Divine Wind
Platinum Member
- Aug 2, 2011
- 20,640
- 5,568
Several thoughts.The problem is when you have terrorists working for foreign agencies that use our own domestic devices... So basically if companies give the government the ability to break the encryption, we have to then trust our government to only use it when it comes to terrorists and not just against its own civilians. We already know we can't always trust our government, given what has come out from Snowden and how the NSA tracks everyone even when you haven't done anything wrong to be tracked. So maybe its a good thing that companies aren't providing the government with that information?
I think another sad thing to realize is, some 14 year old kid in his parent's basement can hack things that people within the government can't.
1) Free and open societies are always more vulnerable than closed, highly secure AKA Police societies. During the Space Race, the US would broadcast all of our launches live. The world saw our failures and successes. The USSR always broadcast their launches after the launch so, by appearances, their success rate was 100%. During the late 60s airline hijackings, the world knew when a US airliner was hijacked (1st Amendment), not so with the USSR. In fact, it seemed their airliners were never hijacked. This same principle applies to every day life, freedom of movement, etc. It's in keeping with the Ben Franklin thoughts on Liberty and Security.
2) This last thought leads directly to the Patriot Act, the NSA and Snowden. It's not that the NSA abused their powers, it's that Americans screamed "SAVE US!" after 9/11 and the Patriot Act was lawfully passed by Congress. We gave up essential liberties for the illusion of greater security. While some increased security is more inconvenience than giving up liberty, there is always a danger of it crossing the line....especially if you are a Muslim-American.
3) Disagreed on the idea a 14-year old kid is smarter than the NSA. Sure, a really sharp kid might hack into the DMV or his school's grading system, but that's more about breaking simplistic passwords than a sophisticated cyber-assault.