Tech_Esq
Sic Semper Tyrannis!
- Jul 10, 2008
- 4,408
- 560
the surge worked in Iraq
No it didn't. The violence started abating when we started PAYING 70,000+ Sunnis not to shoot at us. The surge just gave the insurgents more targets to shoot at.
Afghanistan is also a completely different situation - geographically, culturally and politically. A tactic like what was used in Iraq would likely not work in Afghanistan.
You are definitely right about the first. Additionally, history is against maintaining large masses of troops in Afghanistan. The large footprint give the other side the opportunity to hit lightly protected vehicles operating in support of the mission in great numbers. It is somewhat telling that they aren't more effective at it. But, that's how the Soviets and the British were both pushed out.
The quandary we find ourselves in is that, unlike Vietnam, we don't have the option of just leaving. The Vietnamese were never going to come back to the US to pick up the fight. We know the Islamo-fascists will. So, the options are to do something or do something else, not do nothing.