bripat9643
Diamond Member
- Apr 1, 2011
- 170,158
- 47,300
Not quite. You cited a report by the CDC that referenced a study by Gary Kleck. It made no evaluation of the validity of the study. Luckily others have evaluated it.The study I sited was conducted by the CDC, the government agency officially charged with compiling statistics about such things. You'll have to excuse us if we don't accept a study conducted at Harvard University. It wold be just as credible as an investigation of Hillary Clinton conducted by James Comey and Peter Strzok.
The Contradictions of the Kleck Study
In a 1992 survey, Gary Kleck, a Florida State University criminologist, found that there are 2.5 million defensive gun uses (DGU's) per year by “law-abiding” citizens in the United States. Another study from the same period, the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), estimated 65,000 DGUs annually. The NCVS survey differed from Kleck’s study in that it only interviewed those who reported a threatened, attempted, or completed victimization for one of six crimes: rape, robbery, assault, burglary, non-business larceny, and motor vehicle theft. That accounts for the discrepancy in the two results. A National Research Council report said that Kleck's estimates appeared to be exaggerated and that it was almost certain that "some of what respondents designate[d] as their own self-defense would be construed as aggression by others" (Understanding and Preventing Violence, 266, Albert J. Reiss, Jr. & Jeffrey A. Roth, eds., 1992).
Sorry, but that's just bullshit. You think everyone who chases off a burgler reports it to the police? I was robbed 7 times when I lived in Baltimore, but I never reported it to the police. Why not? Because it was a big hassle and the upshot would be that nothing was done.
Allow me to quote the CDC: The Institute of Medicine and the National Research Council released the results of their research through the CDC last month. Researchers compiled data from previous studies in order to guide future research on gun violence, noting that “almost all national survey estimates indicate that defensive gun uses by victims are at least as common as offensive uses by criminals, with estimates of annual uses ranging from about 500,000 to more than 3 million per year.”
You expect us to accept a study conducted by a couple of pinko Harvard professors over one performed by the CDC?
Sorry, but that dog won't hunt.