The Official Discussion Thread for who is considered indiginous to Palestine?

[surada]

There was no place Palestine in the Ottoman Empire. There were no Palestinians. Jewish population was indigenous.

The Jews are just as indigenous to Palestine as the Assyrians and the Canaanites.

 

[rylah]

The Jews are just as indigenous to Palestine as the Assyrians and the Canaanites.

Know what 'Palestine' means in the native language?

Indigenous means a distinct civilization in its specific place of origin.
Neither Assyria a Levantene civilization, nor Canaanites were even Semites.

 

[MartyNYC]

The Jews are just as indigenous to Palestine as the Assyrians and the Canaanites.

Um, Assyrians and Canaanites are extinct. Except, Jews, who are living links to Canaanites, as Israelites were Canaanites.

 

[MartyNYC]

In the 12th century BC it was called P.alashu .

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/05/28/dueling-histories-debate-over-historic-palestine/

Assyrians called the area between the Jordan River and Mediterranean Sea “Bit Humri,” referring to Israelite King Omri.

Expedition Magazine - Penn Museum

 

[surada]

Um, Assyrians and Canaanites are extinct. Except, Jews, who are living links to Canaanites, as Israelites were Canaanites.

They aren't extinct. They're the ancestors of the Palestinians

 

[MartyNYC]

In the 12th century BC it was called P.alashu .

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/05/28/dueling-histories-debate-over-historic-palestine/

They aren't extinct. They're the ancestors of the Palestinians

No. Rashid Khalidi acknowledges palestinians have no links to ancient peoples…

 

[surada]

Know what 'Palestine' means in the native language?

Indigenous means a distinct civilization in its specific place of origin.
Neither Assyria a Levantene civilization, nor Canaanites were even Semites.

Palestine has nothing to do with the philistines.. They were there before the Sea people. It's reference is Palashu.

 

[surada]

No. Rashid Khalidi acknowledges palestinians have no links to ancient peoples…

View attachment 691936

DNA says he's wrong.

 

[MartyNYC]

In the 12th century BC it was called P.alashu .

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/05/28/dueling-histories-debate-over-historic-palestine/

Assyrians referred to Philistines as Palastu. Philistines were raiders from the Greek world known as Sea Peoples, and Palastu designated the Mediterranean coast inhabited by Philistines. Not Palestine and not Palestinians.

 

[MartyNYC]

Palestine has nothing to do with the philistines.. They were there before the Sea people. It's reference is Palashu.

Philistines gave the name Palestine to the area, specifically the Mediterranean coast they occupied.

 

[MartyNYC]

DNA says he's wrong.

Philistines were related to Greeks and were Sea Peoples. Scholars say Philistine genes help solve biblical mystery

 

[Uncensored2008]

There was no place Palestine in the Ottoman Empire. There were no Palestinians. Jewish population was indigenous.

Oh, Hezbollah Hannah knows that. She's just a Muslim Supremacist who will - and does - tell any lie to further the dream of a Caliphate.

Palestine under the Ottomans was a REGION, like the mid-West the South.

As you noted, there has never in the history of the world been a nation or country of Palestine, and never have their been Palestinian people - until Arafat invented them as part of the Muslim supremacist movement.

What liars for Allah like Hezbollah Hannah - that is surada distort is that Ottoman Palestine included all of Jordan, all of Israel, all of Lebanon, and southern Syria. Muslim supremacists focus on Israel simply because it isn't under Muslim rule.

That Balfour declaration gave Lebanon to the Christians, Israel to the Jews, Jordan to the Arabs, and carved out modern Syria for the Arabs as well - since Muslims long since murdered all the actual Assyrians.

Muslim supremacists like Hezbollah Hannah engaged in a terrorist war to overthrow Christian Lebanon - leaving only tiny Israel not under the dominion of Islam. Muhammad is an angry and jealous god - he will not abide even one grain of sand that is not ruled by Muslims.

Surada and other Muslim supremacists like her, will lie, murder, cheat, and wage war to impose Muslim dominance on any land that was ever invaded by the Caliphate. That includes Spain, Portugal, France, etc.

If the Muslim supremacists were to ever conquer Israel, they will turn their efforts to Europe - where they already have millions of fighters ready to die for their filthy god Muhammad and the two-bit Djin Allah.

 

[MartyNYC]

Oh, Hezbollah Hannah knows that. She's just a Muslim Supremacist who will - and does - tell any lie to further the dream of a Caliphate.

Palestine under the Ottomans was a REGION, like the mid-West the South.

As you noted, there has never in the history of the world been a nation or country of Palestine, and never have their been Palestinian people - until Arafat invented them as part of the Muslim supremacist movement.

What liars for Allah like Hezbollah Hannah - that is surada distort is that Ottoman Palestine included all of Jordan, all of Israel, all of Lebanon, and southern Syria. Muslim supremacists focus on Israel simply because it isn't under Muslim rule.

That Balfour declaration gave Lebanon to the Christians, Israel to the Jews, Jordan to the Arabs, and carved out modern Syria for the Arabs as well - since Muslims long since murdered all the actual Assyrians.

Muslim supremacists like Hezbollah Hannah engaged in a terrorist war to overthrow Christian Lebanon - leaving only tiny Israel not under the dominion of Islam. Muhammad is an angry and jealous god - he will not abide even one grain of sand that is not ruled by Muslims.

Surada and other Muslim supremacists like her, will lie, murder, cheat, and wage war to impose Muslim dominance on any land that was ever invaded by the Caliphate. That includes Spain, Portugal, France, etc.

If the Muslim supremacists were to ever conquer Israel, they will turn their efforts to Europe - where they already have millions of fighters ready to die for their filthy god Muhammad and the two-bit Djin Allah.

Oh, Hezbollah Hannah knows that. She's just a Muslim Supremacist who will - and does - tell any lie to further the dream of a Caliphate.

Palestine under the Ottomans was a REGION, like the mid-West the South.

As you noted, there has never in the history of the world been a nation or country of Palestine, and never have their been Palestinian people - until Arafat invented them as part of the Muslim supremacist movement.

What liars for Allah like Hezbollah Hannah - that is surada distort is that Ottoman Palestine included all of Jordan, all of Israel, all of Lebanon, and southern Syria. Muslim supremacists focus on Israel simply because it isn't under Muslim rule.

That Balfour declaration gave Lebanon to the Christians, Israel to the Jews, Jordan to the Arabs, and carved out modern Syria for the Arabs as well - since Muslims long since murdered all the actual Assyrians.

Muslim supremacists like Hezbollah Hannah engaged in a terrorist war to overthrow Christian Lebanon - leaving only tiny Israel not under the dominion of Islam. Muhammad is an angry and jealous god - he will not abide even one grain of sand that is not ruled by Muslims.

Surada and other Muslim supremacists like her, will lie, murder, cheat, and wage war to impose Muslim dominance on any land that was ever invaded by the Caliphate. That includes Spain, Portugal, France, etc.

If the Muslim supremacists were to ever conquer Israel, they will turn their efforts to Europe - where they already have millions of fighters ready to die for their filthy god Muhammad and the two-bit Djin Allah.

Not all Muslims…

 

[Uncensored2008]

They aren't extinct. They're the ancestors of the Palestinians

There are no "Palestinians."

There are Arabs, who migrated from North Africa. The Assyrians, Medes, Hittites, Persians - all were white. The Arabs engaged in genocide and killed them all - save a smattering of Persians in Iran - but they are nearly displaced by Arabs as well.

 

[Uncensored2008]

Not all Muslims…
View attachment 691942

Not all Muslims - all Muslim supremacists.

 

[surada]

Philistines were related to Greeks and were Sea Peoples. Scholars say Philistine genes help solve biblical mystery

Yes, I know that they came from the Greek islands, but they aren't the ancestors of the Palestinians. They were in Canaan much earlier.

 

[MartyNYC]

Not all Muslims - all Muslim supremacists.

Quran wrote about Solomon’s Temple and even synagogues. Denying Jews’ historical ownership of Israel is denying the Quran.

 

[surada]

There are no "Palestinians."

There are Arabs, who migrated from North Africa. The Assyrians, Medes, Hittites, Persians - all were white. The Arabs engaged in genocide and killed them all - save a smattering of Persians in Iran - but they are nearly displaced by Arabs as well.

Have you never heard of the Akkadian empire? They migrated from Arabia long before Islam or Judaism. Arabs are not a race, but they are white especially in the interior where they didn't mix with East Africans.

 

[MartyNYC]

Have you never heard of the Akkadian empire? They migrated from Arabia long before Islam or Judaism. Arabs are not a race, but they are white especially in the interior where they didn't mix with East Africans.

Renowned scholar Bernard Lewis: “In recent years a new doctrine has been developed in Arab countries. Arab historiography has extended the Arab identity to all or nearly all Semitic peoples. In terms of scholarship there is no evidence whatsoever that Canaanites were Arabs.”

 

[surada]

Quran wrote about Solomon’s Temple and even synagogues. Denying Jews’ historical ownership of Israel is denying the Quran.

View attachment 691947

Yes, Muslims revere all the patriarchs including King Solomon.