Before 1948

[Shusha]

Dumb one, there were a small cult of them in biblical times and they were never there in any large numbers since ...

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

 

[Eloy]

Dumb one, there were a small cult of them in biblical times and they were never there in any large numbers since ...

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

 

[Roudy]

Dumb one, there were a small cult of them in biblical times and they were never there in any large numbers since ...

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

 

[MJB12741]

Dumb one, there were a small cult of them in biblical times and they were never there in any large numbers since ...

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

 

[Eloy]

Dumb one, there were a small cult of them in biblical times and they were never there in any large numbers since ...

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

 

[louie888]

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

Come on, now that's just stupid.

 

[MJB12741]

Dumb one, there were a small cult of them in biblical times and they were never there in any large numbers since ...

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

 

[montelatici]

Dumb one, there were a small cult of them in biblical times and they were never there in any large numbers since ...

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

No, the Jews had no presence for centuries, by law. The Christians have maintained a constant presence since the birth of Christ. The Jews did not.

 

[louie888]

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

The most amusing thing I find watching you idiots continue with this line is how you'll never let facts get in the way of your idiocy.

 

[montelatici]

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

The ancestors of the current Muslim (and Christian) Palestinians practiced mostly Judaism and Samaritanism prior to converting to Christianity and later most to Islam.

But you knew that.

 

[MJB12741]

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

The ancestors of the current Muslim (and Christian) Palestinians practiced mostly Judaism and Samaritanism prior to converting to Christianity and later most to Islam.

But you knew that.

You guys seem to ignore a most important fact. All Land belongs to whoever rules it at any given period in time. Including all the stolen Muslim lands conquered by force.

 

[MJB12741]

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

The ancestors of the current Muslim (and Christian) Palestinians practiced mostly Judaism and Samaritanism prior to converting to Christianity and later most to Islam.

But you knew that.

You guys seem to ignore a most important fact. All Land belongs to whoever rules it at any given period in time. Including all the stolen Muslim lands conquered by force.

And you can bet your bottom dollar that Israel will not be another stolen land ruled by Muslims This time by those who call themselves Palestinians.

 

[louie888]

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

The ancestors of the current Muslim (and Christian) Palestinians practiced mostly Judaism and Samaritanism prior to converting to Christianity and later most to Islam.

But you knew that.

You guys seem to ignore a most important fact. All Land belongs to whoever rules it at any given period in time. Including all the stolen Muslim lands conquered by force.

There you go again, never let facts get in the way of your idiocy.

 

[MJB12741]

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

The ancestors of the current Muslim (and Christian) Palestinians practiced mostly Judaism and Samaritanism prior to converting to Christianity and later most to Islam.

But you knew that.

You guys seem to ignore a most important fact. All Land belongs to whoever rules it at any given period in time. Including all the stolen Muslim lands conquered by force.

There you go again, never let facts get in the way of your idiocy.

Aha. So then land does not belong to its rulers. Right Louie?

 

[MJB12741]

So they have been there for millennia, then. Just not very many of them.

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

Poor Louie. Just can't think with that God given piece of wood in his head.

Hey Louie, tell us, is the city of VILNA Russian, Polish or Lithuanian? Get it yet? Once again, --- all land belongs to those who rule it at any given period of time.

 

[louie888]

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

The ancestors of the current Muslim (and Christian) Palestinians practiced mostly Judaism and Samaritanism prior to converting to Christianity and later most to Islam.

But you knew that.

You guys seem to ignore a most important fact. All Land belongs to whoever rules it at any given period in time. Including all the stolen Muslim lands conquered by force.

There you go again, never let facts get in the way of your idiocy.

Aha. So then land does not belong to its rulers. Right Louie?

Never let facts get in the way of your idiocy.

 

[montelatici]

That sounds about right.
The same goes for Christians too.
After Mohammad, the predominant religion in the Holy Land has been Islam of course, although Christians laid claim to the cradle of the Holy Faith.

The Looting of Jerusalem by Crusaders in A.D. 1099 when all Jews and Muslims were put to the sword making the city exclusively Christian. “The slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles.”

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

Poor Louie. Just can't think with that God given piece of wood in his head.

Hey Louie, tell us, is the city of VILNA Russian, Polish or Lithuanian? Get it yet? Once again, --- all land belongs to those who rule it at any given period of time.

The European Jews will go the way of the European colonists in Rhodesia, Algeria etc. I don't think the non-Jews of Palestine will be as generous as the non-whites of South Africa.

 

[MJB12741]

Yes, despite the many invasions and pogroms over the mellenia, the Jews always maintained a presence and kept coming back. This increased in the last 700 years when the Ottomans defeated the Arabs and invited the Jews to come back to the land the Ottoman's recognized as the ancestral and religious holy land of the Jews. The Arabs have not had any control or governorship on the land for the last 700 years.

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

Poor Louie. Just can't think with that God given piece of wood in his head.

Hey Louie, tell us, is the city of VILNA Russian, Polish or Lithuanian? Get it yet? Once again, --- all land belongs to those who rule it at any given period of time.

The European Jews will go the way of the European colonists in Rhodesia, Algeria etc. I don't think the non-Jews of Palestine will be as generous as the non-whites of South Africa.

In your dreams.

 

[louie888]

Yes, the Jews are indigenous to the land. Not any Muslims, including those who call themselves Palestinians.

You have been told often enough that the European Jews who migrated to Palestine to set-up their own country 69 years ago were not indigenous to the Holy Land as the mainly Arab Palestinians are. Your myth is nonsense.

Is that right? So tell us how many Muslim Palestinians were in the land in antiquity when the Jews were?

Poor Louie. Just can't think with that God given piece of wood in his head.

Hey Louie, tell us, is the city of VILNA Russian, Polish or Lithuanian? Get it yet? Once again, --- all land belongs to those who rule it at any given period of time.

The European Jews will go the way of the European colonists in Rhodesia, Algeria etc. I don't think the non-Jews of Palestine will be as generous as the non-whites of South Africa.

Never let facts get in the way of your idiocy.
In your dreams.

 

[hunarcy]

Zionist Jews incited the violence by attempting to take the Temple Mount which is obviously Arab holy land. Prior to the zionist degenerates inciting this violence, Jews and Muslims and Christians lived in peace in Palestine for centuries. Beyond that, many Muslims protected Jews and even hid them in their homes.

/end thread

Why is it called "Temple Mount"? Because it's a Jewish holy place where both Jewish temples was located before Muslims even took control of Jerusalem in 637. So, by your implied argument, being "obviously Arab holy land" actually means less than nothing.