What is a “well-regulated militia” and why are we so sure it refers to everyone?

[BS Filter]

But why can we be sure the context of the right to bear arms applies to any context outside of a well regulated militia?

Yes. We're sure. The reason we're sure is because we are educated and understand punctuation. The Constitution is for educated people, not Marxist pawns.

 

[irosie91]

the term "well regulated militia" is an oxymoron

 

[Billy000]

Yes. We're sure. The reason we're sure is because we are educated and understand punctuation. The Constitution is for educated people, not Marxist pawns.

What is the amendment saying when it comes to the well regulated militia? What does it mean and why is it in there?

 

[Flash]

Once again you’re just entertaining a fantasy. No one is coming for the guns you own and they NEVER will. You like the idea of the threat though. It makes you feel manly and tough picturing this happening and how you’d respond. That’s why you entertain the notion.

Gun control from the Liberals is never about public safety because most of the gun crime in this country is in Liberal controlled big cities where nobody really gives a fuck.

It is about taking guns away from White Conservative males so that can't oppose the Liberal agenda to turn this country into a Socialist shithole.

That meme is very relevant.

 

[Billy000]

Gun control from the Liberals is never about public safety because most of the gun crime in this country is in Liberal controlled big cities where nobody really gives a fuck.

It is about taking guns away from White Conservative males so that can't oppose the Liberal agenda to turn this country into a Socialist shithole.

That meme is very relevant.

Lol no you’re literally just making shit up. Democrats NEVER talk about confiscating guns already owned. Even if they did, it would still NEVER happen. It’s such a stupid notion to consider.

 

[BS Filter]

What is the amendment saying when it comes to the well regulated militia? What does it mean and why is it in there?

Haven't you ever researched it?

 

[Flash]

Lol no you’re literally just making shit up. Democrats NEVER talk about confiscating guns already owned. Even if they did, it would still NEVER happen. It’s such a stupid notion to consider.

Bullshit!

Several Democrat leaders were calling for the repeal of the 2nd Amendment.

If not repeal then onerous gun restrictions.

Don't try to deny that the Democrats would do away with the right to keep and bear arms if they could get away with it. It just makes you lose even more credibility when you post that lying shit on here.

 

[BlindBoo]

The rightwing will cite court precedent for this issue,

What issue? Well regulated meant to know the chain of command and the basic of military drills. Like marching, picket lines, combat formations, firing lines.....ect.

 

[Lesh]

The rightwing will cite court precedent for this issue, but they don’t actually offer an explanation for why it should be interpreted this way.

Should this apply to 5 year olds? Should it be made legal for kids to buy firearms from a licensed firearm business because of how this is interpreted?

After the Roe ruling you can forget about precedent meaning anything

 

[Lesh]

What issue? Well regulated meant to know the chain of command and the basic of military drills. Like marching, picket lines, combat formations, firing lines.....ect.

I’m fact Article 1 Section 8 spells out what a well regulated militia is. And it ain’t a bunch of slops with assault rifles sittin in front of the barbershop bitching

 

[irosie91]

What issue? Well regulated meant to know the chain of command and the basic of military drills. Like marching, picket lines, combat formations, firing lines.....ect.

yeah--- I did military-----them boys AIN'T well regulated

 

[irosie91]

I’m fact Article 1 Section 8 spells out what a well regulated militia is. And it ain’t a bunch of slops with assault rifles sittin in front of the barbershop bitching

AMERICA is a hunting society. Davy Crockett kilt him a barr when
he was only three. There were people in the state of my childhood
who LIVED for deer and bear hunting season

 

[RetiredGySgt]

What is the amendment saying when it comes to the well regulated militia? What does it mean and why is it in there?

already answered you did not like the answer so ignored it.

 

[Lesh]

AMERICA is a hunting society. Davy Crockett kilt him a barr when
he was only three. There were people in the state of my childhood
who LIVED for deer and bear hunting season

That's nice. I have hunted most of my life.

Has nothing to do with a militia

 

[RetiredGySgt]

After the Roe ruling you can forget about precedent meaning anything

Ya like after plessy? or Board of education?

 

[RetiredGySgt]

That's nice. I have hunted most of my life.

Has nothing to do with a militia

And the second does not depend on a militia to give everyone the right

 

[irosie91]

That's nice. I have hunted most of my life.

Has nothing to do with a militia

in my childhood town----people who HUNTED had rifles. In my adult
town------even if I claimed a need to HUNT DEER---I would have to have
a license to get a rifle

 

[Lesh]

in my childhood town----people who HUNTED had rifles. In my adult
town------even if I claimed a need to HUNT DEER---I would have to have
a license to get a rifle

And?

 

[RetiredGySgt]

And?

Buzz off again there is no requirement for a militia to own a firearm and now the onerous process of getting one in certain locations has been struck down as well.

 

[Billy000]

Haven't you ever researched it?

Can’t you just answer the question?