2aguy
Diamond Member
- Jul 19, 2014
- 112,236
- 52,459
- Thread starter
- #61
Well good luck. Let us know when a state legislature passes this kind of law and it doesn't get dismissed as cruel and unusual punishment by the federal courts.Where this goes is that we will begin making exceptions as to who gets branded. Each time that happens, the proposal becomes less meaningful. We have already moved the bar from felons to violent felons.What would you do with the 20 year old girl who got involved with the wrong crowd and got caught carrying a gun or drugs. Would she be embarrassed anytime she went to the beach or swimming pool? Would she be restricted to her clothing? Would she still be required to wear this brand 25 years after she finished rehab, got a job, paid taxes and never had another run in with the law? All for the convenience and benefit of those who sell guns?Thanks for the comments…I am looking for the down side…and ways to discuss it and get around them.
Simply carrying a gun is not a violent crime. So probably not. If she was involved in a hold up or other violence with a weapon, then sure. Right now, if you are a felon, I don't believe in most states you get all of your rights back…so a brand like that would do nothing that already being a felon doesn't already do. The key here is to keep violent felons from getting guns, and making it harder for anti gunners to push for licensing, registration and "universal" background checks.
There is this…….what if you are arrested, convicted, and sentenced, and branded….and are later proven innocent? I would say to this concern, you could get paperwork from the state or feds that showed you were cleared and are now allowed to own a gun. This would be a small population of people, and it still wouldn't effect the vast majority of law abiding citizens.
Actually, I always only considered violent felons…someone selling drugs who is not violent…no brand….we want violent criminals to not have guns. I would say a violent felon convicted of a knife, club or empty hand attack gets the no gun brand as well.
I am spreading the word on this on gun sites.....and I plan on calling local politicians.....
I know, it sounds crazy...but it is an actual solution that would actually end the debate on gun shows and private sales.