The OLDER Official Discussion Thread for the creation of Israel, the UN and the British Mandate

[theliq]

By every historical account, the Zionist revolution – the incredible ingathering of the exiles and the establishment of the flourishing and highly successful state of Israel – is a unique and unprecedented phenomenon. Those who insist on viewing it as yet another immigration wave among the 20th century global population movements fail to grasp the real nature of this revolution. In this respect, Abbas touched the key issue that, in his eyes, made the Palestinians the main victim of Zionism: if the Jews yearn for a safe haven, and the international community wants to provide them with one, why does it have to be in Palestine, at the Palestinians’ expense?

Of all the leaders of the Zionist movement, it was Israel’s founding father, David Ben-Gurion, who dealt most extensively with the kinds of claims made by Abbas. Below are several passages from Abbas’s address followed by statements by Ben-Gurion on the same topic.

(full article online)

Mahmoud Abbas’s Speech: Who Was the Real Audience?

The important point here is that the Balfour Declaration did not GRANT the Jewish people anything. It merely recognized the EXISTING rights of the Jewish people as an indigenous peoples with an historical connection to the land which was removed from them by successive invaders and conquerers.

Ben-Gurion: “Our right to the Land of Israel does not stem from the Mandate and the Balfour Declaration. It precedes those. ... Our historical right has existed since our beginnings as the Jewish People, and the Balfour Declaration and the Mandate recognize and confirm that right” (testimony to the Peel Royal Commission, January 1937, Bama’archa, vol. 1, pp. 77-78).

“A homeland is not given as a gift and is not acquired by means of political rights and contracts. It is not purchased with gold and is not conquered by force, but is built with sweat. This homeland is a historical creation and a collective endeavor of a people, the fruit of its physical, spiritual, and moral labor down through the generations. … The Land of Israel will be ours not when the Turks, the English, or the next peace conference agrees to it, and it is undersigned in a diplomatic treaty – but when we, the Jews, build it. We will not attain the real, true, and lasting right to the land from others, but from our labor.

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

 

[P F Tinmore]

Three examples highlight the falsity and outright bias of this UN Study:

1.Deliberately misrepresenting General Assembly Resolution 181 that spoke of a “Palestinian Arab State” - when claiming:

“After investigating various alternatives the United Nations proposed the partitioning of Palestine into two independent States, one Palestinian Arab and the other Jewish, with Jerusalem internationalized.”

The actual wording of Resolution 181 stated:

“Independent Arab and Jewish States and the Special International Regime for the City of Jerusalem, set forth in Part III of this Plan, shall come into existence in Palestine....”

2.Omitting any mention of the fact that 78% of Palestine had become an independent Arab State in 1946 and been renamed the Hashemite Kingdom of Transjordan.

3. Falsely alleging:

“The decision on the Mandate [for Palestine] did not take into account the wishes of the people of Palestine”

The evidence contradicting this falsehood actually sits in the United Nations' own archives.

(full article online)

UN Sec. Gen. Guterres needs a crash course on Palestine

UN Sec. Gen. Guterres needs a crash course on Palestine

By a Zionist nutjob?

You are in need of the same crash course on Palestine.
Maybe they can start a class for those like you and Guterres who do not care about History of the land.

I will add both names to the list
Will get in touch with you when it comes up

By a "Jordan is Palestine" nutjob.

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

 

[Hollie]

By a Zionist nutjob?

You are in need of the same crash course on Palestine.
Maybe they can start a class for those like you and Guterres who do not care about History of the land.

I will add both names to the list
Will get in touch with you when it comes up

By a "Jordan is Palestine" nutjob.

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

You can thank your Islamic co-religionists for nakba’ing the bejezzus out of the Arab-Moslem settler colonists.

 

[ForeverYoung436]

By a Zionist nutjob?

You are in need of the same crash course on Palestine.
Maybe they can start a class for those like you and Guterres who do not care about History of the land.

I will add both names to the list
Will get in touch with you when it comes up

By a "Jordan is Palestine" nutjob.

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

Arabs have over 99% of the Middle East, so yes--wanting that last 1% as well is greedy. And many of the Arabs in Palestine were recent migrants to that area. A document from the 1920's said that Palestine's population was constantly being replenished by nomads from the Arabian peninsula.

 

[P F Tinmore]

You are in need of the same crash course on Palestine.
Maybe they can start a class for those like you and Guterres who do not care about History of the land.

I will add both names to the list
Will get in touch with you when it comes up

By a "Jordan is Palestine" nutjob.

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

Arabs have over 99% of the Middle East, so yes--wanting that last 1% as well is greedy. And many of the Arabs in Palestine were recent migrants to that area. A document from the 1920's said that Palestine's population was constantly being replenished by nomads from the Arabian peninsula.

 

[ForeverYoung436]

By a "Jordan is Palestine" nutjob.

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

Arabs have over 99% of the Middle East, so yes--wanting that last 1% as well is greedy. And many of the Arabs in Palestine were recent migrants to that area. A document from the 1920's said that Palestine's population was constantly being replenished by nomads from the Arabian peninsula.

Any intelligent response on your part?

 

[Shusha]

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

Arabs have over 99% of the Middle East, so yes--wanting that last 1% as well is greedy. And many of the Arabs in Palestine were recent migrants to that area. A document from the 1920's said that Palestine's population was constantly being replenished by nomads from the Arabian peninsula.

Any intelligent response on your part?

Excellent match for the post.

 

[theliq]

You are in need of the same crash course on Palestine.
Maybe they can start a class for those like you and Guterres who do not care about History of the land.

I will add both names to the list
Will get in touch with you when it comes up

By a "Jordan is Palestine" nutjob.

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

Arabs have over 99% of the Middle East, so yes--wanting that last 1% as well is greedy. And many of the Arabs in Palestine were recent migrants to that area. A document from the 1920's said that Palestine's population was constantly being replenished by nomads from the Arabian peninsula.

Really Fore,I do give you credit most of the time but when I see such prose like this,I sometimes wonder why...come on man,you can do better than this nonsence..st

 

[theliq]

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

YES,considering your BENT of actually distorting the facts.... to suit your imagination ...of exaggeration ...as an explanation....of you moral deterioration....and degeneration.

Now Bend Down Low,let me show you what I know....steven

 

[rylah]

By a "Jordan is Palestine" nutjob.

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

Arabs have over 99% of the Middle East, so yes--wanting that last 1% as well is greedy. And many of the Arabs in Palestine were recent migrants to that area. A document from the 1920's said that Palestine's population was constantly being replenished by nomads from the Arabian peninsula.

Really Fore,I do give you credit most of the time but when I see such prose like this,I sometimes wonder why...come on man,you can do better than this nonsence..st

Yet what he said was factually correct.

Israel is just 1% of the middle east, Arabs and other Muslims control the other 99%.
Take the Tamimi family for example, they have a WHOLE COUNTRY of their own, called Qatar.

Yet they can't stand seeing Jews having 1% of the land.

 

[P F Tinmore]

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

For centuries before the Zionist settler colonial project there were no Jews going up to Palestinians with deed in hand claiming his land.

Few, if any, European Zionists had any ancestors from that area. How can they say that they are reclaiming land that was never theirs?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Lesson # 1:

TransJordan was part of the Mandate for Palestine.

The Hashemites and TransJordan became an Arab Palestinian State in 1946.

Jordan is IN the Palestine region.

Jordan, therefore IS Palestine. 78 % of it.

You are welcome

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

Arabs have over 99% of the Middle East, so yes--wanting that last 1% as well is greedy. And many of the Arabs in Palestine were recent migrants to that area. A document from the 1920's said that Palestine's population was constantly being replenished by nomads from the Arabian peninsula.

Really Fore,I do give you credit most of the time but when I see such prose like this,I sometimes wonder why...come on man,you can do better than this nonsence..st

Yet what he said was factually correct.

Israel is just 1% of the middle east, Arabs and other Muslims control the other 99%.
Take the Tamimi family for example, they have a WHOLE COUNTRY of their own, called Qatar.

Yet they can't stand seeing Jews having 1% of the land.

Percentages don't matter when someone is claiming your land.

 

[Hollie]

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

For centuries before the Zionist settler colonial project there were no Jews going up to Palestinians with deed in hand claiming his land.

Few, if any, European Zionists had any ancestors from that area. How can they say that they are reclaiming land that was never theirs?

You’re incensed that the Arab-Islamist settler colonial project was supplanted by a modern, educated society.

You will have to learn to deal with that.

 

[Sixties Fan]

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

For centuries before the Zionist settler colonial project there were no Jews going up to Palestinians with deed in hand claiming his land.

Few, if any, European Zionists had any ancestors from that area. How can they say that they are reclaiming land that was never theirs?

Arabs had no deeds. They invaded in the 7th century. That some are now called Palestinians since 1964, for the sake of destroying their hated Jews' Nation, does not grant them the right to the region of Palestine.
The Arabs had no deeds during the Ottoman time, either. Either one, Jew or Arab, only got to buy land from the Ottoman Empire after 1850 when the Empire began to fall.

Rejecting the connection of any Jew descendant of Jews who lived on the land and made a Nation out of it.

Be ashamed of yourself.

Still, your endless rejectionism and denialism of who the Jews are, will never take away from them the 1 % they worked hard for and GAINED legally to recreate their Nation.

sniff....

 

[rylah]

I remember the old Encyclopedias that were around before the Internet. If you looked up the History of Jordan in them, they would refer you to the History of Palestine before the 1900's. Jordan is the name of a River, and not really the name of a country. It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine. It was also put off-limits to any Jew wanting to live there. Numerous Palestinian officials have stated quite openly that there is no real difference between Palestinians and Jordanians. That is why Jordan is the only Arab country that has granted citizenship to "Palestinian refugees", and that is also why the PLO tried to take over Jordan in 1970.

It was artificially carved out of the Palestine Mandate by the British, who mistakenly believed the Arabs' greed for more and more land could be satiated by a mere 78% of what was then known as Palestine.

So it was "greedy" for Palestinians to want to stay on the land that had been in the family for hundreds of years?

What dumbfuck wrote this shit?

Arabs have over 99% of the Middle East, so yes--wanting that last 1% as well is greedy. And many of the Arabs in Palestine were recent migrants to that area. A document from the 1920's said that Palestine's population was constantly being replenished by nomads from the Arabian peninsula.

Really Fore,I do give you credit most of the time but when I see such prose like this,I sometimes wonder why...come on man,you can do better than this nonsence..st

Yet what he said was factually correct.

Israel is just 1% of the middle east, Arabs and other Muslims control the other 99%.
Take the Tamimi family for example, they have a WHOLE COUNTRY of their own, called Qatar.

Yet they can't stand seeing Jews having 1% of the land.

Percentages don't matter when someone is claiming your land.

THANK YOU!

This is exactly what the Jews claim after centuries of being overwhelmed by Arabian invading tribes.
We are minority in the world, but percentages DON"T MATTER when You claim Your ancestral lands.

You Americans are running from the fact that Your state left a tiny percent of Indians, exactly like Arabs did to Jews.

 

[P F Tinmore]

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

For centuries before the Zionist settler colonial project there were no Jews going up to Palestinians with deed in hand claiming his land.

Few, if any, European Zionists had any ancestors from that area. How can they say that they are reclaiming land that was never theirs?

Arabs had no deeds. They invaded in the 7th century. That some are now called Palestinians since 1964, for the sake of destroying their hated Jews' Nation, does not grant them the right to the region of Palestine.
The Arabs had no deeds during the Ottoman time, either. Either one, Jew or Arab, only got to buy land from the Ottoman Empire after 1850 when the Empire began to fall.

Rejecting the connection of any Jew descendant of Jews who lived on the land and made a Nation out of it.

Be ashamed of yourself.

Still, your endless rejectionism and denialism of who the Jews are, will never take away from them the 1 % they worked hard for and GAINED legally to recreate their Nation.

sniff....

You are ducking the issue.

How many European Zionists had ancestors who lost land to the "Arabs?"

 

[rylah]

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

For centuries before the Zionist settler colonial project there were no Jews going up to Palestinians with deed in hand claiming his land.

Few, if any, European Zionists had any ancestors from that area. How can they say that they are reclaiming land that was never theirs?

Arabs had no deeds. They invaded in the 7th century. That some are now called Palestinians since 1964, for the sake of destroying their hated Jews' Nation, does not grant them the right to the region of Palestine.
The Arabs had no deeds during the Ottoman time, either. Either one, Jew or Arab, only got to buy land from the Ottoman Empire after 1850 when the Empire began to fall.

Rejecting the connection of any Jew descendant of Jews who lived on the land and made a Nation out of it.

Be ashamed of yourself.

Still, your endless rejectionism and denialism of who the Jews are, will never take away from them the 1 % they worked hard for and GAINED legally to recreate their Nation.

sniff....

You are ducking the issue.

How many European Zionists had ancestors who lost land to the "Arabs?"

All had relatives in Palestine. All had a land named after them.
Jews are a small tribe.

Some Jews from Europe literally lost lands to Arabs in Jerusalem, Jordan and Syria.
Many left to other lands including Europe exactly because of Arab invasions.

 

[P F Tinmore]

And in your statement you acknowledge YOUR TERRORISM AND UNCONTROLLED HATE...thank you

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

For centuries before the Zionist settler colonial project there were no Jews going up to Palestinians with deed in hand claiming his land.

Few, if any, European Zionists had any ancestors from that area. How can they say that they are reclaiming land that was never theirs?

Arabs had no deeds. They invaded in the 7th century. That some are now called Palestinians since 1964, for the sake of destroying their hated Jews' Nation, does not grant them the right to the region of Palestine.
The Arabs had no deeds during the Ottoman time, either. Either one, Jew or Arab, only got to buy land from the Ottoman Empire after 1850 when the Empire began to fall.

Rejecting the connection of any Jew descendant of Jews who lived on the land and made a Nation out of it.

Be ashamed of yourself.

Still, your endless rejectionism and denialism of who the Jews are, will never take away from them the 1 % they worked hard for and GAINED legally to recreate their Nation.

sniff....

You are ducking the issue.

How many European Zionists had ancestors who lost land to the "Arabs?"

All had relatives in Palestine. All had a land named after them.
Jews are a small tribe.

Some Jews from Europe literally lost lands to Arabs in Jerusalem, Jordan and Syria.

Do you have any evidence to prove your claim?

 

[Sixties Fan]

Its terrorism to state (truthfully) that the Jewish people have an historical connection to the land of Israel?! Get bent.

For centuries before the Zionist settler colonial project there were no Jews going up to Palestinians with deed in hand claiming his land.

Few, if any, European Zionists had any ancestors from that area. How can they say that they are reclaiming land that was never theirs?

Arabs had no deeds. They invaded in the 7th century. That some are now called Palestinians since 1964, for the sake of destroying their hated Jews' Nation, does not grant them the right to the region of Palestine.
The Arabs had no deeds during the Ottoman time, either. Either one, Jew or Arab, only got to buy land from the Ottoman Empire after 1850 when the Empire began to fall.

Rejecting the connection of any Jew descendant of Jews who lived on the land and made a Nation out of it.

Be ashamed of yourself.

Still, your endless rejectionism and denialism of who the Jews are, will never take away from them the 1 % they worked hard for and GAINED legally to recreate their Nation.

sniff....

You are ducking the issue.

How many European Zionists had ancestors who lost land to the "Arabs?"

All had relatives in Palestine. All had a land named after them.
Jews are a small tribe.

Some Jews from Europe literally lost lands to Arabs in Jerusalem, Jordan and Syria.

Do you have any evidence to prove your claim?

You are a denialist. No proof is good enough for you.

For you, the Arabs bought land, but not the Jews.
The Arabs lost land, but not the Jews.
The Arabs were expelled, but not the Jews.

The Jewish Agency had helped buy a lot of the swamps and deserts the Arabs did not want. Tel Aviv was a SWAMP. Look at it now !!!!!

Jews owned lands in Gaza till 1920. What happened that year?
Or the Jews in TranJordan by 1925? Or the Jews of Hebron until 1929?

Not ONE of those Jews owned their homes or lands?

Because you say so?

You show us all the evidence of Arabs, Turks and others having deeds to lands they say is rightfully theirs. As in ALL of Gaza, TransJordan, Judea, Samaria, the Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem.

Where are the Arab, etc deeds for all of those places where the Jews lived, since you insist Jews owned nothing, bought nothing at any time, had no deeds to their homes, etc?