The Nuking of Nagasaki: Even More Immoral and Unnecessary than Hiroshima

[Leo123]

I see no evidence of these claims

I found it in 5 minutes. You just don't want to look because, for some reason, you seem to want to blame America. Here's a hint: Go online, read material, etc. without trying to find stuff that agrees with your POV. All I did was use a search engine and just typed in 'Eisenhower and the Bomb.' Do some research, actually read articles, etc. before you come here and claim you know anything. With Leahy all I did was search his bio. You, apparently just took someone else's word for it because it agreed with your opinion.

 

[Vegasgiants]

I found it in 5 minutes. You just don't want to look because, for some reason, you seem to want to blame America.

Should be very easy to link then

And I never blamed America

 

[Leo123]

Should be very easy to link then

And I never blamed America

Find it yourself. For Leahy, go to Wiki, for Eisenhower type what I told you to type. Read it for yourself. I am not your babysitter. At that time there were plenty of people that doubted the bomb or were questioning it's use. The FACT is that Japan surrendered AFTER the bomb was dropped. You can try to play retrospective arm-chair general all you want but it's nothing but a fantasy.

 

[Vegasgiants]

Find it yourself. For Leahy, go to Wiki, for Eisenhower type what I told you to type. Read it for yourself. I am not your babysitter.

Nope. Link it or not


Dismissed

 

[Leo123]

Nope. Link it or not


Dismissed

I will not do your work for you. Prove me wrong or go away. Dismissed.

 

[Vegasgiants]

I will not do your work for you. Prove me wrong or go away. Dismissed.

Dismissed

 

[Turtlesoup]

I see no evidence of these claims

You have a lot of trouble seeing the facts.

 

[Vegasgiants]

You have a lot of trouble seeing the facts.

Post some and let's find out


I am not the debate

 

[Leo123]

Should be very easy to link then

And I never blamed America

I forgot to mention, you provided no links either. At least I gave you a hint as to where to find more accurate info...."Dismissed.."

 

[Turtlesoup]

Nope. Link it or not


Dismissed

GROW UP VEGAS----

 

[Vegasgiants]

GROW UP VEGAS----

You got nothing

 

[Vegasgiants]

I forgot to mention, you provided no links either. At least I gave you a hint as to where to find more accurate info...."Dismissed.."

Actually I did. Read the thread

 

[Leo123]

Actually I did. Read the thread

I'm not reading 900+ posts to find one. I told you where to go, you just sit there a bloviate and expect us all to believe you. 'Dismissed' LOL

 

[Vegasgiants]

I'm not reading 900+ posts to find one. I told you where to go, you just sit there a bloviate and expect us all to believe you. 'Dismissed' LOL

I gave you a chance.


You got nothing


Dismissed

 

[Turtlesoup]

I see. So the very military leaders that got us to that point are now idiots because YOU say so.


The japanese surrendered so surrender was ALWAYS an option

I thought that I was very clear----I was very specific that atleast one of the idiots (the admiral) that you listed was completely inept at his job---caused the death of several of our soldiers on atleast two documented occasions, was put up for criminal review on for these two occassions, and should have been put in the brig----------he like McCAIN was given a command because of WHO his daddy was instead of his ability. His comments mean less than nothing---he actions were not honorable.

 

[Turtlesoup]

Sure it has. They sued for peace thru sweden and russia. The emperor himself said he wanted peace

He didn't want to be bombed and didn't want to fully surrender...ending Japans world power status which would have allowed him attack again later on.

 

[Vegasgiants]

I thought that I was very clear----I was very specific that atleast one of the idiots (the admiral) that you listed was completely inept at his job---caused the death of several of our soldiers on atleast two documented occasions, was put up for criminal review on for these two occassions, and should have been put in the brig----------he like McCAIN was given a command because of WHO his daddy was instead of his ability. His comments mean less than nothing---he actions were not honorable.

And you have an opinion on that admiral.


Yet his opinion is backed by many other military leaders.


Just a coincidence I guess. Lol

 

[Vegasgiants]

He didn't want to be bombed and didn't want to fully surrender...ending Japans world power status which would have allowed him attack again later on.

Yet he did surrender....so it was always an option

 

[RetiredGySgt]

Post some and let's find out


I am not the debate

LOL why post links for you, you either dont read them or claim they are wrong.

 

[Vegasgiants]

LOL why post links for you, you either dont read them or claim they are wrong.

No I read them
And you can post them or not


And i will judge based on that