JoeB131
Diamond Member
- Jul 11, 2011
- 173,414
- 33,649
The fact is that the fucking government cannot protect you. Not from a bomb, not from a criminal, not from a rapist etc.
If you think it can then you are the one who is mentally ill.
Nor do I really expect it to, but I know I live a better life with a police presense that is 90% effective than one where everyone is on their own.
You expect it to and you will be disappointed.
A gun in the household is 43 times more likely to kill a member of the household than a bad guy. You might as well fill your yard with rattlesnakes and hope one doesn't bite little Sally.
people use guns 2.5 million times a year in self defense. See I can quote statistics too.
Yeah, unfortunately, yours are bullshit.
The Kleck Survey, which is where these numbers came from, had a number of statistical flaws in it. Besides the fact it was conducted in 1992, and it differed from another survey that found only 65K defensive gun uses a year.
The Contradictions of the Kleck Study
Klecks survey also included gun uses against animals and did not distinguish civilian uses from military of police uses. Klecks Interviewers do not appear to have questioned a random individual at a given telephone number, but rather asked to speak to the male head of the household. Males from the South and West were oversampled. The results imply that many hundreds of thousands of murders should have been occurring when a private gun was not available for protection. Yet guns are rarely carried, less than a third of adult Americans personally own guns, and only 27,000 homicides occurred in 1992.
As for the method used.
Consider the responses to a national random-digit-dial telephone survey of over 1,500 adults conducted in May 1994 by ABC News and the Washington Post. One question asked: "Have you yourself ever seen anything that you believe was a spacecraft from another planet?" 10% of respondents answered in the affirmative. These 150 individuals were then asked, "Have you personally ever been in contact with aliens from another planet or not?" and 6% answered "Yes."
By extrapolating to the national population, we might conclude that almost 20 million Americans have seen spacecraft from another planet, and over a million have been in personal contact with aliens from other planets. That more than a million Americans had contact with aliens would be incredible newsbut not the kind actively publicized by reputable scientists. Yet the ABC News/Washington Post data on aliens are as good as or better than that from any of the thirteen surveys cited by K-G as supporting their conclusions about self-defense gun use.
Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology
Maybe we need guns to protect ourselves from the space aliens.