Is Ima still asking why jews consider Israel to be a land holy to jews? Lets try to help her regarding the issue of PLACES which are HOLY to some people ie PLACES they consider VERY VERY IMPORTANT specifically to them. Only intensely bigotted people would focus on that which is HOLY to one and not the other when dealing with this question. When I was seven years old-----an aunt took us kids to WASHINGTON DC I was impressed with the LINCOLN MEMORIAL and would be insulted if someone TOOK IT AWAY from the USA I grew up thinking TIMES SQUARE in New York City is important too------uhm the great play houses are there and I sorta identify with broadway stage plays
when I was a kid----some neighbors want BACK TO IRELAND------they were actually the great grandchildren of Irish people and did not even speak with Irish accents
-----so Ima may ask WHY GO BACK TO IRELAND and not ZIMBABWE?
Lots of my indian friends go back to INDIA now and then even if their whole families are in
the USA for decades ----------why not Argentina?
DISCUSS!!!!!!!!!
If Israel was in say, a part of Australia, where everyone is safe. Nothing would then stop them from taking a trip to Jerusalem. You don't have to live in Vatican City to be a Catholic.
I'm just asking why, would anyone want to set up in a place that you know will cause you trouble, and do it in a way that causes you massive problems to start with? Jews are supposed to be smart people, aren't they?
Israel as a HOLY PLACE IN WHICH JEWS SHOULD LIVE is so strong an aspect of jewish BELIEF-----that assigning another place would just not have worked out. Jews have been risking their lives for centuries JUST TO GO THERE ------interestingly the most EAGER to go
there were the jews who ended up living in lands invaded by the dogs of arabia who certainly ALREADY knew of the dangers of living among muslims. You are demanding that a a people who are fascinated with a language that developed in a specific part of the world and whose history took place there and who were so interested in that land that they could draw maps of the place having never seen it---and whose literature involved it even if the writers had never actually been there----JUST GIVE IT UP ------and choose another place in which they either had no history or a negative history. no poetry and about which they have no art---------its as silly a suggestion as asking the HINDUS of the world to pretend that the MISSISSIPPI is THE GANGES RIVER In fact the word ART----applies. Israel --the land is SYMBOLIC for jews ------it shows up everywhere in the ART of the jews-----depictions, stories, poetry, celebrations-----even the various agricultural products of the area are SYMBOLS thereof. All of the languages that jews all over the world speak-----end up containing hebrew words. That commonality is important in the structure of a society. Its CULTURE you would not understand. For better insight----read CHILDHOOD AND SOCIETY ------all the children of jewish parents----because of the issues of language art and culture -----are linked------thru the symbols and language that developed in Israel.
An interesting factoid is that muslims all over the world include some bits of arabic in their language ---------another example of shared culture forming a link. Would you ask them to move Mecca to Chicago? Lets say people start attacking Mecca-------bombing the place should they move it to Las Vegas?