What the science says

[jc456]

what's emitting and where is it emitting from?

Photons are being emitted. From all matter above 0K.
All the time. In all directions. Whether warmer matter is near or far or not.

In all directions based off of what?

Why does heat rise?

In all directions based off of what?

Based off of photons moving in all directions.

Why does heat rise?

Define heat.

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

Do it again.
do what again?

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Photons are being emitted. From all matter above 0K.
All the time. In all directions. Whether warmer matter is near or far or not.

In all directions based off of what?

Why does heat rise?

In all directions based off of what?

Based off of photons moving in all directions.

Why does heat rise?

Define heat.

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

there you go saying IR is heat again. I thought you stated it wasn't. heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction.

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Photons are being emitted. From all matter above 0K.
All the time. In all directions. Whether warmer matter is near or far or not.

In all directions based off of what?

Why does heat rise?

In all directions based off of what?

Based off of photons moving in all directions.

Why does heat rise?

Define heat.

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

Do it again.
do what again?

Define heat.

 

[jc456]

In all directions based off of what?

Why does heat rise?

In all directions based off of what?

Based off of photons moving in all directions.

Why does heat rise?

Define heat.

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

Do it again.
do what again?

Define heat.

nope, I did it already. live with my initial post.

 

[jc456]

In all directions based off of what?

Why does heat rise?

In all directions based off of what?

Based off of photons moving in all directions.

Why does heat rise?

Define heat.

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

there you go saying IR is heat again. I thought you stated it wasn't. heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction.

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

In all directions based off of what?

Based off of photons moving in all directions.

Why does heat rise?

Define heat.

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

Do it again.
do what again?

Define heat.

nope, I did it already. live with my initial post.

If you really did, you could post it again.

But you didn't.....and you won't. What are you afraid of?

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

In all directions based off of what?

Based off of photons moving in all directions.

Why does heat rise?

Define heat.

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

there you go saying IR is heat again. I thought you stated it wasn't. heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction.

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

 

[jc456]

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

Do it again.
do what again?

Define heat.

nope, I did it already. live with my initial post.

If you really did, you could post it again.

But you didn't.....and you won't. What are you afraid of?

it's really simple to do a search by entering 'define heat' and search under jc456. it really is simple to do. you should try once.

 

[jc456]

I did that already. if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

photons

Based off what?

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

there you go saying IR is heat again. I thought you stated it wasn't. heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction.

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

Do it again.
do what again?

Define heat.

nope, I did it already. live with my initial post.

If you really did, you could post it again.

But you didn't.....and you won't. What are you afraid of?

it's really simple to do a search by entering 'define heat' and search under jc456. it really is simple to do. you should try once.

You don't remember your definition?

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

I did that already.

Do it again. Try to be precise.

if you lit a match and held it in your hand which direction does the heat go?

IR from the flame would travel in all directions.

Why are heat detectors in ceilings?

Because fires are bad.

there you go saying IR is heat again. I thought you stated it wasn't. heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction.

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

 

[IanC]

Interesting factoid. A candle won't burn without gravity to remove the heated air and replace it with fresh.

I think there is even a utube video demonstrating the effect in one of those high speed elevators going down under a fraction of g.

 

[IanC]

there you go saying IR is heat again. I thought you stated it wasn't. heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction.

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

Hahahaha, you might as well be trying to explain things to your dog.

Maybe that is unfair to dogs. Make it a fish. Hahahaha

 

[jc456]

there you go saying IR is heat again. I thought you stated it wasn't. heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction.

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?
yep!

What stops it?
Temperature

 

[jc456]

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

Hahahaha, you might as well be trying to explain things to your dog.

Maybe that is unfair to dogs. Make it a fish. Hahahaha

ahh the condescending puppy barks.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

there you go saying IR is heat again.

Nope. You'll notice I didn't use the word heat in that post.

Your thinking is so muddled, your questions are pointless.
IR from the flame goes in all directions. Do you deny that?

If you'd like to talk about where hot air that touches the flame moves, that's a completely different question.

Be precise, for once, please.

heat goes to cool so it only goes that direction

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?
yep!

What stops it?
Temperature

A temperature force field blocks IR, preventing it from traveling down to the ice?

 

[jc456]

If I light a match an inch above an ice cube, the heat only travels down?

nope, heat rises, the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer. And the IR doesn't hit it either.

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?
yep!

What stops it?
Temperature

A temperature force field blocks IR, preventing it from traveling down to the ice?

nature does.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

heat rises

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?

How do you know?

the ice underneath will eventually melt due to not being in a freezer.

It is in a freezer.

And the IR doesn't hit it either

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?

Does the ice have a force field?

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?
yep!

What stops it?
Temperature

A temperature force field blocks IR, preventing it from traveling down to the ice?

nature does.

How does nature prevent IR from traveling down to the ice?

 

[jc456]

Something you won't...can't...define, rises?
defined once, not again. use search in the application.

How do you know?

I feel it.

It is in a freezer.
well then it will remain as ice and your hand will get cold.

IR won't hit the ice below the match? Why?
since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere.

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?
yep!

What stops it?
Temperature

A temperature force field blocks IR, preventing it from traveling down to the ice?

nature does.

How does nature prevent IR from traveling down to the ice?

it should be tested for that answer.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

I feel it.

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?

since it is in a freezer, the IR will go nowhere

What stops it?

We're basing scientific discussions on what your nerve endings can detect?
yep!

What stops it?
Temperature

A temperature force field blocks IR, preventing it from traveling down to the ice?

nature does.

How does nature prevent IR from traveling down to the ice?

it should be tested for that answer.

Yes, you should run some tests to show that IR is magically blocked from going in certain directions.
You'll be famous!

In the meantime, downward IR from the atmosphere to the warmer ground, at night, shows the greenhouse effect is real.