Wehrwolfen
Senior Member
- May 22, 2012
- 2,750
- 340
- 48
Feinsteins Folly
By Aaron Goldstein
1.30.138AM
If Canada doesnt need a national gun registry, why do we?
When Senator Dianne Feinstein introduced legislation last week to reinstate the assault weapons ban, the veteran California Democrat also proposed a national gun registry. The registry would apply to all legally owned weapons grandfathered prior to the assault weapons ban taking effect.
Canadians are all too familiar with gun registries. In 1995, the Liberal government of Jean Chrétien passed the Firearms Act which established the Canadian Firearms Registry. It was a white elephant plagued by cost overruns in the hundreds of millions of dollars and was the target of frequent criticism by Sheila Fraser, Canadas former Auditor General. Noted conservative Canadian journalist Peter Worthington wrote, Gun registry is little but an expensive, unnecessary, largely useless waste of time. Bureaucratic boondoggle aptly describes the program.
The Conservative Party long vowed to scrap the gun registry when it came to power. Although Stephen Harpers Tories ousted the Liberals from power in 2006, they did not have a majority in parliament until after the 2011 election. Last year, the Tories finally abolished the Canadian Firearms Registry. Shortly before the House of Commons held its final vote on the matter, Public Safety Minister Vic Toews told reporters, It does nothing to help put an end to gun crimes, nor has it saved one Canadian life. This is simply an attempt to make people feel safe, rather than doing something substantive in criminal law.
The Canadian Firearms Registry has become such an albatross that even Liberal politicians now want no part of it. Last December, Liberal leadership hopeful Justin Trudeau (the eldest son of the late Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau) said, The long gun registry, as it was, was a failure and Im not going to resuscitate that. Trudeaus main leadership rival, Marc Garneau (who is best known as Canadas first man in space), made similar comments. Its gone now, he said. The Conservatives have killed it. Lets move on to other things. It is not my intention to spend more money to bring it back.
So if Canada doesnt need a national gun registry, why do we?
[Excerpt]
Read more:
The American Spectator : Feinstein's Folly