Whose fault is it really?

wow sounds like a long period of peace before that surge of attacks near our election

Why do you think that the Taliban surge has anything to do with the US elections?

The rest of the world really doesn’t give a shit about the US elections, except as they might affect foreign. The Taliban certainly wouldn’t care because the Americans were gone and they weren’t coming back.
 
Our obligations in the Doha Accords were complete in the Summer of 2020. The extra troop reduction was done in the final months of 2020 over the objections of the Generals. The Taliban only fully complied with the truce and none of the peace measures of the Agreement. So Trump ignored all that while withdrawing the bulk of the forces. The forces that could be used as leverage to get the Taliban in compliance. But you want to blame Biden for not re-deploying enough troops to force them to comply? Did you want him to reconquer the 5 bases Trump abandoned too?
They weren't obligations on our part, moron. They were escape clauses.

Once again, you lte Biden off the hook.
 
So for you it wasn't an "Agreement for Bringing Peace to Afghanistan" but rather the Trumpybear Skedaddle plan?
It doesn't matter what they tried to sell it as. It had provisions and the Taliban violated those provisions. Biden failed to hold them accountable.
 
wow sounds like a long period of peace before that surge of attacks near our election

Afghan War Casualty Report: September 2020. At least 429 pro-government forces and 134 civilians were killed in Afghanistan in September.

That NYT's one is behind a paywall. It wasn't the elections, it was the continued withdrawal of American and our allies troops as well as the prospect of a complete withdrawal in the next year.
 
Why do you think that the Taliban surge has anything to do with the US elections?

The rest of the world really doesn’t give a shit about the US elections, except as they might affect foreign. The Taliban certainly wouldn’t care because the Americans were gone and they weren’t coming back.
to impact the elections.

americans we’re gone during the attacks mentioned in the post i responded to
 
Afghan War Casualty Report: September 2020. At least 429 pro-government forces and 134 civilians were killed in Afghanistan in September.

That NYT's one is behind a paywall. It wasn't the elections, it was the continued withdrawal of American and our allies troops as well as the prospect of a complete withdrawal in the next year.
nah it was the election
Afghan War Casualty Report: September 2020. At least 429 pro-government forces and 134 civilians were killed in Afghanistan in September.

That NYT's one is behind a paywall. It wasn't the elections, it was the continued withdrawal of American and our allies troops as well as the prospect of a complete withdrawal in the next year.
nab it was the election. We had over 5k troops there still at the time of these surges
 
It doesn't matter what they tried to sell it as. It had provisions and the Taliban violated those provisions. Biden failed to hold them accountable.

When I read the provisions of that agreement, it looks like an agreement that was set up to fail. We see that occasionally in business when you’re dealing with a sleazy operator like Donald Trump.

The terms are somewhat vague. Either side can easily claim a “default”, giving them the excuse to “void” at the drop of a hat.

If Donald Trump had been reelected, he probably would’ve voided the agreement on some pretext or other to avoid pulling the troops out of Afghanistan and having the same sort of PR fiasco that Biden had.

Biden actually pulled off the most successful withdrawal after losing a war in the history of the world.

With nothing like the nightmare that was Nixon, pulling out of Vietnam. Americans watched horror on television as people died while the last helicopters were leaving.

 
When I read the provisions of that agreement, it looks like an agreement that was set up to fail. We see that occasionally in business when you’re dealing with a sleazy operator like Donald Trump.

The terms are somewhat vague. Either side can easily claim a “default”, giving them the excuse to “void” at the drop of a hat.

If Donald Trump had been reelected, he probably would’ve voided the agreement on some pretext or other to avoid pulling the troops out of Afghanistan and having the same sort of PR fiasco that Biden had.

Biden actually pulled off the most successful withdrawal after losing a war in the history of the world.

With nothing like the nightmare that was Nixon, pulling out of Vietnam. Americans watched horror on television as people died while the last helicopters were leaving.

there was nothing vague about it, that why the UN all signed off on it
 
to impact the elections.

americans we’re gone during the attacks mentioned in the post i responded to

What would the Taliban care about who got elected in the USA? They hate you all. There has been no difference between Republicans or Democrats in the war. It doesn’t matter to the Taliban who sits in your White House.

The only people who are interested in whom wins American elections, are Putin, Xi, Kim, Erdogan, and Bondonaro.

All of the authoritarian dictators want Donald Trump to join their club because he’ll let them divide up the world between them.
 
What would the Taliban care about who got elected in the USA? They hate you all. There has been no difference between Republicans or Democrats in the war. It doesn’t matter to the Taliban who sits in your White House.

The only people who are interested in whom wins American elections, are Putin, Xi, Kim, Erdogan, and Bondonaro.

All of the authoritarian dictators want Donald Trump to join their club because he’ll let them divide up the world between them.
Lol, the Taliban loves Biden. He made them a top military and sent them billions after that. He should be executed for that alone.
 
What would the Taliban care about who got elected in the USA? They hate you all. There has been no difference between Republicans or Democrats in the war. It doesn’t matter to the Taliban who sits in your White House.

The only people who are interested in whom wins American elections, are Putin, Xi, Kim, Erdogan, and Bondonaro.

All of the authoritarian dictators want Donald Trump to join their club because he’ll let them divide up the world between them.
why? look what happened when they got xiden…a total surrender

of course they cared.
 
Why did Trump withdraw all those troops while allowing the Taliban to skate on 6 out of 7 of the Conditions agreed to before our withdrawal? How about those 5 bases Trump abandoned to the Taliban or the 5,000 fighters he force the Afghans to swap 1,000 Afghans held by the Taliban. That's twice as many Taliban fighter as troops that were left for Biden to complete the evacuation.

History will not be kind to the Trump implementation of his Skedaddle Accords, ops I mean Doha Accords......
Trump told the Taliban that if they interfered in any way with the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan or with the duly installed government, retaliation would be quick, certain, disastrous for the Taliban. And they knew he meant it.

He would have gotten every American citizen and at risk ally out who wanted out, gotten all our stuff out, and left the Afghan government in place and the Taliban in check.

Biden reversed all that and his deadly and chaotic withdrawal left billions of our equipment behind, at least some of it useful to the Taliban, and he left hundreds if not thousands of American citizens and our faithful allies behind, many to be hunted down, arrested, executed. And that is still going on.
 
there was nothing vague about it, that why the UN all signed off on it

There are no clear definitions on what constitutes breaches of the agreement. Vague clauses voiding the Agreement if the Taliban engage in or supports “terrorist activities” are a prime example.

If an angry teenager throws a rock at departing US soldiers, does that constitute a “terrorist activity”? Once Taliban becomes the official government of Afghanistan, then doesn’t the definition “terrorist activities” shift?

At the point that the Taliban becomes a government, the USA and its allies become the terrorists.

The attack that killed the 13 Americans at the airport was carried out by ISIS, not the Taliban. Does that count? Technically any act of terrorism carried out by anyone on either side in the entire country would void the agreement. That’s what we mean by vague provisions.
 
Trump told the Taliban that if they interfered in any way with the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan or with the duly installed government, retaliation would be quick, certain, disastrous for the Taliban. And they knew he meant it.

He would have gotten every American citizen and at risk ally out who wanted out, gotten all our stuff out, and left the Afghan government in place and the Taliban in check.

Biden reversed all that and his deadly and chaotic withdrawal left billions of our equipment behind, at least some of it useful to the Taliban, and he left hundreds if not thousands of American citizens and our faithful allies behind, many to be hunted down, arrested, executed. And that is still going on.
the taliban won big time when xiden got elected

the world suffered, the poor women of afghan suffered…

frankly xiden’s surrender was a key reason why putin knew it was the right time to invade ukraine again
 
There are no clear definitions on what constitutes breaches of the agreement. Vague clauses voiding the Agreement if the Taliban engage in or supports “terrorist activities” are a prime example.

If an angry teenager throws a rock at departing US soldiers, does that constitute a “terrorist activity”? Once Taliban becomes the official government of Afghanistan, then doesn’t the definition “terrorist activities” shift?

At the point that the Taliban becomes a government, the USA and its allies become the terrorists.

The attack that killed the 13 Americans at the airport was carried out by ISIS, not the Taliban. Does that count? Technically any act of terrorism carried out by anyone on either side in the entire country would void the agreement. That’s what we mean by vague provisions.
nah it was clear. we didn’t have to leave. xiden did anyway cause rhe ignored it

the world loved the agreement, sadly rhe dembots put xiden in charge and the peace path was lost and we wanted rhe contempt of your queen
 
Got a cite for my “claim”? Went through all my posts and couldn’t find it. Smells like another MAGA lie! :cool-45:
And there it is. When you can't refute a statement you call it a MAGA lie. With no proof, only what your masters tell you. Pathetic and furthering your lies.
 
why? look what happened when they got xiden…a total surrender

of course they cared.

The Agreement which surrendered the country to the Taliban, was negotiated and signed by Donald Trump. All of the troop drawdowns and closing of military bases happened before Biden’s inauguration.

Biden had to send 3000 troops back into Afghanistan to complete the airlift and final withdrawal in some things that approach an orderly fashion.

Joe Biden completed the final withdrawal of forces under the Agreement but didn’t negotiate it or sign it.
 

Forum List

Back
Top