MacTheKnife
Gold Member
- Jul 20, 2018
- 5,977
- 2,040
- 325
The answer isn’t to do away with unions. They need reforming. During the great bush recession they were forced to. But when things got better they got profit sharing.Reagan was the beginning of the end. In the years union membership went from 35% to 10, wages have gone down.
If you are a libertarian type who thinks the free market will set a fair wage you are wrong. Unions keep wages up. You know how to attack them but you don’t have a clue how important they are.
I think unions aren’t as bad today as they were. But you attack them no matter what. Probably because you don’t understand their value.
Yes weve all seen bad union stories. Get over it. Corporations would love to do away with unions, labor laws, minimium wage, social security
Are you a libertarian?
What unions did was force companies to overpay employees. So of course when they left, wages went down. But Reagan having something to do with it just because of the traffic controllers is nothing but a myth.
First off, the American consumer no longer supported unions. We used to buy mostly American made products. With unions, those products cost more and more, so eventually the consumers went to cheaper foreign products, and still do today.
It was less Reagan's choice than it was American consumers. Companies were forced to compete with foreign labor, and you can't do that by hiring people to drive around on floor sweepers for 25 bucks an hour plus outstanding benefits.
Yes I do attack unions because as a person who worked in industry for over three decades, I've had plenty of experiences with them. In the day, if I delivered to a new company I've never been to before and knew nothing about, I could tell you within ten minutes if they were union or not. I could write a book on my union experiences.
As for my politics, I consider myself to be 70% conservative and about 30% Libertarian, although I just consider myself conservative since that's where most of my values are. I would be a Libertarian if not for their stance on our military and recreational narcotics usage.
No doubt there were a lot of problems with unions many of them were run by organized crime to begin with....but the real problem was that we allowed so much cheap stuff to come into America...especially automobiles...but the list goes on and on.
That was what really screwed Ameican workers.
Unions accomplished a lot for American workers...anyone who does not know that is clueless...do a liittle research on the work conditions in the automobile industry before the unions came in...that should be an eye opener for anyone that is anti-union.
Unions were valuable at one time. The problem with unions is like anything else. They thought they were too big to fail.
So their demands kept getting more expensive and more intrusive on the companies they dominated. It got to the point a business had only two choices: move out of the state or country altogether to get rid of the unions, or join their employees in the unemployment line when they closed up shop.
Are unions still as bad as they used to be? I bet not.
It’s like Detroit. You guys think it’s a lot worse than it actually is
You can't reform unions. You either have them or you don't. During the Bush years is when I experienced the most companies leaving our city and state. We lost a lot of customers over the years because of unions, and perhaps that's why I hold them responsible for the decline of our businesses.
Unions can definitely be reformed...but the decline you mention was caused by more than just unions ...as has been pointed out...cheap foreign products.
The government being unwilling to do back then what Trump is doing mow...putting tarriffs on cheap foreign products produced in many cases by slave labor.
In a nutshell companies must be able to make a profit...they cannot make enough of a profit if foreign companies are allow to undersell them in America...with or without unions Ameican companies cannot compete with cheap foreign labor which in many cases amounts to slave labor.