the blacks

 

[rightwinger]

Military Commander with the task of defending the western US coast against Japanese attack and espionage was in favor of and asked for the Japanese internment program. FDR's hands were tied so to speak. He would have had to go against his military commanders on the internment issue.

Nobody cared how the Japs were treated after Pearl Harbor

 

[Camp]

Espionage in WWll could and did often consist of a spy with binoculars reporting the comings and goings of ships via a radio to an offshore Submarine.

 

[JakeStarkey]

Laney and Muhammed would have supported FDR's internment policies in 1942.

As would Hitler and Stalin

So what is your point?

You would have supported it as well, Votto.

No, that is where you are wrong. I'm more of a libertarian and not a partisan hack like yourself

The fact of the matter is, YOU are the one supporting a man who supported it.

I am more of a Republican and not a partisan hack like you, Votto. 95% of America supported it.

 

[regent]

Are some posters saying that both the American people and America's best historians have had it wrong about FDR. The people elected him four times in a row and might still be voting for him had he lived. Name another president elected four times. Historians have never placed FDR below third best president since 1948, and recently named FDR best American president.
Is it possible that Trump supporters are getting ready to replace FDR as America's best president with Trump?

 

[JakeStarkey]

Trump supporters be like crazy if they think that craziness.

 

[regent]

Progs are in a dilemma over FDR. He was one of the Founding Prog fathers who preached "positive rights". In other words, he promoted exponentially expanding and power hungry government but was a racist and locked up innocent Japanese Americans. He also tried to change the Constitution to put stooge judges on the Supreme Court so that they would rule in his favor.

Shrug, they just embrace him anyway..

Disgusting.

So did the Japanese Americans ever vote Democratic again? Did any Japanese Americans ever join the American army during the war?
Germans and Italians were picked up during the war but they had already been identified and watched before Pearl Harbor.

 

[Unkotare]

...

Wrong is wrong no matter what era it was!

You do not take American citizens and put them into prison camps!.....

The scumbag fdr was one of only two US presidents to put innocent Americans into concentration camps.

 

[Unkotare]

Progs are in a dilemma over FDR. He was one of the Founding Prog fathers who preached "positive rights". In other words, he promoted exponentially expanding and power hungry government but was a racist and locked up innocent Japanese Americans. He also tried to change the Constitution to put stooge judges on the Supreme Court so that they would rule in his favor.

Shrug, they just embrace him anyway..

Disgusting.

So did the Japanese Americans ever vote Democratic again? Did any Japanese Americans ever join the American army during the war?.....

Red herring - again.

 

[Unkotare]

Military Commander with the task of defending the western US coast against Japanese attack and espionage was in favor of and asked for the Japanese internment program. FDR's hands were tied so to speak. He would have had to go against his military commanders on the internment issue.

Are some posters saying that both the American people and America's best historians have had it wrong about FDR. The people elected him four times in a row and might still be voting for him had he lived. Name another president elected four times. Historians have never placed FDR below third best president since 1948, and recently named FDR best American president.
Is it possible that Trump supporters are getting ready to replace FDR as America's best president with Trump?

Trying to see how many logical fallacies you can cram into one post?