Wry Catcher
Diamond Member
- Aug 3, 2009
- 51,322
- 6,470
You seem quite reluctant to answer the following two questions:We have an express naturalization clause. You simply are lousy at capitalism with a Commerce Clause.You didn't answer this question:Naturalization is not immigration. We should have no illegals or illegal underclass.The Founders didn't write the Constitution, the Framers did.I know what our Founding Fathers expressed, not implied.
Article I, Section 8 authorizes Congress, “To establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization.” From a Constitutional stand point it is the responsibility of Congress to establish all laws and rules of naturalization or immigration.
The 14th Amendment states that , “All persons born or naturalized in the United States,” are, “citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”
The 14th Amendment supports that the intent of the Framers was that only citizens of the United States whether born or naturalized are granted the rights and privileges that are available in America.
While Congress has the Constitutional authority to establish laws of naturalization or immigration they do not have a true Constitutional authority to create blanket legislation that allows non – citizens the rights of born or naturalized Americans.
Are you arguing that non-citizens have the rights of natural born or naturalized Americans?
Birth gives Americans the right of citizenship but to those who immigrate citizenship must be given by the rule of law. The Framers made it very clear that the law must first be satisfied before the rights of citizenship are available.
The Framers understood the necessity of keeping our identity as Americans and in establishing a uniform rule of law for gaining citizenship in America, automatic for the natural born, bestowed by law on the naturalized.
i) Are you arguing that non-citizens have the rights of natural born or naturalized Americans?
Or this one:
ii) Are you arguing that unlike every other nation on the face of the earth, that the US does not have the right to control who enters our country?
The American hating Left fools no one. They want to stop even even our feeble enforcement of the border, make illegal immigration not illegal, never send illegals home once they get here and – think about this – take our tax money to give these foreigners who shouldn’t even be here in the first place better free health care than our vets get? I'm sure that will go well in places like Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania. Why I'm certain that construction workers at a diner near Pittsburg are known to say:
“It really bugs me, Lou and Joe here that those people coming into the country illegally aren’t getting free heath care on our dime. We all want to work an extra shift so we can give it to ‘em. We need a president who finally puts foreigners first! Also, we all agree we ought to give up our deer rifles because people in Cory Booker’s neighborhood can’t stop shooting each other.”Well, Trump Just Won in 2020
i) Are you arguing that non-citizens have the rights of natural born or naturalized Americans?
Or this one:
ii) Are you arguing that unlike every other nation on the face of the earth, that the US does not have the right to control who enters our country?
i] non-citizens have the rights enumerated in the Bill of Rights, they do not have the right to vote in a General Election or secure a job unless they have the proper visa;
ii] No one argues that, only Donald Trump and the fools who echo his lies make that claim. We have borders which are not secure, the argument and chaos today is trump wants to wall the entire southern border, and not accept the rational plan to secure our coasts, ports, airports and northern border with technology too.