The Official Discussion Thread for who is considered indiginous to Palestine?

[rylah]

There were no Palestinians?

The society was founded on 31 March 1805, with its first meeting of 13 members taking place on 24 April 1805, at which it was decided with no further explanation that the Syrian Society "shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"
Palestine Association - Wikipedia

1805... Hmmmm?

From Your link:

The Palestine Association, formerly the Syrian Society, was formed in 1805 by William Richard Hamilton to promote the study of the geography, natural history, antiquities and anthropology of Palestine and the surrounding areas.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Again conflating a geographic area with a non-existent people.

 

[abi]

Yes, and 1805, long before zionism, they changed their name to reflect the reality.

"shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"

 

[rylah]

Yes, and 1805, long before zionism, they changed their name to reflect the reality.

"shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"

Yes it was British association, if You ever care to read Your own link.
You have no more knowledge than that young brainwashed child.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

There were no Palestinians?

The society was founded on 31 March 1805, with its first meeting of 13 members taking place on 24 April 1805, at which it was decided with no further explanation that the Syrian Society "shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"
Palestine Association - Wikipedia

1805... Hmmmm?

Look at all the Muslim founders.........

 

[abi]

Yes, and 1805, long before zionism, they changed their name to reflect the reality.

"shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"

Yes it was British association, if You ever care to read Your own link.
You have no more knowledge than this young brainwashed child.

What part of 1805, long before zionism, they changed their name to reflect the reality are you stumbling over?

"shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"

 

[rylah]

Yes, and 1805, long before zionism, they changed their name to reflect the reality.

"shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"

Yes it was British association, if You ever care to read Your own link.
You have no more knowledge than this young brainwashed child.

What part of 1805, long before zionism, they changed their name to reflect the reality are you stumbling over?

"shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"

What part of - goegraphy, British organization, and no Arabs - don't You understand.

What part of Arabs declaring they're Syrians don't You understand?

 

[abi]

In 1805, they admitted it in their declaration:
"shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"

Can you relate? LOL, sorry, but look what you are doing here.

 

[rylah]

In 1805, they admitted it in their declaration:
"shall henceforth be denominated The Palestine Association"

Can you relate? LOL, sorry, but look what you are doing here.

They were British, the organization was British.
Arabs started calling themselves "Palestinians" only 160 years after that, and some 50 years after they officially proclaimed to be Syrian Nationals.

 

[Shusha]

There is a Pacific Northwest Association of Pathologists. That doesn't mean that the Pacific Northwest is a sovereign nation. Its just a geographical term.

 

[GHook93]

She is probably a stupid twat just like you


Sent from my iPhone using USMessageBoard.com

 

[GHook93]

This is how women are treated in Islam


Sent from my iPhone using USMessageBoard.com

 

[fanger]

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

But her ankle was visible. Allah says she should be raped.

 

[fanger]

You hear voices?

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

You hear voices?

Allah, speaking to the faithful......

 

[abi]

Palestine (now called Israel) is the homeland for the Jewish people

Then who built the wall that Joshua and his people brought down by blowing their trumpets? I will give you a hint. They were not Jews!

 

[Shusha]

Palestine (now called Israel) is the homeland for the Jewish people

Then who built the wall that Joshua and his people brought down by blowing their trumpets? I will give you a hint. They were not Jews!

Now, now. What ever happened to not bringing up biblical stories as historical documents? Play by your own rules, now.

 

[abi]

Now, now. What ever happened to not bringing up biblical stories as historical documents? Play by your own rules, now.

Fair, but the historical evidence that other people were there first is undeniable. I'm pretty sure, if you were to be honest, you would admit this.

 

[Shusha]

Now, now. What ever happened to not bringing up biblical stories as historical documents? Play by your own rules, now.

Fair, but the historical evidence that other people were there first is undeniable. I'm pretty sure, if you were to be honest, you would admit this.

If those "other people" showed up, I would gladly give them a piece of the territory. (Though that is unlikely given that they were proto-Jews).

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

This claim I have seen so oft-repeated appears to be simply that. It is a claim that was popularized in a propaganda video put out by Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs. As a bonus, another young lady comes on to explain the claim that the six day war was fought in self defense. It is only six minutes long and I would love the opportunity for academic discussion of these topics. For example, if something is factually incorrect, please state why, and post a source for the correction. Thanks in advance for any help.

Can she tell us why there were no Americans in 1500?

Good question. What were native Americans called before it was America? Were they a different people? Did they just not exist?

Mohawks, Sioux, Cherokee, Shawnee, Navaho, Utes, Seminoles, etc. etc.