OldLady
Diamond Member
- Nov 16, 2015
- 69,568
- 19,607
Iceberg, you didn't see my earlier post, did you? The majority -- the large majority -- of inmates don't give a damn about voting. You are not going to "punish" them further by taking it away.but it has to do with our rights overall to me. i *do* see a difference but don't feel someone in prison has a voice in the direction of this country. not while in prison anyway. when out - unless they were in for election fraud or something then yes - they get their rights back - time served, move on.I never would have connected the prison voting with race if I hadn't seen that article. I have heard that rumor before but didn't know if it was true. Sad statement.to me it simply isn't a racial issue. while *everything* these days seems to be - the fact is, you're in prison, odds are you did *something* to get there and *rights* are suspended. no guns, no voting, no tooling around town in your buick, yea, it sucks but that's prison.I read an article yesterday that I can't find now, saying there were no laws prohibiting prisoners from voting until after the Civil War, when blacks were given the right to vote. Then all of a sudden, these prohibitions sprung up. Apparently, back then there also was a large percentage of black men in prison. Times don't change all that much.the founding fathers did not think that was a good idea, back then... so no such thing was allowed by them or the States, yet voting was allowed when in prison...great.
so give 'em some guns while we're at it.
Makes sense though.... early in our creation, people were much more aware of the power of government officials, and the tyranny they could impose with their power, especially if they were corrupted by it... allowing prisoners to be heard thru their vote, when they think they have legitimate grievances with the laws or judicial system that put them there, seems like a check on the system, so to say...
I think murderers probably got the death penalty back then, via hanging, so it's likely they were not around to vote...
all the "well this race is picked on by that race" i just don't get into. it gives a huge gray area for people to say their race guides their decisions when to me, they guide their own. if they choose to use race as a guide, that doesn't always work. that doesn't make the other person racist anymore than it makes the one doing it racist.
My viewpoint is that inmates are as affected by our laws as anyone else and their right for their voice to be heard should not be interfered with. This argument has nothing to do with guns, btw, so don't keep raising that issue.
guns are also something that even upon release many should just lose the right to have/own. again, depending on the crime but yes, that is a different issue.
as for voting and voting alone - i don't think prisoners should be allowed. to. we keep drifting to releasing people of responsibility for poor decisions and what is going to stop people from continuing to make these decisions if we keep lessening the impact of it for "human concerns".
sooner or later we have to give "tough love" - not make things easier.