Sequester harming the Nation's defenses? (ask the US Navy)

Kondor3

Cafeteria Centrist
Jul 29, 2009
33,946
9,912
1,340
Illinois, USA
Man torches $400 million nuke sub; Navy's budget struggles for air

By Emily Smith, CNN - updated 9:11 AM EDT, Thu August 8, 2013

130807194149-uss-miami-horizontal-gallery.jpg


On Tuesday, August 6, the Navy announced that despite the demand for attack submarines being "as strong as ever," the USS Miami is being deactivated because the repairs are too costly. The submarine was damaged in 2012 after worker Casey James Fury set a fire on board the sub.

(CNN) -- Casey James Fury simply didn't want to be at work, and in the process cost the Navy nearly a half-billion dollars and one attack submarine.

Fury admitted to setting fire to the USS Miami, a nuclear sub, in May 2012 while it was in dry dock. He was sentenced to 17 years in federal prison in March and ordered to pay $400 million in restitution -- roughly the cost of the damage.

The Navy won't see anything close to that amount from Fury, of course, but neither will it from Uncle Sam.

On Tuesday, the Navy announced that despite the demand for attack submarines being "as strong as ever," the Miami is being inactivated. The reason: Under sequestration, the federal government's forced budget cuts, the Navy simply can't afford to make the repairs.

"The type of damage was unlike anything we'd seen in recent memory," Rear Admiral Richard Breckenridge, director of undersea warfare, said on a Navy Live blog post. "The anticipated scope of work is four times greater than any previous submarine repair due to damage," the post continued.

http://security.blogs.cnn.com/2013/02/20/military-shows-congress-where-mandatory-cuts-will-hit-home/ (supplemental link, Military Shows Congress Where Cuts Will Hit Home)

Breckenridge blamed across-board budget cuts, saying, "Sequestration pressures remove the needed foundation of stability to support an endeavor of this magnitude."

Fury was working inside the Miami on May 23 as a painter and sandblaster while the Los Angeles-class attack submarine was at the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard in Maine undergoing a massive overhaul.

Initial investigations by the Navy found that the fire may have been started by a vacuum cleaner. But a federal criminal complaint said Fury admitted to setting fire to a pile of rags near a vacuum cleaner in a stateroom in the submarine.

Seven people were injured in the blaze, including three shipyard firefighters. The sub's reactor was not operating when the fire broke out and remained unaffected and stable throughout, Capt. Bryant Fuller, commander for the shipyard, said at the time.

Fury also admitted to starting a second fire at the dry dock three weeks later, according to federal court documents. The second fire was started in an area underneath the submarine where Fury was working. In both cases, he told investigators that he started the fires because he was having extreme anxiety and was trying to get out of work, according to federal documents.

...

U.S. Sens. Susan Collins and Angus King of Maine, and Jeanne Shaheen and Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire, expressed their disappointment at the announcement, saying in a statement that inactivating the Miami, "will mean a loss to our nuclear submarine fleet -- yet another unfortunate consequence of the across-the-board cuts known as sequestration. We will continue to work together to find a responsible budget solution that replaces sequestration."

...

Link to article: http://www.cnn.com/2013/08/07/us/navy-submarine-lost/index.html?hpt=hp_c2

==============================

Is this a blip on the scope or does the Sequester threaten considerable more harm to our military capability than we first made allowance for?
 
Last edited:
Government spending makes the flowers bloom, the grass grow and the sun rise!

Government spending keeps Al Qaida at bay as well. The US Government sponsored Al Qaida at least.
 
Well, for a hater of civilization that is about your limitations in your understanding.

People like you are kind of like the Taliban as you don't want any advancement of the nation. You want to go back to 1791!
 
Last edited:
Does this have anything to do with the white house memo to increase the maximum amount of pain on Americans and blame it on the sequester?

Yes it does.
 
The conservative movement in this country has blown its brains out by NOT focusing on our 1st, 2nd, 4th amendment rights. Stupidly you want to defund our educational programs, science and infrastructure that makes us a first world nation over them.

You people are nuts.
 
Does this have anything to do with the white house memo to increase the maximum amount of pain on Americans and blame it on the sequester?

Yes it does.
Yeah because one less attack submarine sure impacts hundreds of millions of Americans every day. In fact just the other day I found my neighbor sobbing on his front porch, when I asked what was wrong a tear rolled down his cheek as he said in a whispery voice "they aren't repairing the USS Miami" then we had a moment of silence and pondered how this was hitting us where it hurts.

Neighbor aside this sounds like political grandstanding to me, the 70s era Los Angeles class is older and are in the process of being decommissioned (20 already have been) to be replaced by the newer more capable Virginia class attack submarines which have several under construction and more coming online possibly into the late 2020s. The only real impact this will have is shuffling around the decommissioning schedule to move Miami to the front of the line.

Does it suck that some asshat burned up a working sub? Yes.

Do having less money hurt the military? Yes of course.

Does losing a 25 year old submarine that would be replaced soon anyway significantly impact our national defense? Probably not.
 
Last edited:

Forum List

Back
Top