Umm, do USMB Republicans understand that the Keystone pipeline will only create 35 permanent jobs?

They are not buying your bullshit about this being important about jobs.

Jobs and cheap energy prices with an energy source that actually works when you need it to...

Jobs? How many rail jobs are going to be lost.

Cheap Energy? So Canada is just giving this stuff away.

Saying that I would give the Pipeline extension if there more legislation to restrict coal.

Canada is your number one supplier. Keystone is just a transport mechanism to get the crude to your various refineries. XL is to the Gulf but Keystone I and II were to Oklahoma and to Illinois.

It's coming by rain, truck and or pipeline. You need it.

Your State Department put the reasons of why you want and need the Keystone Pipelines quite eloquently. This was 2008. Before energy needs became a political football.

Keystone Pipeline Presidential Permit

On March 14, the Department of State issued a Presidential Permit authorizing TransCanada Keystone Pipeline LP to construct, operate and maintain facilities related to the Keystone crude oil pipeline project.

The Keystone pipeline will extend 1,300 miles from the Canadian border through the U.S. Midwest.

When fully operational, the Keystone pipeline is anticipated to increase U.S. oil imports from Canada by an amount equivalent to as much as 4.5 percent of total U.S. daily imports.

Canada is the United States' largest supplier of oil, natural gas, and electricity.

The Department has determined that issuance of the permit to TransCanada Keystone Pipeline LP is in the national interest, in part, because it increases U.S. market access to crude oil supplies from a stable and reliable trading partner, Canada, that is in close proximity to the United States.


Canadian oil represents a safe, secure supply for the North American market. In 2004, Canada became the largest supplier of crude oil to the United States.

In 2006, Canada supplied the United States with 2.3 million barrels of oil per day (mbd), equivalent to 17% of total U.S. imports.

More at the State Department link:

Keystone Pipeline Presidential Permit

Fine. Then end Keystone in Texas/Louisiana and mandate that only crude destined for American refineries can be pumped through it.

Tell that to your refineries. Keystone/Trans Canada has no say whatsoever.

They're just the pipeline.

But your own EIA states that 80% stays for domestic use. And that just makes sense because you are producing only about 9 million barrels a day but you use 18 million barrels a day.
 
The plan is to turn it over to the government...that's when the number becomes 350,000.
OK that was funny. Nice post.

Imo Dean sort of misses the point though. Who cares how many jobs it creates? It doesn't cost taxpayers anything to build the thing. It will increase the amt of petroleum in the world supply (which isn't a bad thing considering Putin these days). And, a pipeline is actually safer than a bunch of rail cars. It's not gonna make my gas cheaper, but why not let them build the fcking thing if they want? We are a capitalist econ.
 
How about the thousands of multi-year jobs that the XL Pipeline would create? They would not be permanent jobs, but they would last for several years. In addition, millions of dollars would be pumped into the local economies where the pipeline would be constructed.

And if you're worried about the environment, the pipeline would be far more enviro friendly than how the oil is currently being transported to our southern ports. Right now that oil is being transported by trucks and some rail. Sending it through a pipeline would produce almost no emissions into the atmosphere.

Why not do the smart thing, the thing that would create thousands of jobs for several years and would pump millions of dollars into our economy?

How about we rebuild America's roads and bridges and create thousands of jobs that way?

How about we rebuild America's roads and bridges and create thousands of jobs that way?

Sounds good.
We can pay for it by cutting social spending back to pre-Obama levels.
That should be no problem since Obama fixed the economy and the country. Just look at the Dow.

And while we're at it, we can allow these privately funded pipeline projects to be built.
 
Only 35 jobs! That's way more than Solyndra created!

w00t!
 
Welders have made out like bandits?

images


rdean is another left wing idiot who doesn't understand that the very nature of construction work is temporary.

And this pipeline will create thousands of jobs. Welders in Oklahoma for example have made out like bandits on that part of the pipeline. They averaged $134,000. for their "temporary construction job".

Cripes I just can't believe that liberals can be this freaking stupid!!!!!!!!!!!
 
heres more from my politifact reference above:

Importantly, as Raddatz said, these jobs would only be supported during the construction phase, which is expected to take one to two years. After construction, the pipeline would employ about 50 people, primarily for maintenance.

And so fucking what? It takes hundreds of men and women to build a highway and how many permanent jobs result from the construction of that highway?

Does that negate the economic benefit to those construction workers on the highway?
Listen up "Dum Dum". Once that highway is built, it can be used for commerce. What a dipshit.

The "Keystone" plan is to mine the oil in Canada, transport it through the US. Then sell it overseas. It won't lower the price of oil or gas in this country. It won't be used in this country. It will only create thousands of jobs when it leaks and it has to be cleaned up. But don't worry. Republicans will protect those foreign oil companies they same way the blocked the BP oil spill from being investigated.

The tards won and now they are cheering. They refuse to believe what they won and when the mess needs to be cleaned up, the tards with blame the Democrats. Just like they always do when they fail, which, of course, is always.

The "Keystone" plan is to mine the oil in Canada, transport it through the US. Then sell it overseas.

Why would the Canadians pay extra to ship it further, when they can sell it to us?

They aren't the ones paying for the shipping. Besides, piping through America's breadbasket is the cheapest way to go. Unless there is a spill. But don't worry. Republicans kept BP from being investigated. They will protect TransCanada.

They aren't the ones paying for the shipping.

The oil producers won't be paying to ship the oil? Who will?

Besides, piping through America's breadbasket is the cheapest way to go.

Selling it to US refiners is cheaper than loading it on a tanker and shipping it thousands of miles further.
 
35 permanent jobs and higher gas prices. Hilarious.

Canadian oil is refined in our refineries before it's shipped overseas creating competition between American and foreign oil. Of course, that will cause gas prices to rise. Republicans don't seem to understand that Canadian oil is foreign oil. Who owns the refineries? The Koch Bros. It's estimated they could make a hundred billion dollars. Not "million". "BILLION".

So the GOP plan is 35 jobs, higher gas prices and billions to billionaires. And America has bought into it. Hilarious! Truly Hilarious!

Who owns the refineries? The Koch Bros.

They own all the refineries? Really?

It's estimated they could make a hundred billion dollars.

By refining oil? How do you figure that, it's a low margin business.

And America has bought into it.

No, America has not bought into your stupid strawman. Well, maybe the stupid libs have. They are easily led.
 
How about the thousands of multi-year jobs that the XL Pipeline would create? They would not be permanent jobs, but they would last for several years. In addition, millions of dollars would be pumped into the local economies where the pipeline would be constructed.

And if you're worried about the environment, the pipeline would be far more enviro friendly than how the oil is currently being transported to our southern ports. Right now that oil is being transported by trucks and some rail. Sending it through a pipeline would produce almost no emissions into the atmosphere.

Why not do the smart thing, the thing that would create thousands of jobs for several years and would pump millions of dollars into our economy?

You seriously have to catch up...

The jobs argument has been thrown out ages ago... Look at all the Rail and Truck jobs lost...

The jobs figures published have been rubbished.

Saying that I would give the pipeline for Coal restrictions...

The jobs argument has been thrown out ages ago... Look at all the Rail and Truck jobs lost...
Yes, Warren Buffett will make a bit less. Boohoo.
 
CNN s Van Jones says Keystone pipeline only creates 35 permanent jobs PunditFact

Contrary To GOP Promises Keystone XL Pipeline Will Only Create 35 Permanent Jobs

Republicans and conservative Democrats have continuously pushed for this pipeline’s approval is due to the huge windfall it will create for oil companies, specifically the Koch Bros. A report completed last year shows that the Kochs stand to make $100 billion from the passage of the Keystone extension. That’s billion, not million.

Republicans can’t just go to the people and say that we need to make sure insanely rich billionaires need to be given an opportunity to become even more insanely wealthy, environmental impacts be damned. Of course not. Therefore, they need to go out and claim that the project will create tons of jobs, help the country’s economy and fulfill its energy needs. Or, in other words, lie. Lie through their teeth.

Fox News host Keystone pipeline would create tens of thousands of jobs PunditFact

Fox News host: Keystone pipeline would create 'tens of thousands of jobs'

As far as new jobs go, the State Department estimates the operation of the pipeline will only create 35 permanent, full-time jobs and 15 temporary contractors. The full-time workers would be "required for annual operations, including routine inspections, maintenance and repair." Some would work in a Nebraska field office.

The lack of many full-time positions makes sense, given that the project is to build a pipeline so that tar sands can travel without the need of rail cars or ships.



-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Well, there you have it. Maybe we are "misunderestimating" Republicans. Maybe they mean 35 permanent jobs and tens of thousands of jobs cleaning up the fucking mess.

Another huge GOP disaster looms on the horizon. Will this country never learn?
The Keystone Pipeline would have created thousands of temporary jobs during construction which would have been a much needed stimulus during the recession. Today it's value in job creation is minimal. The pipeline would carry Canadian oil to ports on the Gulf Coast for shipment around the world. The big winners would be Canadian oil companies, operators of the pipeline and oil shippers. The question is whether the damage to the environment is worth the additional oil that could be delivered to the world market.
 
They talk about 35 lousy permanent jobs. Good grief!

They fail to recognize the following:

"Keystone XL would require hundreds of millions of dollars worth of materials and related services for items such as the steel pipe, the thousands of fittings, hundreds of large valves, fabrication of piping assemblies and structural steel for supports, and thousands of other pieces of equipment used to build such things as transformers for pumping stations, meters to measure the amount of oil delivered, large electric motors for operating pumps and cabling and electrical equipment to connect our vast pipeline monitoring systems.

TransCanada alone has contracts with over 50 suppliers across the U.S.. Manufacturing locations for our equipment include: Texas, Missouri, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Indiana, Georgia, Maryland, New York, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Minnesota, Ohio, Arkansas, Kansas, California and Pennsylvania.

Construction of Keystone XL is expected to create 7000 manufacturing jobs. Key support companies include: Welspun (pipe from Arkansas), Cameron (valves from Louisiana), Siemens (pumps, motors and related control equipment manufactured in Oregon, Ohio and Indiana) and dozens of other companies manufacturing everything from nuts and bolts to complex electrical control equipment.

The pipeline construction contractors must also procure hundreds of millions dollars worth of equipment and materials.

Hundreds of jobs will be created through requirements for fuel, coating materials, welding supplies, concrete materials, geo-textile materials, pipeline weights, native seed materials for reclamation, cathodic protection materials, crushed rock, sediment barrier materials, valve and pigging assemblies, field trailer manufacturing, construction mats, power facility materials, aggregate manufacturing, road construction materials, water and waste facility manufacturing, fencing materials, communication infrastructure, bridge construction materials and many others."

More at link:

TransCanada Releases Detailed Keystone XL Job Creation Data
 
Remember all those "shovel ready" jobs Biden and Obama wet their pants about? THOSE ARE TEMPORARY, TOO!

I didn't hear the Left whining then about those jobs being temporary. Hypocrites.

This whining about the Keystone construction jobs only being temporary is bullshit.

EVERY construction job is temporary.

That's the nature of the work. You finish one construction job, you move on to the next one. Except the fuckwads want to prevent that next job from being there. And unlike the stimulus jobs, these jobs aren't funded by taxpayers. They are paid out of the pockets of (gasp) a corporation.
 
CNN s Van Jones says Keystone pipeline only creates 35 permanent jobs PunditFact

Contrary To GOP Promises Keystone XL Pipeline Will Only Create 35 Permanent Jobs

Republicans and conservative Democrats have continuously pushed for this pipeline’s approval is due to the huge windfall it will create for oil companies, specifically the Koch Bros. A report completed last year shows that the Kochs stand to make $100 billion from the passage of the Keystone extension. That’s billion, not million.

Republicans can’t just go to the people and say that we need to make sure insanely rich billionaires need to be given an opportunity to become even more insanely wealthy, environmental impacts be damned. Of course not. Therefore, they need to go out and claim that the project will create tons of jobs, help the country’s economy and fulfill its energy needs. Or, in other words, lie. Lie through their teeth.

Fox News host Keystone pipeline would create tens of thousands of jobs PunditFact

Fox News host: Keystone pipeline would create 'tens of thousands of jobs'

As far as new jobs go, the State Department estimates the operation of the pipeline will only create 35 permanent, full-time jobs and 15 temporary contractors. The full-time workers would be "required for annual operations, including routine inspections, maintenance and repair." Some would work in a Nebraska field office.

The lack of many full-time positions makes sense, given that the project is to build a pipeline so that tar sands can travel without the need of rail cars or ships.



-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Well, there you have it. Maybe we are "misunderestimating" Republicans. Maybe they mean 35 permanent jobs and tens of thousands of jobs cleaning up the fucking mess.

Another huge GOP disaster looms on the horizon. Will this country never learn?
The Keystone Pipeline would have created thousands of temporary jobs during construction which would have been a much needed stimulus during the recession. Today it's value in job creation is minimal. The pipeline would carry Canadian oil to ports on the Gulf Coast for shipment around the world. The big winners would be Canadian oil companies, operators of the pipeline and oil shippers. The question is whether the damage to the environment is worth the additional oil that could be delivered to the world market.

That's just insane. Your own EIA has stated that 80% of the crude being refined is staying in the domestic market.

You only produce 9 million barrels a day but you use 18 million barrels of oil a day.

You use Canadian crude every day of your lives.

And considering we already ship to China and India from ports in British Columbia with a direct route across the Pacific why in hell would we ship crude all the way to the Gulf to ship to China or anywhere else in Asia?

This argument is bogus.

Check a map. You'll see this really big blue body of water off our West coast. AND we use it.
 
We won , you lost, get over it.

Seriously though, tarsands are a smoldering powderkeg that should not even be extracted
35 permanent jobs and higher gas prices. Hilarious.

Canadian oil is refined in our refineries before it's shipped overseas creating competition between American and foreign oil. Of course, that will cause gas prices to rise. Republicans don't seem to understand that Canadian oil is foreign oil. Who owns the refineries? The Koch Bros. It's estimated they could make a hundred billion dollars. Not "million". "BILLION".

So the GOP plan is 35 jobs, higher gas prices and billions to billionaires. And America has bought into it. Hilarious! Truly Hilarious!
thanks for spending millions in taxpayer $$$ to secure 35 jobs Repubs :bye1:

America doesn't spend a dime. Not one thin dime. Not a penny of taxpayers dollars is going into Keystone XL.

:lol:
Au contraire my cute little injun princess-

Repubs are spending MILLIONS in US Taxpayer dollars $$$ holding vote after vote after vote on the same things just like they did to repeal obamneycare. Costs money to have staff, electricity, security, etc.. to keep the capitol functioning. More than you realize.

Health Care Law Repeal Efforts By House GOP Cost Nearly 50 Million CBS Report :thup:
CBS' Nancy Cordes reported Wednesday that Republicans' many fruitless attempts at repealing the Affordable Care Act have taken up at least 80 hours of time on the House floor since 2010, amounting to two full work weeks. As the House, according to the Congressional Research Service, costs taxpayers $24 million a week to operate, those two weeks amounted to a total cost of approximately $48 million.

When they are in session it costs $24 million a week no matter what they are doing according to the study.
 
CNN s Van Jones says Keystone pipeline only creates 35 permanent jobs PunditFact

Contrary To GOP Promises Keystone XL Pipeline Will Only Create 35 Permanent Jobs

Republicans and conservative Democrats have continuously pushed for this pipeline’s approval is due to the huge windfall it will create for oil companies, specifically the Koch Bros. A report completed last year shows that the Kochs stand to make $100 billion from the passage of the Keystone extension. That’s billion, not million.

Republicans can’t just go to the people and say that we need to make sure insanely rich billionaires need to be given an opportunity to become even more insanely wealthy, environmental impacts be damned. Of course not. Therefore, they need to go out and claim that the project will create tons of jobs, help the country’s economy and fulfill its energy needs. Or, in other words, lie. Lie through their teeth.

Fox News host Keystone pipeline would create tens of thousands of jobs PunditFact

Fox News host: Keystone pipeline would create 'tens of thousands of jobs'

As far as new jobs go, the State Department estimates the operation of the pipeline will only create 35 permanent, full-time jobs and 15 temporary contractors. The full-time workers would be "required for annual operations, including routine inspections, maintenance and repair." Some would work in a Nebraska field office.

The lack of many full-time positions makes sense, given that the project is to build a pipeline so that tar sands can travel without the need of rail cars or ships.



-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Well, there you have it. Maybe we are "misunderestimating" Republicans. Maybe they mean 35 permanent jobs and tens of thousands of jobs cleaning up the fucking mess.

Another huge GOP disaster looms on the horizon. Will this country never learn?
The Keystone Pipeline would have created thousands of temporary jobs during construction which would have been a much needed stimulus during the recession. Today it's value in job creation is minimal. The pipeline would carry Canadian oil to ports on the Gulf Coast for shipment around the world. The big winners would be Canadian oil companies, operators of the pipeline and oil shippers. The question is whether the damage to the environment is worth the additional oil that could be delivered to the world market.

That's just insane. Your own EIA has stated that 80% of the crude being refined is staying in the domestic market.


--- link?
 
I do have to admit, the Keystone Pipeline issue has been way over-blown. It won't create very many American Jobs. Canadians will actually be the biggest winners if it happens. Much ado about nothing in my opinion. Build it, or don't build it. It won't make or break our Nation.
 
We won , you lost, get over it.

Seriously though, tarsands are a smoldering powderkeg that should not even be extracted
35 permanent jobs and higher gas prices. Hilarious.

Canadian oil is refined in our refineries before it's shipped overseas creating competition between American and foreign oil. Of course, that will cause gas prices to rise. Republicans don't seem to understand that Canadian oil is foreign oil. Who owns the refineries? The Koch Bros. It's estimated they could make a hundred billion dollars. Not "million". "BILLION".

So the GOP plan is 35 jobs, higher gas prices and billions to billionaires. And America has bought into it. Hilarious! Truly Hilarious!
thanks for spending millions in taxpayer $$$ to secure 35 jobs Repubs :bye1:

America doesn't spend a dime. Not one thin dime. Not a penny of taxpayers dollars is going into Keystone XL.

:lol:
Au contraire my cute little injun princess-

Repubs are spending MILLIONS in US Taxpayer dollars $$$ holding vote after vote after vote on the same things just like they did to repeal obamneycare. Costs money to have staff, electricity, security, etc.. to keep the capitol functioning. More than you realize.

Health Care Law Repeal Efforts By House GOP Cost Nearly 50 Million CBS Report :thup:
CBS' Nancy Cordes reported Wednesday that Republicans' many fruitless attempts at repealing the Affordable Care Act have taken up at least 80 hours of time on the House floor since 2010, amounting to two full work weeks. As the House, according to the Congressional Research Service, costs taxpayers $24 million a week to operate, those two weeks amounted to a total cost of approximately $48 million.

When they are in session it costs $24 million a week no matter what they are doing according to the study.
The diff is that the taxpayers are getting zilch in return.
 
I do have to admit, the Keystone Pipeline issue has been way over-blown. It won't create very many American Jobs. Canadians will actually be the biggest winners if it happens. Much ado about nothing in my opinion. Build it, or don't build it. It won't make or break our Nation.

I posted that I agree, but I agree as a practical matter about jobs and benefits. However, I sort of disagree on a fundamental belief issue. If oil companies want to build a pipeline, and if they can secure easements across private property or local state govts grant them right aways, then the ONLY legit reason the fed govt should prevent it is if there's some showing that the danger to the general public can't be protected against, or at least the general benefit outweighs the danger.

There could be a spill; prolly would be if its built. But, we could require really careful monitoring in sensitive areas. And the train wrecks are pretty nasty too. I just see it as the greens' elitist attempts to tell people what to do with their own property.
 

Forum List

Back
Top