How should Democrats vote on Gorsuch?

Only willing to do it now because of the obstruction. If the president KNOWS he only needs 51 votes he may pick someone very extreme. I don't think ALL republicans want to use the nuclear option.They know we won't ALWAYS have a GOP president picking SC justices nor a majority GOP senate to confirm them. Its also baffling why McCaskill would say that then turn around next day and say she is an absolute no LOL
Makes no sense
If Republicans are willing to go nuclear now...why not do the same later?

Are Republicans willing to assure Dems that they will never go nuclear in the future if Dems only confirm Gorsuch?

Let bygones be bygones?


The racist party, the democrats, already showed that if they get blocked in the gaining of power they will do whatever it takes to get it...including ending the filibuster for judges......so if the republicans ever tried to use the filibuster to block a democrat supreme court pick...and the racist party had the votes, they would simply knock out the filibuster themselves...up to this point the idiot republicans have allowed every single anti American, left wing activist onto the court....so the democrats have never had to consider ending the filibuster....

Now...the Republicans have the chance to save the country and appoint actual justices to the court.....
So...seems we have one vote for ending filibuster and turning the Senate into a majority rules body

Yes.....that would be fine by me. Better to do it now, while republicans have control, than wait for the democrats to have control...since the democrats have already shown they will change the tradition if it gives them power.....I am tired of the Republicans playing by rules the democrats don't recognize.....
As a Republican...I can see why you want to take an advantage while you have it. Makes sense

For Republicans
Best case: Trump serves eight years, Republicans hold the Senate and fill the court 6-3 with young conservatives

For Democrats
Best case: Trump remains historically unpopular and scandal surrounds him. Republicans lose Senate in 2018 and White House in 2020. Gorsuch takes seat through nuclear option and other judges last through 2020.
Dems take White House from one term Trump and pack court through nuclear option


They would fill the court regardless of if they had the power....they would not let the filibuster by republicans stand in their way if they had the votes to stop it...they know how much power they can give the Supreme Court by packing it with anti-American, left wing justices....
 
They should STFU and get it done. Then they can lock themselves in their bathrooms and sob to their hearts content. Why in the hell should the rest of the country care how they react?

OK .....so that is what Republicans want

Just accept your beating and be thankful. So what happens the next time Democrats have a chance to make a liberal court........do they just treat the Republicans like nothing happened?

I'm a liberal and I'm letting you know right now...........the rest of us don't have time for a bunch of idiocy.
So as a liberal....you confirm Gorsuch and assume it will never happen again

As a liberal, not a Democrat, confirm Gorsuch and get on with it. If you insist in this nonsense then you will continue to piss off the American public.
The American public seems indifferent to filling Supreme Court vacancies
Otherwise there would have been political repercussions for leaving a seat vacant for over a year

Over 40% of the public identifies as independent. The public does think the SC and the lower court vacancies are a major issue.

Further, this one is an easy one.
 
1. Let bygones be bygones and vote on his qualifications
2. Admit the Republicans got one on you with Garland and move on
3. Retaliate for Republicans stealing the Garland seat and block the nomination
4. Declare war and refuse to fill any Republican SCOTUS nominations







.

Well, since Gorsuch would be filling a conservative seat in the SCOTUS (vacated by the "dearly" departed Scalia,) democrats should vote him in and hope that he is no worse than Rogers.

HOWEVER, should another seat be vacated, democrats should fight that nomination with fervor, especially since this upcoming midterm elections will strengthen the moderate/liberal cause.
 
Like Obama saud, If you want to have an impact, win elections

Perhaps........and when Obama won EIGHT years of the presidency, right wing low-life wanted for the eight year to NOT count........
See the difference? ................Maybe a grown-up can help you?
 
Only if the dems have the votes to stop the nomination .......as obama told the Republicans....elections have consequences....

True.....and Obama won EIGHT years of the presidency NOT seven.......
 
At this point, the Dems have no power anywhere and they would rather strut then get this shit done. They aren't liberals. They are unnecessary. Just kill the neoliberal beast and be done with it.
 
Makes no sense
If Republicans are willing to go nuclear now...why not do the same later?

Are Republicans willing to assure Dems that they will never go nuclear in the future if Dems only confirm Gorsuch?

Let bygones be bygones?


The racist party, the democrats, already showed that if they get blocked in the gaining of power they will do whatever it takes to get it...including ending the filibuster for judges......so if the republicans ever tried to use the filibuster to block a democrat supreme court pick...and the racist party had the votes, they would simply knock out the filibuster themselves...up to this point the idiot republicans have allowed every single anti American, left wing activist onto the court....so the democrats have never had to consider ending the filibuster....

Now...the Republicans have the chance to save the country and appoint actual justices to the court.....
So...seems we have one vote for ending filibuster and turning the Senate into a majority rules body

Yes.....that would be fine by me. Better to do it now, while republicans have control, than wait for the democrats to have control...since the democrats have already shown they will change the tradition if it gives them power.....I am tired of the Republicans playing by rules the democrats don't recognize.....
As a Republican...I can see why you want to take an advantage while you have it. Makes sense

For Republicans
Best case: Trump serves eight years, Republicans hold the Senate and fill the court 6-3 with young conservatives

For Democrats
Best case: Trump remains historically unpopular and scandal surrounds him. Republicans lose Senate in 2018 and White House in 2020. Gorsuch takes seat through nuclear option and other judges last through 2020.
Dems take White House from one term Trump and pack court through nuclear option


They would fill the court regardless of if they had the power....they would not let the filibuster by republicans stand in their way if they had the votes to stop it...they know how much power they can give the Supreme Court by packing it with anti-American, left wing justices....
As do the right

Looks like all out war
 
The racist party, the democrats, already showed that if they get blocked in the gaining of power they will do whatever it takes to get it...including ending the filibuster for judges......so if the republicans ever tried to use the filibuster to block a democrat supreme court pick...and the racist party had the votes, they would simply knock out the filibuster themselves...up to this point the idiot republicans have allowed every single anti American, left wing activist onto the court....so the democrats have never had to consider ending the filibuster....

Now...the Republicans have the chance to save the country and appoint actual justices to the court.....
So...seems we have one vote for ending filibuster and turning the Senate into a majority rules body

Yes.....that would be fine by me. Better to do it now, while republicans have control, than wait for the democrats to have control...since the democrats have already shown they will change the tradition if it gives them power.....I am tired of the Republicans playing by rules the democrats don't recognize.....
As a Republican...I can see why you want to take an advantage while you have it. Makes sense

For Republicans
Best case: Trump serves eight years, Republicans hold the Senate and fill the court 6-3 with young conservatives

For Democrats
Best case: Trump remains historically unpopular and scandal surrounds him. Republicans lose Senate in 2018 and White House in 2020. Gorsuch takes seat through nuclear option and other judges last through 2020.
Dems take White House from one term Trump and pack court through nuclear option


They would fill the court regardless of if they had the power....they would not let the filibuster by republicans stand in their way if they had the votes to stop it...they know how much power they can give the Supreme Court by packing it with anti-American, left wing justices....
As do the right

Looks like all out war


No....for decades the Republicans have allowed the democrats to get their way.....putting sotomayor and kagan on the court.....allowing Bork to be blocked......morons like mccain and graham have said the President should get his pick...even as the democrats did their best to block republican judges and justices....

The time for allowing democrats to do what they want is over.
 
They should vote against any and everything that comes from the Trump White House.

Right wingers made an "argument" that during the last year of a president, no SCOTUS nomination should be entertained......

Democrats are making an argument that when an administration is so thoroughly fucked up, no SCOTUS nominations should ALSO be entertained.....

Who is right and who is wrong?
 
They should vote against any and everything that comes from the Trump White House.

Right wingers made an "argument" that during the last year of a president, no SCOTUS nomination should be entertained......

Democrats are making an argument that when an administration is so thoroughly fucked up, no SCOTUS nominations should ALSO be entertained.....

Who is right and who is wrong?

The one with the votes....
 
They should vote against any and everything that comes from the Trump White House.

Right wingers made an "argument" that during the last year of a president, no SCOTUS nomination should be entertained......

Democrats are making an argument that when an administration is so thoroughly fucked up, no SCOTUS nominations should ALSO be entertained.....

Who is right and who is wrong?

The Dems. Who knows? This may be Trump's last year in office, so The Republican "logic" could work out.
 
1. Let bygones be bygones and vote on his qualifications
2. Admit the Republicans got one on you with Garland and move on
3. Retaliate for Republicans stealing the Garland seat and block the nomination
4. Declare war and refuse to fill any Republican SCOTUS nominations







.
Nominate this one block the next one. They got us. We got got.
 
Only if the dems have the votes to stop the nomination .......as obama told the Republicans....elections have consequences....

True.....and Obama won EIGHT years of the presidency NOT seven.......


No......the way it works is if you have the votes, you make the policy and the decisions.....when the dems had the votes they shoved obamacare down our throats even with over 60 percent of the country and not one republican supporting it...

so now that the Republicans have the votes...you think they should give democrats more power....

Fuck that bullshit....
 

Forum List

Back
Top