Redfish
Diamond Member
Count Jindal unpersuaded: Repeal and replace Obamacare
In his plan, Jindal calls for:
Providing $100 billion over 10 years to provide grants to states that take innovative steps on health care, including guaranteeing access to insurance for people with preexisting conditions. The Affordable Care Act bars insurers from discriminating against those with medical problems that often have made getting coverage difficult. Why can't this be done in addition to Obama care? If you want to provide additional money to the states for innovative healthcare.....do it. Nothing in Obamacare prevents this
Creating a standard individual deduction for health insurance for individuals whether they are covered through their employers or on their own.
Want a standard individual deduction for health insurance? Do it. Nothing in Obamacare prevents this
Instituting a permanent ban on federal funding of health insurance plans that cover abortions.
Unconstitutional
The plan calls for increased state flexibility on Medicaid, expanded health savings accounts, additional price and quality disclosures by hospitals and other health care providers, and new limits on lawsuits.
Obamacare already provides increased state flexibility on Medicaid. Health savings accounts can be expanded under Obamacare, so can requiring more disclosure. If Republicans want tort reform...pass it
Nothing in this plan makes it necessary to repeal Obamacare
Creating a standard individual deduction for health insurance for individuals whether they are covered through their employers or on their own.
Want a standard individual deduction for health insurance? Do it. Nothing in Obamacare prevents this
Fair enough, then ask yourself a very obvious question. If this is a good thing then why it not already in Obamacare? Me thinks you smart enough to know why but I am not sure you will admit it. To sell the bill to the moderate democrats Obamacare had to pay for itself. That is why how many young people sign up is so important. If they don't, or they got their figures wrong, then the thing does not pay for itself. Thus we either do the unpatriotic thing and use our Chinese credit card or cut somewhere else.
So, in order to pay for itself you can not take money in one hand and hand it back in another and say that makes any sense at all. There will be no tax credits for the middle class for Obamacare. If there are it will be an even bigger financial disaster.
Nobody ever claimed Obamacare to be the final solution. Obama has always said that if you could make it better, do it
Republicans have had 50 Repeal Obamacare bills...they have yet to pass one to improve it
repealing it would be an improvement, but we agree that there needs to be a replacement bill that would actually fix some of the problems with medical care, not create more problems as ACA has done.
When the GOP takes the senate and holds the house in November, you will see some action to fix the mess. then obama will have a choice, either sign the bills to fix his mess or veto them in arrogance--------------any idea which way he will go?