Steinlight
VIP Member
- Jan 30, 2014
- 4,508
- 289
The fact that you can claim a dependent even if you are divorced doesn't mean that married couples can't claim dependents or child tax credit, one doesn't negate the other. This is what you don't seem to understand. And honestly, I can't fix your stupidity here. The dependent claim, the child tax credit, is the incentive to have children, you couldn't get it without having children. This is simple stuff.You just said when the mother and father are separated, again!Now you are changing the goal posts and being dishonest. I am talking about married couples, not divorced couples. I am saying the tax structure incentivizes married couples to have children. Married couples, both father and mother, can claim the child as a dependent.The tax break incentivizes procreation within marriage is what I mean. It is true, one parent can claim the child as the dependent and the other parent theoretically couldn't, but the system incentivizes both parents to claim the child as a dependent to get more tax credits..
No.
You are just wrong.
You can only claim a child as a dependent once. If the mother and father are separated, only one gets to claim the child as a dependent.
Marriage- as it is currently- does not 'incentivize' having children at all. I could come up with ways to make marriage incentivize having children- for instance married couples with children could get cash bonuses from the State that unmarried parents of children don't get- but that has never been done.
I didn't mention divorce or move any goal posts.
As I said:
You are just wrong.
You can only claim a child as a dependent once. If the mother and father are separated, only one gets to claim the child as a dependent.
Marriage- as it is currently- does not 'incentivize' having children at all. I could come up with ways to make marriage incentivize having children- for instance married couples with children could get cash bonuses from the State that unmarried parents of children don't get- but that has never been done
Sorry, you are simply wrong, dependent exemptions and for that matter child tax credits are given, whether the married couples, whether they file jointly, with a single head of household, or the mother and father do so on separate forms. In this way they incentivize married couples to have children.
Even if they didn't, they should, as it is smart policy.
I am pointing out that parents get the same credit for a dependent whether they are married- even if they are seperated. We only get to claim claim our dependents on one tax return.
There is no tax incentive for me to have children.
I agree that marriage helps protect my child and I would always prefer parents do marry.
Which is why I think you are wrong when you want to deny marriage to the children of gay couples.
I would have preferred you didn't have kids. Hopefully your child can overcome the fact their father is a stupid, morally relativist, weak, feminine, faggot, but I don't like the odds.