NYcarbineer
Diamond Member
How can you selectively apply the 14th amendment when it applies to all American citizens?So you want to pick and choose what the 14th Amendment protects, but you don't want others to do the same.
Right back at ya hero. You seem to think the 14th can't be selectively applied and the 2nd can. You can't have it both ways.
You still haven't demonstrated how it was selectively applied, marriage laws treated all men and women equally, there was no discrimination based on sex.
Yes there was.
You, a man could marry a woman.
Bodecea, a woman, could not marry a woman.
Bod was being denied a right that you had because she was a woman.
Right, she could marry any man she chose, so in fact there was no discrimination because it was applied equally to both genders.
So your argument is that a state if it so chose could in fact ONLY recognize same sex marriage as legal and that wouldn't be discriminatory and no one in that state should complain about it.