POLL: Does the left want to end capitalism?

Does the left want to end capitalism?

  • I'm left wing - No, I want to emulate Nordic capitalism.

    Votes: 4 6.8%
  • I'm left wing - Yes, I want to end capitalism and bring about total socialism.

    Votes: 3 5.1%
  • I'm left wing - I want something else. (please elaborate with a post)

    Votes: 6 10.2%
  • I'm right wing - No, they want to emulate Scandinavian countries and I disagree with that.

    Votes: 5 8.5%
  • I'm right wing - Yes, they want to end capitalism and bring about total socialism or communism.

    Votes: 22 37.3%
  • I'm right wing - They want something else. (please elaborate with a post)

    Votes: 2 3.4%
  • I'm something else - No, they want to emulate Scandinavian countries.

    Votes: 2 3.4%
  • I'm something else - Yes, they want to end capitalism and bring about total socialism or communism.

    Votes: 10 16.9%
  • I'm something else - They want something else. (please elaborate with a post)

    Votes: 5 8.5%

  • Total voters
    59
I'm a liberal that likes a healthy portion of socialism with my well regulated capitalism. That is the recipe that makes a vibrant middle class.
Oh yeah...that’s why the middle class had lower incomes and lower savings under MaObama and the Pelosi/Reid reign of terror.

Everything you’ve been conditioned to believe is 100% bullshit. You’d know that too if you’d just look at data rather than your ideology.
 
I'm a liberal that likes a healthy portion of socialism with my well regulated capitalism. That is the recipe that makes a vibrant middle class.
Oh yeah...that’s why the middle class had lower incomes and lower savings under MaObama and the Pelosi/Reid reign of terror.

Everything you’ve been conditioned to believe is 100% bullshit. You’d know that too if you’d just look at data rather than your ideology.

I'm well aware of the "data" and know that Obama and Pelosi have nothing to do with stagnant wages and Republicans block efforts to do anything about it...like raise the minimum wage.
 
I'm well aware of the "data" and know that Obama and Pelosi have nothing to do with stagnant wages and Republicans block efforts to do anything about it...like raise the minimum wage.
Sweetie...for two years...Republicans couldn’t block anything. Dumbocrats controlled the White House (MaObama). Dumbocrats controlled the House (Pelosi). And Dumbocrats controlled the Senate (Reid). And all we saw was unemployment exceed 10%, wages decrease, and family savings decrease.
 
Can you provide an example of socialism that existed without government force?
Can you provide an example of capitalism that existed without government force?

What guarantees private property relations if not government force?

Government has to run the courts, that's all the need to do

Augustus Ceasar didnt even have a police department when he became Emperor
We have a Constitution that defines our Government.


You should read it sometime, stoner.
I have; I am a federalist Because I subscribe to the federal doctrine.

Sure daffy.

iu
 
Can you provide an example of capitalism that existed without government force?

What guarantees private property relations if not government force?

Government has to run the courts, that's all the need to do

Augustus Ceasar didnt even have a police department when he became Emperor
We have a Constitution that defines our Government.


You should read it sometime, stoner.
I have; I am a federalist Because I subscribe to the federal doctrine.

Sure daffy.

iu
The federal doctrine is about results, not excuses.
 
[

Western Europe is Capitalist for starters.

Not according to the democrats here.

Western Europe has heavy socialism. The only reason they have survived is because of small, homogeneous societies with a shared value system.

The influx of Muzzie Beasts guarantees collapse in the European socialist welfare states.

Communist Europe had solved it's diversity problem, and now Capitalists are supporting them to come back in.

The idea was Capitalist motivated, in the first place.

Not Enough Immigration? Leading German Economist Demands More Workers from Abroad - SPIEGEL ONLINE - International

Do you even know what capitalism is?

Klaus Zimmermann is an imperialist who seeks a slave labor force to thwart the market mechanisms that are weighing on the failed socialist state in Germany. This is a far left Keynesian mush brain.


But not all. Indeed, according to Klaus Zimmermann, president of the influential German Institute for Economic Research (DIW Berlin), Germany needs even more immigrants. In an interview with the newspaper Hamburger Abendblatt, Zimmermann said that the country's aging society means that Germany "badly needs workers and immigrants from abroad." He said the labor market needed "net immigration of at least 500,000 more people each year to ensure our economic strength."

As I said, he is an imperialist who thinks the importation of slave labor is the answer to gentrification in a society that has lived beyond their means for 50 years. Suddenly Germany finds it has no way to support the massive welfare system that lets workers retire at 55 at full salaries.

The question for Zimmermann is, how'd that work out for Rome?
 
Tax Cut Economics is pure ignorance that benefits those with the most capital, the most.

I think in general the right wing is more ignorant than the left. This thread has shifted my perspective somewhat, though. It's closer than I thought.

What is the left correct about?

Completely unchecked capitalism does not work for ordinary people. It eats itself and becomes destructive to the comfort of everyday people.
Wrong. Unchecked capitalism produced the greatest increase in the standard of living for the common man every seen.
Only in right wing fantasy.


Comrade, the cornerstone of capitalism is the free trader. You cannot exploit a free man. If I find no value in the deal, I'm free to walk away. Capitalism allows no coercion.
 
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?
I'm left wing and love capitalism What I don't like is the Nazi racist we have in our WH now and all those supporting him and putting up with his BS ,,This includes his protectors in congress
Show us one thing you've posted that demonstrates your love for capitalism.
Here's one bri ,,believe it or not
YTD Change
+$844,121.43
Huh? What the fuck is that supposed to mean?


That eddie is WELL into that half-gallon of gin he picked up this morning....
 
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?
I'm left wing and love capitalism What I don't like is the Nazi racist we have in our WH now and all those supporting him and putting up with his BS ,,This includes his protectors in congress
Show us one thing you've posted that demonstrates your love for capitalism.
Here's one bri ,,believe it or not
YTD Change
+$844,121.43
Huh? What the fuck is that supposed to mean?


That eddie is WELL into that half-gallon of gin he picked up this morning....
Only drink good scotch and only at closing bell
 
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?

What I think doesn't matter. What exists is an economic system which has a public sector and a private sector; a a system which has been pretty successful for centuries.

We've had ups and downs, bull and bear markets, wars and peace, and until January of 2017 a good ride with some serious hiccups since the late 18th Century. What we face today is a nation divided and probably more divided than at any other time in our history.

This thread, and the posts it generated, is an example of what is wrong with our country.

You Communists started this civil war in 2000. One common theme with you Marxists is that you're filthy fucking liars. Here you lie that "all was fine until Donald Trump." But you're a fucking liar. You Stalinist scum were every bit as vicious in your attacks on Bush as you are with your attacks on Trump.

What is changing is that normal people, the decent folk you Marxist scumbags so bitterly hate, are standing up to you. We are saying "enough."

The economy is booming, Americans have jobs, we have HOPE, which is what vile pigs like you really hate. The future for America is bright under Trump. You Marxists seek to end America, Trump is a monkey wrench in you plot to destroy the nation.
 
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?


In any political party you're going to have splits. The Democrat party majority of course would never be for the end of capitalism.

There are factions within it that would prefer some type of socialism--but they would never have the support in their own party to get to that point. As the majority of the Republican party are moderates and respect U.S. Supreme court decisiions on Roe V Wade and gay marriage, there is a faction within the party that will continue to fight against it, and will never get anything done.

Within both parties there are moderates--(the majority) & then the left and right wing of both parties which are the minority of both parties.


:lol:

You are a paid troll, an asset of the Soros International Communist cabal. You are PAID to assist in putting an end to the United States Constitution and establishing a Totalitarian Socialist state under the rule of Oligarchs such as Soros, Bezos, Cook, Musk, et al.

The only reason you are here is to end capitalism, to end America.
 
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?

Your poll is useless. As a card carrying liberal, there isn’t a choice I would tick.

32 people have voted and only 6 of them are liberals. The opinions of the 26 non-liberals who voted are moot because they don’t have a clue what liberals want.

23 idiots said liberals want communism. Their stupidity knows no bounds.


Pssst, Comrade - your party has dropped the mask.

Everyone knows you are Communists. The party not only admits it, but is proud of being a Marxist party.

bg081018dAPR20180810014512.jpg
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: kaz
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?

What I think doesn't matter. What exists is an economic system which has a public sector and a private sector; a a system which has been pretty successful for centuries.

We've had ups and downs, bull and bear markets, wars and peace, and until January of 2017 a good ride with some serious hiccups since the late 18th Century. What we face today is a nation divided and probably more divided than at any other time in our history.

This thread, and the posts it generated, is an example of what is wrong with our country.

You Communists started this civil war in 2000. One common theme with you Marxists is that you're filthy fucking liars. Here you lie that "all was fine until Donald Trump." But you're a fucking liar. You Stalinist scum were every bit as vicious in your attacks on Bush as you are with your attacks on Trump.

What is changing is that normal people, the decent folk you Marxist scumbags so bitterly hate, are standing up to you. We are saying "enough."

The economy is booming, Americans have jobs, we have HOPE, which is what vile pigs like you really hate. The future for America is bright under Trump. You Marxists seek to end America, Trump is a monkey wrench in you plot to destroy the nation.
The Marxist that we had 75 straight months of 6 digit job gains under,,,,unemployment fell from 10% to 4.5% an almost triple in the DOW ?? You should be kissing his ass along with the racist trump I for one have had enough of you racist southern crackers you traitors
 
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?

What I think doesn't matter. What exists is an economic system which has a public sector and a private sector; a a system which has been pretty successful for centuries.

We've had ups and downs, bull and bear markets, wars and peace, and until January of 2017 a good ride with some serious hiccups since the late 18th Century. What we face today is a nation divided and probably more divided than at any other time in our history.

This thread, and the posts it generated, is an example of what is wrong with our country.

You Communists started this civil war in 2000. One common theme with you Marxists is that you're filthy fucking liars. Here you lie that "all was fine until Donald Trump." But you're a fucking liar. You Stalinist scum were every bit as vicious in your attacks on Bush as you are with your attacks on Trump.

What is changing is that normal people, the decent folk you Marxist scumbags so bitterly hate, are standing up to you. We are saying "enough."

The economy is booming, Americans have jobs, we have HOPE, which is what vile pigs like you really hate. The future for America is bright under Trump. You Marxists seek to end America, Trump is a monkey wrench in you plot to destroy the nation.
The Marxist that we had 75 straight months of 6 digit job gains under,,,,unemployment fell from 10% to 4.5% an almost triple in the DOW ?? You should be kissing his ass along with the racist trump I for one have had enough of you racist southern crackers you traitors

Worst recession recovery since the Great Depression
 
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?

What I think doesn't matter. What exists is an economic system which has a public sector and a private sector; a a system which has been pretty successful for centuries.

We've had ups and downs, bull and bear markets, wars and peace, and until January of 2017 a good ride with some serious hiccups since the late 18th Century. What we face today is a nation divided and probably more divided than at any other time in our history.

This thread, and the posts it generated, is an example of what is wrong with our country.

You Communists started this civil war in 2000. One common theme with you Marxists is that you're filthy fucking liars. Here you lie that "all was fine until Donald Trump." But you're a fucking liar. You Stalinist scum were every bit as vicious in your attacks on Bush as you are with your attacks on Trump.

What is changing is that normal people, the decent folk you Marxist scumbags so bitterly hate, are standing up to you. We are saying "enough."

The economy is booming, Americans have jobs, we have HOPE, which is what vile pigs like you really hate. The future for America is bright under Trump. You Marxists seek to end America, Trump is a monkey wrench in you plot to destroy the nation.
The Marxist that we had 75 straight months of 6 digit job gains under,,,,unemployment fell from 10% to 4.5% an almost triple in the DOW ?? You should be kissing his ass along with the racist trump I for one have had enough of you racist southern crackers you traitors

Worst recession recovery since the Great Depression
With the leader of the Senate saying they will do NOTHING to help Obama or America clean up your gwb republican mess you should understand why it was slow ... Millions were out of work thanks to GWB and repubs Once more Repubs prove they're all about their jobs and FK America
 
It's my opinion that the left wing is not an opponent of capitalism. What do you think?

What I think doesn't matter. What exists is an economic system which has a public sector and a private sector; a a system which has been pretty successful for centuries.

We've had ups and downs, bull and bear markets, wars and peace, and until January of 2017 a good ride with some serious hiccups since the late 18th Century. What we face today is a nation divided and probably more divided than at any other time in our history.

This thread, and the posts it generated, is an example of what is wrong with our country.

You Communists started this civil war in 2000. One common theme with you Marxists is that you're filthy fucking liars. Here you lie that "all was fine until Donald Trump." But you're a fucking liar. You Stalinist scum were every bit as vicious in your attacks on Bush as you are with your attacks on Trump.

What is changing is that normal people, the decent folk you Marxist scumbags so bitterly hate, are standing up to you. We are saying "enough."

The economy is booming, Americans have jobs, we have HOPE, which is what vile pigs like you really hate. The future for America is bright under Trump. You Marxists seek to end America, Trump is a monkey wrench in you plot to destroy the nation.
The Marxist that we had 75 straight months of 6 digit job gains under,,,,unemployment fell from 10% to 4.5% an almost triple in the DOW ?? You should be kissing his ass along with the racist trump I for one have had enough of you racist southern crackers you traitors

Worst recession recovery since the Great Depression
With the leader of the Senate saying they will do NOTHING to help Obama or America clean up your gwb republican mess you should understand why it was slow ... Millions were out of work thanks to GWB and repubs Once more Repubs prove they're all about their jobs and FK America

You voted for W, I didn't. So it's your mess.

Obama continued his policies, strange way to try to clean it up.

edward: kaz, you voted against W, you voted against Obama continuing his policies, so this really is your fault.

Idiot
 
Not only have I read Marx, but I have actively sought to understand what it was he was writing. The concept of the dictatorship of the proletariat needs be no more authoritarian than the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie that exists today in America and which you freely accept as being the natural state of things.

Ah, so you seek to contradict the words written with your desires.

Dictatorship of the bourgeoisie? :lmao:

Come off it dude, the middle class is (or rather was until Trump) under sustained assault and declining fast. The nearly Communist state of California wages full on war on the Middle class on behalf of a ruling Marxist Aristocracy in Silicone valley.

The bourgeoisie, the middle class, are barely surviving after 8 years of Obama.

Here in California, we have the rule of the Oligarchs, just as the Soviets had.


"The most democratic bourgeois republic is no more than a machine for the suppression of the working class by the bourgeoisie, for the suppression of the working people by a handful of capitalists.

Even in the most democratic bourgeois republic "freedom of assembly" is a hollow phrase, for the rich have the best public and private buildings at their disposal, and enough leisure to assemble at meetings, which are protected by the bourgeois machine of power. The rural and urban workers and small peasants – the overwhelming majority of the population – are denied all these things. As long as that state of affairs prevails, "equality", i.e., "pure democracy", is a fraud.

"Freedom of the press" is another of the principal slogans of "pure democracy". And here, too, the workers know – and Socialists everywhere have explained millions of times – that this freedom is a deception because the best printing presses and the biggest stocks of paper are appropriated by the capitalists, and while capitalist rule over the press remains – a rule that is manifested throughout the whole world all the more strikingly, sharply and cynically – the more democracy and the republican system are developed, as in America for example...

The capitalists have always use the term "freedom" to mean freedom for the rich to get richer and for the workers to starve to death. And capitalist usage, freedom of the press means freedom of the rich to bribe the press, freedom to use their wealth to shape and fabricate so-called public opinion. In this respect, too, the defenders of "pure democracy" prove to be defenders of an utterly foul and venal system that gives the rich control over the mass media. They prove to be deceivers of the people, who, with the aid of plausible, fine-sounding, but thoroughly false phrases, divert them from the concrete historical task of liberating the press from capitalist enslavement."
First Congress of the Communist International

Had Marx aimed his ire at the Aristocracy rather than the Middle Class, he may have fared better. But what is clear from your quote is the Communists are mere pawns of the elite, attempting to turn the proletariat into supporters of the Monarchy that is the actually oppressor of them. Marx sought to cut off the middle class so as to destroy the path out of poverty as a means of protecting the position and power of the ruling elite.

Socialism is simply a return to serfdom. That is both the intent and result.
 
Last edited:
My statement didn't need clarification. Socialism is a socioeconomic relationship. It is not a form of government.

Socialism requires an authoritarian state to enforce the division of labor and resources. Have you not read Marx?

Whether the "Dictatorship of the Proletarians" or the Kleptocracy of Merkle in Germany, Socialism is ALWAYS authoritarian, and must be so. Evolution drives a species to survive and thrive. Working to ones own harm for the supposed benefit of society violates our basic programming. Hence socialists ALWAYS use force.
Not only have I read Marx, but I have actively sought to understand what it was he was writing. The concept of the dictatorship of the proletariat needs be no more authoritarian than the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie that exists today in America and which you freely accept as being the natural state of things.


"The most democratic bourgeois republic is no more than a machine for the suppression of the working class by the bourgeoisie, for the suppression of the working people by a handful of capitalists.

Even in the most democratic bourgeois republic "freedom of assembly" is a hollow phrase, for the rich have the best public and private buildings at their disposal, and enough leisure to assemble at meetings, which are protected by the bourgeois machine of power. The rural and urban workers and small peasants – the overwhelming majority of the population – are denied all these things. As long as that state of affairs prevails, "equality", i.e., "pure democracy", is a fraud.

"Freedom of the press" is another of the principal slogans of "pure democracy". And here, too, the workers know – and Socialists everywhere have explained millions of times – that this freedom is a deception because the best printing presses and the biggest stocks of paper are appropriated by the capitalists, and while capitalist rule over the press remains – a rule that is manifested throughout the whole world all the more strikingly, sharply and cynically – the more democracy and the republican system are developed, as in America for example...

The capitalists have always use the term "freedom" to mean freedom for the rich to get richer and for the workers to starve to death. And capitalist usage, freedom of the press means freedom of the rich to bribe the press, freedom to use their wealth to shape and fabricate so-called public opinion. In this respect, too, the defenders of "pure democracy" prove to be defenders of an utterly foul and venal system that gives the rich control over the mass media. They prove to be deceivers of the people, who, with the aid of plausible, fine-sounding, but thoroughly false phrases, divert them from the concrete historical task of liberating the press from capitalist enslavement."
First Congress of the Communist International

Wow, you have read Marx, comrade.

You think that when people buy political power, that's capitalism. It's not, it's socialism. Government is making our choices, which is central economic planning, which is by definition socialism.

Capitalism is when government does NOT make our choices for us. Maybe when you're done studying Marx, you can start on Adam Smith and the other side


I've read Marx as well. "Capital Vol. 1" has many valid insights. We are best served by understanding all aspects of an issue.
 
Trading in peace and offering value in exchange for value is the exact intent of socialism.

:lol:

One cannot "trade" when the state owns everything, including the enslaved people who would do the trading.

The capitalist seeks a profit, therefore he seeks an advantage over his trading partner. Capitalism is a system that relies on competition hence the phrase "buyer beware".

All people seek a profit. You seek a "profit" over me in this argument - you seek to win.

Socialism is a club to crush the natural way that people interact, a method of destroying the human spirit in the quest to enslave man under the rule of the elite.

Marxism is merely repackaging of the Monarchies.
 
I think in general the right wing is more ignorant than the left. This thread has shifted my perspective somewhat, though. It's closer than I thought.

What is the left correct about?

Completely unchecked capitalism does not work for ordinary people. It eats itself and becomes destructive to the comfort of everyday people.
Yep. The screamingly obvious point of equilibrium here is effective and efficient regulation. But the libertarians controlling the GOP and the left wingers controlling the Dems have other ideas.
.


Mac, you need to learn what terms mean before tossing them about.

{
What is 'Economic Equilibrium '
Economic equilibrium is a condition or state in which economic forces are balanced. In effect, economic variables remain unchanged from their equilibrium values in the absence of external influences.

Economic equilibrium may also be defined as the point at which supply equals demand for a product, with the equilibrium price existing where the hypothetical supply and demand curves intersect.}

Economic Equilibrium

Just because you hear a term doesn't mean you should use it with no understanding of it's meaning.
Um, I didn't use the term "Economic Equilibrium".

Maybe read my post one more time.

Then you can try again.
.


Pathetic Mac.

Equilibrium is an economic term and concept, which you deployed in a discussion on economics.

Weaseling out of your obvious faux paus is unbecoming.
 

Forum List

Back
Top