Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Indeed. What DOES the Constitution say regarding seccession?
Can't say that I have read ANY clause saying that ANY State cannot.
The states are subordinate to federal law via the Supremacy Clause. They have accepted that by joining the Union. In order to secede a state has to effectively nullify all federal laws that it is subject to as a part of the Union.
Nullification was ruled unconstitutional.
Therefore, unless a state could somehow secede while continuing to obey all federal laws,
secession has to be unconstitutional.
btw, the Supremacy Clause is not conditional. There is no 'out' related to the Supremacy Clause in which a loophole could be found to let secession through.
Bullshit, three states New York, Rhode Island and Virginia incorporated in their ratification documents the right to secede.
.
I can see that this fantasy game can go on forever, so I will simply deliver the bottom line, and then prepare dinner.
Nobody is ever going to sucessfully suceed from the union.
I suggest that folks talk about something that is actually within our own universe and dimension, as a real possibility, like, whether or not Dean is going to rescue her career.
Chow....
Before 1880 abortion was legal in this country.
What else is new?
I can see that this fantasy game can go on forever, so I will simply deliver the bottom line, and then prepare dinner.
Nobody is ever going to sucessfully suceed from the union.
I suggest that folks talk about something that is actually within our own universe and dimension, as a real possibility, like, whether or not Dean is going to rescue her career.
Chow....
before 1880 abortion was legal in this country.
What else is new?
of all the people in this thread who are saying secession is a constitutional right because nowhere in the constitution does it say it isn't,
how many of them do you suppose would also then say that abortion at any stage of the pregnancy must also be a constitutional right,
since nowhere in the constitution does it say it isn't?
Eh? How many of you experts want to sign onto that simple logic?
I can see that this fantasy game can go on forever, so I will simply deliver the bottom line, and then prepare dinner.
Nobody is ever going to sucessfully suceed from the union.
I suggest that folks talk about something that is actually within our own universe and dimension, as a real possibility, like, whether or not Dean is going to rescue her career.
Chow....
Wanna bet? I highly recommend ALL STATES Secede from the Union for BREACH of Contract meaning the Ninth and Tenth...and the PEOPLE.
I can see that this fantasy game can go on forever, so I will simply deliver the bottom line, and then prepare dinner.
Nobody is ever going to sucessfully suceed from the union.
I suggest that folks talk about something that is actually within our own universe and dimension, as a real possibility, like, whether or not Dean is going to rescue her career.
Chow....
"Nobody is ever going to successfully secede from the Union Jack"
King George III
I believe he was proven wrong.
.
I can see that this fantasy game can go on forever, so I will simply deliver the bottom line, and then prepare dinner.
Nobody is ever going to sucessfully suceed from the union.
I suggest that folks talk about something that is actually within our own universe and dimension, as a real possibility, like, whether or not Dean is going to rescue her career.
Chow....
Wanna bet? I highly recommend ALL STATES Secede from the Union for BREACH of Contract meaning the Ninth and Tenth...and the PEOPLE.
What about the PEOPLE in the various seceding states who don't want to secede? Is the state government going to DICTATE to them that they must simply give up their rights as US citizens,
whether they want to or not?
Where's the authority for that come from? Arbitrarily, unilaterally, tyrannically revoking someone's constitutional rights, privileges, and protections against their will...
another question none of you nuts can answer.
before 1880 abortion was legal in this country.
What else is new?
of all the people in this thread who are saying secession is a constitutional right because nowhere in the constitution does it say it isn't,
how many of them do you suppose would also then say that abortion at any stage of the pregnancy must also be a constitutional right,
since nowhere in the constitution does it say it isn't?
Eh? How many of you experts want to sign onto that simple logic?
ninth amendment
.
Wanna bet? I highly recommend ALL STATES Secede from the Union for BREACH of Contract meaning the Ninth and Tenth...and the PEOPLE.
What about the PEOPLE in the various seceding states who don't want to secede? Is the state government going to DICTATE to them that they must simply give up their rights as US citizens,
whether they want to or not?
Where's the authority for that come from? Arbitrarily, unilaterally, tyrannically revoking someone's constitutional rights, privileges, and protections against their will...
another question none of you nuts can answer.
In order to protect your parasitic rights to welfare you must move to the remaining states.
.
of all the people in this thread who are saying secession is a constitutional right because nowhere in the constitution does it say it isn't,
how many of them do you suppose would also then say that abortion at any stage of the pregnancy must also be a constitutional right,
since nowhere in the constitution does it say it isn't?
Eh? How many of you experts want to sign onto that simple logic?
ninth amendment
.
The Ninth Amendment makes all abortion a constitutional right?
lol, your conservative pals are going to horsewhip you for that one.
Wanna bet? I highly recommend ALL STATES Secede from the Union for BREACH of Contract meaning the Ninth and Tenth...and the PEOPLE.
What about the PEOPLE in the various seceding states who don't want to secede? Is the state government going to DICTATE to them that they must simply give up their rights as US citizens,
whether they want to or not?
Where's the authority for that come from? Arbitrarily, unilaterally, tyrannically revoking someone's constitutional rights, privileges, and protections against their will...
another question none of you nuts can answer.
In order to protect your parasitic rights to welfare you must move to the remaining states.
.
ninth amendment
.
The Ninth Amendment makes all abortion a constitutional right?
lol, your conservative pals are going to horsewhip you for that one.
WHO is Talking abortion squimby? NO ONE but YOU. Nice try.
This one is a STATES Issue IDIOT.
What about the PEOPLE in the various seceding states who don't want to secede? Is the state government going to DICTATE to them that they must simply give up their rights as US citizens,
whether they want to or not?
Where's the authority for that come from? Arbitrarily, unilaterally, tyrannically revoking someone's constitutional rights, privileges, and protections against their will...
another question none of you nuts can answer.
In order to protect your parasitic rights to welfare you must move to the remaining states.
.
Maybe I just want my right to bear arms. Maybe I'm in Connecticut, and Connecticut is seceding so they can get out from under the 'tyranny' of the Second Amendment.
What then?
ninth amendment
.
The Ninth Amendment makes all abortion a constitutional right?
lol, your conservative pals are going to horsewhip you for that one.
WHO is Talking abortion squimby? NO ONE but YOU. Nice try.
This one is a STATES Issue IDIOT.
*YOU* Have the RIGHT TO MOVE if they do...Are you really this dense?The Ninth Amendment makes all abortion a constitutional right?
lol, your conservative pals are going to horsewhip you for that one.
WHO is Talking abortion squimby? NO ONE but YOU. Nice try.
This one is a STATES Issue IDIOT.
What gives my State the right to void my Constitutional Rights, which is what would happen if my State seceded.
Answer THAT.
In order to protect your parasitic rights to welfare you must move to the remaining states.
.
Maybe I just want my right to bear arms. Maybe I'm in Connecticut, and Connecticut is seceding so they can get out from under the 'tyranny' of the Second Amendment.
What then?
Then it is their RIGHT to CAPITULATE TO CRIMINALS AND TYRANNY...Get it yet Squimby?
*YOU* Have the RIGHT TO MOVE if they do...Are you really this dense?WHO is Talking abortion squimby? NO ONE but YOU. Nice try.
This one is a STATES Issue IDIOT.
What gives my State the right to void my Constitutional Rights, which is what would happen if my State seceded.
Answer THAT.
What about the PEOPLE in the various seceding states who don't want to secede? Is the state government going to DICTATE to them that they must simply give up their rights as US citizens,
whether they want to or not?
Where's the authority for that come from? Arbitrarily, unilaterally, tyrannically revoking someone's constitutional rights, privileges, and protections against their will...
another question none of you nuts can answer.
In order to protect your parasitic rights to welfare you must move to the remaining states.
.
Maybe I just want my right to bear arms. Maybe I'm in Connecticut, and Connecticut is seceding so they can get out from under the 'tyranny' of the Second Amendment.
What then?
