USAF 2023
Gold Member
- Feb 22, 2012
- 9,576
- 2,813
- 160
You don't make any sense.The occupation is the defining factor.
So you would agree then, that the Chinese people have no right to sovereign self-determination.
Bump for P F Tinmore . You didn't address this. If occupation is the defining factor for whether or not peoples have rights to sovereignty then there are a large number of peoples who, due to holding occupations, would be ineligible for self-determination and sovereignty, including the Turks, the Chinese, Indonesians, Moroccans, Spanish and a whole host of others.
Since I am certain you will say that the Chinese people DO have a right to sovereignty and self-determination, your claim that occupation is the defining factor is patently false. You are applying standards to Israel that you do not apply to China.
This was my original post on this mini-topic:
So many useful idiots have bought into this notion -- that the destruction of a sovereign State is not only permissible but the morally superior act.
This is intimately tied to irrational beliefs about Jews, I think. It speaks to a double standard held only for Jews. While people might speak about dismantling a sovereign State's government as a morally correct action against a harmful government, I can't think of a single instance of suggesting that self-determination be removed from an entire people -- except Israel. Surely, no one is suggesting, for example, that the Persian people of Iran must not be permitted under any circumstances to have a sovereign nation and self-determination, are they?
So, again I ask you -- Can the right to self-determination be removed from a people, or can they be rendered ineligible for that right? If yes, under what circumstances?
Sigh. Let me break it down again.
Do the Chinese people have the right to sovereignty and self-determination even though their State is occupying another peoples? If yes, then occupation is not the determining factor.
You’re not going to get a response. If he refuses to acknowledge whether or not the Israelis have the Rights to their Religious Sites or why Israel is under any obligation to cede any of the “ 67 Borders” linking Gaza and the W. Bank you’re not going to get a response.
He can’t stand the fact that Israel Exists. It’s that simple.
![eusa_dance :eusa_dance: :eusa_dance:](/styles/smilies/eusa_dance.gif)