Pogo
Diamond Member
- Dec 7, 2012
- 123,708
- 22,748
Not really. I'm not Christian. They aren't "my people". It's not my religion. I don't have one.
I know they're not. You already self-identified as an agnostic. Don't take it personally.
Islamic jihad revolves around an archaic, fundamentalist reading of their texts. It REVOLVES around it. It is the foremost impetus of their actions. There are other political factors involved, but their terrorism is as lethal as it is because they have a genuine belief in martyrdom and paradise, leaving them unafraid of death.
That's just not the case. You touched on what is the case --- "political factors". As I just noted above, any skilled political mob manipulator can make his sheeple believe it's what Allah wants, just as the Klan could convince its own sheeple that it really is what God wants to lynch a Jew. And yes, no question it is a "genuine belief". That's the whole problem of sheeple.
With the KKK, Christianity is a tool. Their ideology revolves around racial superiority, which has nothing to do with the bible. At least, not in a modern-day context.
Absolutely it's a tool. And kind of an effective one, which is one of the side effects of investing that much magic in a book totem that remains open to interpretation by any manipulator who can convince enough blind followers that he has all the answers -- in other words a skilled salesman.
Again, the Klan saw itself as a moral police force, not just race. They went after gamblers, adulterers, bad debt holders, drinkers and various others (labor unions, Jews, Catholics and later, communists) that had nothing to do with race. That the bible doesn't specifically tell them to pull a woman out of her house and whip her for not going to church is irrelevant to the fact that they CLAIM it as a basis.
There are similarities, but the motivations are very different. We just disagree on the extent to which Islam plays a role in Islamic terror. I think it plays a large role. By itself, maybe it would just remain a conflict between Shiite and Sunni. But throw in the political factors, and now they're bombing white people in Paris. It changes the game, but the violence inherent in the text would still remain regardless.
Pfft. There's more violence in the Old Testes than any book ever written, from smiting everybody in sight to outright genocide to giving up one's own daughters to a rape squad to dashing babies' heads against the rocks to stoning people to death. Again, any slick salesman can use that to either bless babies or to dash their heads against the rocks. The book being used as a tool is profoundly irrelevant. It's the sales pitch, by that flashy guy who is very much alive and animated, that does the damage.