Never was a Jewish exodus from Egypt

[rupol2000]

Science? Carbon dating?

no, there are no copies at all in paper. This is the result of linguistic analysis by the method of comparison with other ancient languages.

 

[Carl in Michigan]

Just a colorful and intriguing story
It never happened
It’s just fable
Zero archeological evidence

Sorry

There was an ISRAELITE EXODUS from Egypt.

When will you idiots get it thru your thick heads that the Jews are just ONE of the TWELVE TRIBES of ISRAEL.

 

[Indeependent]

There was an ISRAELITE EXODUS from Egypt.

When will you idiots get it thru your thick heads that the Jews are just ONE of the TWELVE TRIBES of ISRAEL.

Mostly the tribes of Judah and Levi with a smattering of Benjamin.

 

[rupol2000]

Most Hindus I have met quote the 4 billion year story.

Modern Hindus generally have an indirect relationship to this. Firstly, Aryavarta covered only the northern part of India, and secondly, even in northern India there were migrations and conquests. Perhaps the Kshatriyas inherited from the Aryans, but it is possible that the brahmanas later began to form their own military aristocracy, therefore even the Kshatriya clans there are not authentically Aryan.

 

[rupol2000]

Most Hindus I have met quote the 4 billion year story.

Modern Hindus generally have an indirect relationship to this. Firstly, Aryavarta covered only the northern part of India, and secondly, even in northern India there were migrations and conquests. Perhaps the Kshatriyas inherited from the Aryans, but it is possible that the brahmanas later began to form their own military aristocracy, therefore even the Kshatriya clans there are not authentically Aryan.

are as OLD AS THE VEDAS

This confusion apparently arose due to the fact that Sanskrit inherited the word brahman from the Vedic, and this word itself is found in the Vedas as "prayer", the Vedic Aryans could call those who chanted hymns that way, because the word brahman meant prayer. But this has nothing to do with those priests who laid the foundation of Hinduism.

The main religious role there belonged to the atharvans, the servants of fire, and the main ritual was to pour out Soma on burning straw. It has nothing to do with the religious culture of Brahmanism.

 

[Indeependent]

Modern Hindus generally have an indirect relationship to this. Firstly, Aryavarta covered only the northern part of India, and secondly, even in northern India there were migrations and conquests. Perhaps the Kshatriyas inherited from the Aryans, but it is possible that the brahmanas later began to form their own military aristocracy, therefore even the Kshatriya clans there are not authentically Aryan.

This confusion apparently arose due to the fact that Sanskrit inherited the word brahman from the Vedic, and this word itself is found in the Vedas as "prayer", the Vedic Aryans could call those who chanted hymns that way, because the word brahman meant prayer. But this has nothing to do with those priests who laid the foundation of Hinduism.

The main religious role there belonged to the atharvans, the servants of fire, and the main ritual was to pour out Soma on burning straw. It has nothing to do with the religious culture of Brahmanism.

All I know is that the Caste system has over 99% of the people starving and living in shit.

 

[irosie91]

now everyone is confused

All I know is that the Caste system has over 99% of the people starving and living in shit.

it had a function ONCE UPON A TIME-----it is being eroded -----with some level of
resistance

 

[Indeependent]

now everyone is confused

it had a function ONCE UPON A TIME-----it is being eroded -----with some level of
resistance

2 people in my community went to India a few months ago for business and said the 3rd caste and on were being devastated by COVID because the government doesn't give a damn about them.

 

[irosie91]

2 people in my community went to India a few months ago for business and said the 3rd caste and on were being devastated by COVID because the government doesn't give a damn about them.

yeah----well-----I had a good friend in college-----a real live Brahmin who rejected that role
but told me about the stuff that goes on in India. This was a REAL LIVE BRAHMIN---he even
sang classical sanskrit stuff. We played "cat's cradle" with his SACRED STRING. Sometimes
the "OTHER CASTES" played victim like some of OUR OTHER CASTES play victim. For your
interest-----the sacred string thing that he was SUPPOSED to wear on his chest, had specific
knots -----all done in prescribed manner -----kinda like TZITZES

 

[rylah]

Just a colorful and intriguing story
It never happened
It’s just fable
Zero archeological evidence

Sorry

Is that your expert verdict?

First written record of Semitic alphabet, from 15th century BCE, found in Egypt

Inscribed 3,400-year-old limestone flake from Luxor is world's first -- and second -- transliteration of early Canaanite alphabet, says Egyptologist Thomas Schneider

www.timesofisrael.com

 

[Quasar44]

rylah
So ?
They have early Canaanite language ??
Has zero to do with an exodus

 

[Quasar44]

Jews brutally attacked and killed the C

 

[DudleySmith]

There was an ISRAELITE EXODUS from Egypt.

When will you idiots get it thru your thick heads that the Jews are just ONE of the TWELVE TRIBES of ISRAEL.

The story also clearly notes hundreds of thousands of other people left with the Israelites.

 

[Quasar44]

DudleySmith
That many folks would leave “ massive clues in the sand “ . The deserts are an easy way to retrieve bones , pottery , weapons etc

 

[DudleySmith]

DudleySmith
That many folks would leave “ massive clues in the sand “ . The deserts are an easy way to retrieve bones , pottery , weapons etc

The Dead Sea Scrolls were only found relatively recently, and they're not far at all from places that were populated for thousands of years, and in caves everybody knew about for at least that long. Israeli archeologists keep finding ancient ruins and objects, and small towns alleged to have never existed.

 

[Quasar44]

DudleySmith

They don’t mention any Jewish exodus. ???

 

[DudleySmith]

DudleySmith

They don’t mention any Jewish exodus. ???

They don't have to to make my point about 'remains' in deserts. In any case ...

Biblical Dead Sea Scrolls - Exodus

Biblical Dead Sea Scrolls Translation page

dssenglishbible.com

 

[Quasar44]

DudleySmith
It never happened !
It was fabricated to give a new nation a glorious history

 

[Quasar44]

You would need insane wind speed blowing for a long duration in only one vector to part a sea path

 

[rylah]

rylah
So ?
They have early Canaanite language ??
Has zero to do with an exodus

Currently the earliest Semitic writing is found in Egypt,
and that has nothing with crossing the continent, or ruling the country?