The Official Discussion Thread for who is considered indiginous to Palestine?

[Shusha]

Your problem is that you have the racist view that "one people" should have sovereignty. Palestine had been a mult-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic place for centuries. To say that one group is superior and run the show for their own benefit is the root of the problem.

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government. There are currently nearly 200 countries in the world and nearly all of them are based on the sovereignty of a specific peoples. And more people - like the Catalans - are working toward it. Surely, you are not suggesting they are ALL racist and believe themselves superior. Surely you are not suggesting they ALL be dismantled.

You just keep confirming that the root of the problem is antisemitism. It's a fundamental belief that it's fine for the Catalans or the Tibetans or the Jordanians to have a nation but not for the Jews.

And "Palestine" IS multi-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic in all of the places under Jewish sovereignty. ONLY in the places of Jewish sovereignty. In the places under Arab sovereignty there is only one ethnicity and for the most part one religion. So your comments should actually be directed to the PA, Hamas and Jordan.

If you want to address racist views why don't you start with the simple act of demanding ALL people have access to holy places?

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government.

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Your problem is that you have the racist view that "one people" should have sovereignty. Palestine had been a mult-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic place for centuries. To say that one group is superior and run the show for their own benefit is the root of the problem.

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government. There are currently nearly 200 countries in the world and nearly all of them are based on the sovereignty of a specific peoples. And more people - like the Catalans - are working toward it. Surely, you are not suggesting they are ALL racist and believe themselves superior. Surely you are not suggesting they ALL be dismantled.

You just keep confirming that the root of the problem is antisemitism. It's a fundamental belief that it's fine for the Catalans or the Tibetans or the Jordanians to have a nation but not for the Jews.

And "Palestine" IS multi-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic in all of the places under Jewish sovereignty. ONLY in the places of Jewish sovereignty. In the places under Arab sovereignty there is only one ethnicity and for the most part one religion. So your comments should actually be directed to the PA, Hamas and Jordan.

If you want to address racist views why don't you start with the simple act of demanding ALL people have access to holy places?

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government.

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

But not in their homeland.

 

[JoelT1]

View attachment 160796

Your problem is that you have the racist view that "one people" should have sovereignty. Palestine had been a mult-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic place for centuries. To say that one group is superior and run the show for their own benefit is the root of the problem.

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government. There are currently nearly 200 countries in the world and nearly all of them are based on the sovereignty of a specific peoples. And more people - like the Catalans - are working toward it. Surely, you are not suggesting they are ALL racist and believe themselves superior. Surely you are not suggesting they ALL be dismantled.

You just keep confirming that the root of the problem is antisemitism. It's a fundamental belief that it's fine for the Catalans or the Tibetans or the Jordanians to have a nation but not for the Jews.

And "Palestine" IS multi-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic in all of the places under Jewish sovereignty. ONLY in the places of Jewish sovereignty. In the places under Arab sovereignty there is only one ethnicity and for the most part one religion. So your comments should actually be directed to the PA, Hamas and Jordan.

If you want to address racist views why don't you start with the simple act of demanding ALL people have access to holy places?

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government.

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews, the indigenous population, about 2000 years ago. No such things as palestinians

 

[JoelT1]

Your problem is that you have the racist view that "one people" should have sovereignty. Palestine had been a mult-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic place for centuries. To say that one group is superior and run the show for their own benefit is the root of the problem.

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government. There are currently nearly 200 countries in the world and nearly all of them are based on the sovereignty of a specific peoples. And more people - like the Catalans - are working toward it. Surely, you are not suggesting they are ALL racist and believe themselves superior. Surely you are not suggesting they ALL be dismantled.

You just keep confirming that the root of the problem is antisemitism. It's a fundamental belief that it's fine for the Catalans or the Tibetans or the Jordanians to have a nation but not for the Jews.

And "Palestine" IS multi-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic in all of the places under Jewish sovereignty. ONLY in the places of Jewish sovereignty. In the places under Arab sovereignty there is only one ethnicity and for the most part one religion. So your comments should actually be directed to the PA, Hamas and Jordan.

If you want to address racist views why don't you start with the simple act of demanding ALL people have access to holy places?

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government.

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

But not in their homeland.

Jews were originally called palestinians, by the British who made up the word. No such things as palestinians

 

[JoelT1]

Your problem is that you have the racist view that "one people" should have sovereignty. Palestine had been a mult-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic place for centuries. To say that one group is superior and run the show for their own benefit is the root of the problem.

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government. There are currently nearly 200 countries in the world and nearly all of them are based on the sovereignty of a specific peoples. And more people - like the Catalans - are working toward it. Surely, you are not suggesting they are ALL racist and believe themselves superior. Surely you are not suggesting they ALL be dismantled.

You just keep confirming that the root of the problem is antisemitism. It's a fundamental belief that it's fine for the Catalans or the Tibetans or the Jordanians to have a nation but not for the Jews.

And "Palestine" IS multi-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic in all of the places under Jewish sovereignty. ONLY in the places of Jewish sovereignty. In the places under Arab sovereignty there is only one ethnicity and for the most part one religion. So your comments should actually be directed to the PA, Hamas and Jordan.

If you want to address racist views why don't you start with the simple act of demanding ALL people have access to holy places?

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government.

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

But not in their homeland.

Israel is, of course, Jews’ Homeland. Ever hear of a Jewish rabbi named Jesus? His synagogue in Israel Israeli Archeologists Discover "Jesus' Synagogue"

 

[JoelT1]

Your problem is that you have the racist view that "one people" should have sovereignty. Palestine had been a mult-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic place for centuries. To say that one group is superior and run the show for their own benefit is the root of the problem.

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government. There are currently nearly 200 countries in the world and nearly all of them are based on the sovereignty of a specific peoples. And more people - like the Catalans - are working toward it. Surely, you are not suggesting they are ALL racist and believe themselves superior. Surely you are not suggesting they ALL be dismantled.

You just keep confirming that the root of the problem is antisemitism. It's a fundamental belief that it's fine for the Catalans or the Tibetans or the Jordanians to have a nation but not for the Jews.

And "Palestine" IS multi-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic in all of the places under Jewish sovereignty. ONLY in the places of Jewish sovereignty. In the places under Arab sovereignty there is only one ethnicity and for the most part one religion. So your comments should actually be directed to the PA, Hamas and Jordan.

If you want to address racist views why don't you start with the simple act of demanding ALL people have access to holy places?

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government.

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

But not in their homeland.

Anyone with a functioning brain knows that (Saudi) Arabia is Arabs’ homeland.

 

[Shusha]

But not in their homeland.

Of course in their homeland. I'm not suggesting Poland.

 

[ForeverYoung436]

Your problem is that you have the racist view that "one people" should have sovereignty. Palestine had been a mult-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic place for centuries. To say that one group is superior and run the show for their own benefit is the root of the problem.

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government. There are currently nearly 200 countries in the world and nearly all of them are based on the sovereignty of a specific peoples. And more people - like the Catalans - are working toward it. Surely, you are not suggesting they are ALL racist and believe themselves superior. Surely you are not suggesting they ALL be dismantled.

You just keep confirming that the root of the problem is antisemitism. It's a fundamental belief that it's fine for the Catalans or the Tibetans or the Jordanians to have a nation but not for the Jews.

And "Palestine" IS multi-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic in all of the places under Jewish sovereignty. ONLY in the places of Jewish sovereignty. In the places under Arab sovereignty there is only one ethnicity and for the most part one religion. So your comments should actually be directed to the PA, Hamas and Jordan.

If you want to address racist views why don't you start with the simple act of demanding ALL people have access to holy places?

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government.

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

But not in their homeland.

Anyone with a functioning brain knows that (Saudi) Arabia is Arabs’ homeland.

They have 22 or 23 homelands. How many homelands do the Arabs need?

 

[JoelT1]

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government. There are currently nearly 200 countries in the world and nearly all of them are based on the sovereignty of a specific peoples. And more people - like the Catalans - are working toward it. Surely, you are not suggesting they are ALL racist and believe themselves superior. Surely you are not suggesting they ALL be dismantled.

You just keep confirming that the root of the problem is antisemitism. It's a fundamental belief that it's fine for the Catalans or the Tibetans or the Jordanians to have a nation but not for the Jews.

And "Palestine" IS multi-racial, multi-religious, multi-ethnic in all of the places under Jewish sovereignty. ONLY in the places of Jewish sovereignty. In the places under Arab sovereignty there is only one ethnicity and for the most part one religion. So your comments should actually be directed to the PA, Hamas and Jordan.

If you want to address racist views why don't you start with the simple act of demanding ALL people have access to holy places?

I hold a view that all peoples who wish it should have sovereignty, self-determination and independence. It's NORMAL. It is the basis for our world's system of government.

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

But not in their homeland.

Anyone with a functioning brain knows that (Saudi) Arabia is Arabs’ homeland.

They have 22 or 23 homelands. How many homelands do the Arabs need?

Arab palestine? No p in Arabic

 

[ForeverYoung436]

Except for the Palestinians. They got the boot.

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

But not in their homeland.

Anyone with a functioning brain knows that (Saudi) Arabia is Arabs’ homeland.

They have 22 or 23 homelands. How many homelands do the Arabs need?

Arab palestine? No p in Arabic

They can't even pronounce the name of what they claim is their own country! How fake is that?

 

[P F Tinmore]

But not in their homeland.

Of course in their homeland. I'm not suggesting Poland.

You are not suggesting Jaffa.

 

[Sixties Fan]

But not in their homeland.

Of course in their homeland. I'm not suggesting Poland.

You are not suggesting Jaffa.

ALL of Israel.
Feel free to return to where your ancestors came from.
I won't mind

 

[ForeverYoung436]

But not in their homeland.

Of course in their homeland. I'm not suggesting Poland.

You are not suggesting Jaffa.

ALL of Israel.
Feel free to return to where your ancestors came from.
I won't mind

Do you mean they should return to Arabia? I agree. Arabs to Arabia, and Jews to Judea.

 

[Shusha]

You are not suggesting Jaffa.

Where exactly do you think I am suggesting?

 

[P F Tinmore]

You are not suggesting Jaffa.

Where exactly do you think I am suggesting?

Are you suggesting that the Palestinians return to their homes?

 

[JoelT1]

You know I support Arab Palestine as well as Israel.

But not in their homeland.

Anyone with a functioning brain knows that (Saudi) Arabia is Arabs’ homeland.

They have 22 or 23 homelands. How many homelands do the Arabs need?

Arab palestine? No p in Arabic

Palestine referred to ancient Philistines, who were Greek. Maybe, Arabs descend from Gr

They can't even pronounce the name of what they claim is their own country! How fake is that?

You are not suggesting Jaffa.

Where exactly do you think I am suggesting?

Are you suggesting that the Palestinians return to their homes?

Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews, about 2000 years ago. So, Jews are really palestinians and palestine is Jews’ home

 

[Sixties Fan]

You are not suggesting Jaffa.

Where exactly do you think I am suggesting?

Are you suggesting that the Palestinians return to their homes?

The ARAB Palestinians keep demanding that the Jews return to where they came from.
The Jews have returned to where they came from.

Now....is the time for the Arabs, Palestinians or otherwise, to follow their own advise and RETURN to where THEY came from.

ARABIA

 

[JoelT1]

You are not suggesting Jaffa.

Where exactly do you think I am suggesting?

Are you suggesting that the Palestinians return to their homes?

Um, Arabs’ homeland is (Saudi) Arabia, not Israel Homeland of the Jewish People

Anyone with a functioning brain knows these basic facts

 

[jamesduncan]

.,.,.,Prove Jordan has land. Or France.

Before entering the Land of Oz; I ask you, Shusha--- Show readers a map of "Israel" prior to 1947ad.
.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,

-

 

[JoelT1]

.,.,.,Prove Jordan has land. Or France.

Before entering the Land of Oz; I ask you, Shusha--- Show readers a map of "Israel" prior to 1947ad.
.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,.,.,.,waiting.,.,.waiting.,,..,.,.waiting.,.,..,.,

-

Ancient Israel verified by archaeology The Mesha Stele | Louvre Museum | Paris

Palestine never existed