Is the knowledge of good and evil, good or evil?

[ding]

1. Everything God created is good.
1a. Therefore, man has an inclination for good.
1b. Therefore, evil is not extant.
1c. Therefore, evil is the absence of good.
2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Same argument Moses ben Maimon made.

 

[rylah]

And a week later he will be making the argument that everything God created is good so it isn't possible that God created evil.

No I will still be making the same argument you can't address.

About G-d giving the man the ability to do evil,
as function of freedom of choice.

You'll still be ducking.

I love how you changed your argument.

Problem is Moses ben Maimon said that everything God made is good. You say God gave man an evil inclination.

Maimonides says otherwise?
You really don't grasp the full extent of what he says.

Instead of grasp at straws, try reading book

You know a revolutionary idea...

 

[ding]

And a week later he will be making the argument that everything God created is good so it isn't possible that God created evil.

No I will still be making the same argument you can't address.

About G-d giving the man the ability to do evil,
as function of freedom of choice.

You'll still be ducking.

I love how you changed your argument.

Problem is Moses ben Maimon said that everything God made is good. You say God gave man an evil inclination.

Maimonides says otherwise?
You really don't grasp the full extent of what he says.

Instead of grasp at straws, try reading book

You know a revolutionary idea...

You are hopeless.

I predict many predictable surprises in your life.

 

[rylah]

1. Everything God created is good.
1a. Therefore, man has an inclination for good.
1b. Therefore, evil is not extant.
1c. Therefore, evil is the absence of good.
2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Same argument Moses ben Maimon made.

No he didn't.

But do try to back up every claim with a quote.

I'll wait for your answer.

Won't hold my breath though.

 

[rylah]

And a week later he will be making the argument that everything God created is good so it isn't possible that God created evil.

No I will still be making the same argument you can't address.

About G-d giving the man the ability to do evil,
as function of freedom of choice.

You'll still be ducking.

I love how you changed your argument.

Problem is Moses ben Maimon said that everything God made is good. You say God gave man an evil inclination.

Maimonides says otherwise?
You really don't grasp the full extent of what he says.

Instead of grasp at straws, try reading book

You know a revolutionary idea...

You are hopeless.

I predict many predictable surprises in your life.

Oh you've been raised to prophecy...

Doctors notified?

 

[ding]

1. Everything God created is good.
1a. Therefore, man has an inclination for good.
1b. Therefore, evil is not extant.
1c. Therefore, evil is the absence of good.
2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Same argument Moses ben Maimon made.

No he didn't.

But do try to back up every claim with a quote.

I'll wait for your answer.

Won't hold my breath though.

You are the male version of Hollie

 

[rylah]

1. Everything God created is good.
1a. Therefore, man has an inclination for good.
1b. Therefore, evil is not extant.
1c. Therefore, evil is the absence of good.
2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Same argument Moses ben Maimon made.

No he didn't.

But do try to back up every claim with a quote.

I'll wait for your answer.

Won't hold my breath though.

You are the male version of Hollie

Is that an argument for "man can do no evil"?

'Cmon you can do better.

 

[rylah]

If as you claimed Rambam was arguing your points,
it should have been easier to just quote him,
than all this mindless chest thumping.

Try to change my mind, but don't bs me.

 

[rylah]

2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Ok,
tell me,
who posted the following?

From MOSES MAIMONIDES, THE GUIDE FOR THE PERPLEXED
Part 3, Chapter XII, Titled "Three Kinds of Evil; 1 Caused by the Nature of Man, 2 Caused by Man to Man, 3 Caused by Man to Himself"

Do I need to explain again...
how this contradicts your denial of man's ability to do evil?

 

[ding]

And a week later he will be making the argument that everything God created is good so it isn't possible that God created evil.

No I will still be making the same argument you can't address.

About G-d giving the man the ability to do evil,
as function of freedom of choice.

You'll still be ducking.

I love how you changed your argument.

Problem is Moses ben Maimon said that everything God made is good. You say God gave man an evil inclination.

Maimonides says otherwise?
You really don't grasp the full extent of what he says.

Instead of grasp at straws, try reading book

You know a revolutionary idea...

You are hopeless.

I predict many predictable surprises in your life.

Oh you've been raised to prophecy...

Doctors notified?

It doesn't take a prophet to predict what will happen to people who are dishonest, ignorant and have over-inflated egos.

 

[ding]

2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Ok,
tell me,
who posted the following?

From MOSES MAIMONIDES, THE GUIDE FOR THE PERPLEXED
Part 3, Chapter XII, Titled "Three Kinds of Evil; 1 Caused by the Nature of Man, 2 Caused by Man to Man, 3 Caused by Man to Himself"

Do I need to explain again...
how this contradicts your denial of man's ability to do evil?

By next week you will be using what I have taught you.

 

[rylah]

And a week later he will be making the argument that everything God created is good so it isn't possible that God created evil.

No I will still be making the same argument you can't address.

About G-d giving the man the ability to do evil,
as function of freedom of choice.

You'll still be ducking.

I love how you changed your argument.

Problem is Moses ben Maimon said that everything God made is good. You say God gave man an evil inclination.

Maimonides says otherwise?
You really don't grasp the full extent of what he says.

Instead of grasp at straws, try reading book

You know a revolutionary idea...

You are hopeless.

I predict many predictable surprises in your life.

Oh you've been raised to prophecy...

Doctors notified?

It doesn't take a prophet to predict what will happen to people who are dishonest, ignorant and have over-inflated egos.

Thank you,
I'll note that in my quarterly customer review.

One question though - heard about projecting?

 

[rylah]

2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Ok,
tell me,
who posted the following?

From MOSES MAIMONIDES, THE GUIDE FOR THE PERPLEXED
Part 3, Chapter XII, Titled "Three Kinds of Evil; 1 Caused by the Nature of Man, 2 Caused by Man to Man, 3 Caused by Man to Himself"

Do I need to explain again...
how this contradicts your denial of man's ability to do evil?

By next week you will be using what I have taught you.

You have taught me the meaning of the phrase "Satan's biggest lie is that he doesn't exist".

And the kind of archetype that during the Inquisition,
allowed the lowest wicked filth to feel not only that they act most righteously,
but that they are even absolved of doing anything but good.

Kinda like the most outspokenly "anti-racist" folks today,
are the worst banal kind of racists in the most vulgar manner.

 

[ding]

And a week later he will be making the argument that everything God created is good so it isn't possible that God created evil.

No I will still be making the same argument you can't address.

About G-d giving the man the ability to do evil,
as function of freedom of choice.

You'll still be ducking.

I love how you changed your argument.

Problem is Moses ben Maimon said that everything God made is good. You say God gave man an evil inclination.

Maimonides says otherwise?
You really don't grasp the full extent of what he says.

Instead of grasp at straws, try reading book

You know a revolutionary idea...

You are hopeless.

I predict many predictable surprises in your life.

Oh you've been raised to prophecy...

Doctors notified?

It doesn't take a prophet to predict what will happen to people who are dishonest, ignorant and have over-inflated egos.

Thank you,
I'll note that in my quarterly customer review.

One though question - heard about projecting?

tick, tick, tick, tick, tick...

 

[ding]

2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Ok,
tell me,
who posted the following?

From MOSES MAIMONIDES, THE GUIDE FOR THE PERPLEXED
Part 3, Chapter XII, Titled "Three Kinds of Evil; 1 Caused by the Nature of Man, 2 Caused by Man to Man, 3 Caused by Man to Himself"

Do I need to explain again...
how this contradicts your denial of man's ability to do evil?

By next week you will be using what I have taught you.

You have taught me the meaning of the phrase "Satan's biggest lie is that he doesn't exist".

And the kind of archetype that during the Inquisition,
allowed the lowest wicked filth to feel not only that they act most righteously,
but that they are even absolved of doing anything but good.

Kinda like the most outspokenly "anti-racist" folks today,
are the worst banal kind of racists in the most vulgar manner.

I look forward to you using what you learned from me.

 

[rylah]

2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Ok,
tell me,
who posted the following?

From MOSES MAIMONIDES, THE GUIDE FOR THE PERPLEXED
Part 3, Chapter XII, Titled "Three Kinds of Evil; 1 Caused by the Nature of Man, 2 Caused by Man to Man, 3 Caused by Man to Himself"

Do I need to explain again...
how this contradicts your denial of man's ability to do evil?

By next week you will be using what I have taught you.

You have taught me the meaning of the phrase "Satan's biggest lie is that he doesn't exist".

And the kind of archetype that during the Inquisition,
allowed the lowest wicked filth to feel not only that they act most righteously,
but that they are even absolved of doing anything but good.

Kinda like the most outspokenly "anti-racist" folks today,
are the worst banal kind of racists in the most vulgar manner.

I look forward to you using what you learned from me.

The "teacher" didn't get the parallels?
Strange they say schools are so bad in the US.

Read Maimonides, then try Kozari,
it's great material, outstandingly well written, precise and clear language.

A must if you're interested in this kind of subject in whole, which seems you are.

 

[ding]

2. Man has free will to choose doing good or to choose not doing good.

Ok,
tell me,
who posted the following?

From MOSES MAIMONIDES, THE GUIDE FOR THE PERPLEXED
Part 3, Chapter XII, Titled "Three Kinds of Evil; 1 Caused by the Nature of Man, 2 Caused by Man to Man, 3 Caused by Man to Himself"

Do I need to explain again...
how this contradicts your denial of man's ability to do evil?

By next week you will be using what I have taught you.

You have taught me the meaning of the phrase "Satan's biggest lie is that he doesn't exist".

And the kind of archetype that during the Inquisition,
allowed the lowest wicked filth to feel not only that they act most righteously,
but that they are even absolved of doing anything but good.

Kinda like the most outspokenly "anti-racist" folks today,
are the worst banal kind of racists in the most vulgar manner.

I look forward to you using what you learned from me.

The "teacher" didn't get the parallels?
Strange they say schools are so bad in the US.

Read Maimonides, then try Kozari,
it's great material, outstandingly well written, precise and clear language.

A must if you're interested in this kind of subject in whole, which seems you are.

You got caught lying. The question is... are you a liar.

 

[zaangalewa]

... There is no absolute right and wrong. ...

Good is everything what helps all and every life.

Your opinion

Then you know now, what I expect from you.

 

[zaangalewa]

... There is no logic if there is no human mind to create it. ...

 

[zaangalewa]

... I find it amazing that any Jew could believe that God was responsible or capable of creating evil.

God created everything. Your theory the absence of god (whatever this could be, because nothing is without god) creates evil, is not plausible. Again: When someone kills someone else then there are many factors in this "game". For example a weapon has to be produced, transported, dealed, sold, bought ... - a situation has to be created - a meeting arranged - and so on and so on - and then someone kills someone with a bullet. Nowhere is any absence of anything - except the absence of the respect for life. The whole evil system is wrongdoing - and not absence.

And again. God created the devil. And he knew before he created the devil what will happen. He knew also what Eve and her children will do. And so on.