Soggy in NOLA
Diamond Member
- Jul 31, 2009
- 40,565
- 5,359
The courts decide what is or isn't constitutional. The President, or a Governor, can tell their AG don't bother defending this one, it's probably unconstitutional. It;' good money after bad and there is no requirement that bad laws be defended by the government. Another party can, if they have standing, defend the law just without the government's help. It's a judgment call and it's entirely legal. Learn how the government works please.He takes an oath to defend the Constitution not to defend probably unconstitutional laws in the courts. In this case that would have just been a waste of time and money. Everyone with a brain knew that POS was going down. It was very obviously unconstitutional.The POTUS takes an oath to uphold the laws and defend the constitution.... not just the ones he agrees with.
Probable constitutionality is not his call, that is the call of the courts. Why then can't Judge Moore decide that gay marriage is probably unconstitutional and as such, refuse to marry gay couples?
And again, I am not defending Judge Moore.. he needs to perform hist duties as prescribed by the law.
I am aware how the government works; presidents do not decide constitutionality of laws. You are the one that needs a basic civics lesson. So then, you'd be fine with a President deciding on his own that a law, any law, pick one you really like, say, Obamacare, is probably unconstitutional therefore don't enforce it?