P F Tinmore
Diamond Member
- Dec 6, 2009
- 79,138
- 4,386
- 1,815
You haven't been following my posts.It is you who misunderstood what he said. He said that a condition had to be met. That condition was a Jewish majority. If Palestine was given to the Jews, why would this be important? If the Palestinians had no sovereignty in the land that should not make a difference. But it did.As always, you are not discussing, you are just messing around.That is not what he was talking about.Many times. What is he saying from 6:00 to 7:50 What is the significance?
Quit being so obtuse. He states that the independent State for the Jewish homeland could have come into being at any time from 1920. Where is the self-contradiction and where is the contradiction with Kontorovich?
What ARE you trying to argue here? The territory HAD borders. Borders are normally transferred from one political entity to another with a change of sovereignty. Do you dispute that?
He clearly states that the Jews would have had a State from 1920 to 1948, any time after 1920, had it not been for the British back stabbing the Jews with Article #6 by cutting down the Jewish right to immigrate into their own homeland.
Is there a problem with that? What is it?
What did you understand from 6 to 7:50 minutes into the video that you are bringing it up? Or let us say it, what is it that you did misunderstand about it?
After the Treaty of Lausenne, The Palestinians became the sovereigns and citizens of Palestine. If a representative government was established with the Jews in the minority there would not be a Jewish state. Britain had the Mandate for 30 years and never established a representative government for that reason. The plan was, through mass immigration, to pack Palestine with Jews and when they became the majority then a government could be established. This never happened. The plan failed and Britain left Palestine without establishing a government.
Link?
It was only a matter of time before you erroneously and falsely tried to connect the Treaty of Lausanne with creation of your invented “country of Pally’land”.
I suppose the last dozen times you failed to support that claim gives credence to another attempt.