11 Year Old Girl Is Pregnant, Sparks Abortion Debate

[FA_Q2]

Oh stop it


You're argument is completely ridiculous and has no basis in the OP at all. Stop trying to make this little girl into something she's not. This isn't about someone who choose to have sex or someone who purchased birth control. I don't care how "old" you think she may look.

You are tossing up nonsense statements in an attempt to avoid the argument. Women in Chile don't get a choice. This little girl doesn't have a choice. She didn't choose to be raped, she didn't choose to have a disgusting mother, and she doesn't get to choose what happens with her pregnancy at this point.

In Chile, women are not allowed to have an abortion to save their life.

Do you know for a fact that this wasn't consensual sex and therefore the rape was merely stautory?

We are passed rape and onto molestation.

She was far too young, period.

 

[Katzndogz]

Oh stop it


You're argument is completely ridiculous and has no basis in the OP at all. Stop trying to make this little girl into something she's not. This isn't about someone who choose to have sex or someone who purchased birth control. I don't care how "old" you think she may look.

You are tossing up nonsense statements in an attempt to avoid the argument. Women in Chile don't get a choice. This little girl doesn't have a choice. She didn't choose to be raped, she didn't choose to have a disgusting mother, and she doesn't get to choose what happens with her pregnancy at this point.

In Chile, women are not allowed to have an abortion to save their life.

Do you know for a fact that this wasn't consensual sex and therefore the rape was merely stautory?

We are passed rape and onto molestation.

She was far too young, period.

If she's far too young, she's far too young period. She's far too young to decide whether or not she wants an abortion. She can't be old enough when it suits and far too young when it doesn't.

 

[Uncensored2008]

Abortion is not even allowed in cases of rape. Its a total blanket ban, which is completely wrong.

My view - a child should not be having a child. She is 11 years old, she has been raped and abused by someone who should have been caring for her, she should have a termination in order to protect her health, and her life.

Opinions?

You should fly to Chile and DEMAND they obey you and offer abortion on demand.

After that, you should make the rounds to Muslims countries and demand abortion on demand.

Edit: Didn't notice this was the CDZ

 

[FA_Q2]

Do you know for a fact that this wasn't consensual sex and therefore the rape was merely stautory?

We are passed rape and onto molestation.

She was far too young, period.

If she's far too young, she's far too young period. She's far too young to decide whether or not she wants an abortion. She can't be old enough when it suits and far too young when it doesn't.

You can when you are talking about two completely different issues. She IS tou young to decide on an abortion HOWEVER she is in a situation that demands an answer. Simple as that. She might be too young to have sex and too young to have an abortion but she has already had sex (through rape) so not she is STUCK with the latter situation. Nothing can be done t rectify it. She is to young to have a baby as well. There is really only 2 outcomes and 2 decent options, she either passes on the abortion or she gets one. Trying to take the decision out of her hands only allows the parents to FORCE an abortion on her.

How would you feel if anyone, at any age, FORCED you to have an abortion? Can you square that with yourself?

 

[Flopper]

Do they even sell plan B in Chile?

Why are you obsessed with trying to make this little girl seem like an adult Katz?

Not legally

 

[AmyNation]

All abortion was abolished in Chile by the former dictator in 89'. The majority of Chileans agree that there should be an exception for health of the mother. However the current president is devout and the church plays a huge role in their policy decision.

 

[ABikerSailor]

Yanno......................all of you who think she should have the kid, should think back to when you were 11 or 12 years old.

Did YOU have the experience, the intelligence and the knowledge of how to raise a child at that age?

If not.....................why are you trying to force her into having the child?

 

[S.J.]

Yanno......................all of you who think she should have the kid, should think back to when you were 11 or 12 years old.

Did YOU have the experience, the intelligence and the knowledge of how to raise a child at that age?

If not.....................why are you trying to force her into having the child?

Why are you trying to force her to have an abortion?

 

[ABikerSailor]

Yanno......................all of you who think she should have the kid, should think back to when you were 11 or 12 years old.

Did YOU have the experience, the intelligence and the knowledge of how to raise a child at that age?

If not.....................why are you trying to force her into having the child?

Why are you trying to force her to have an abortion?

Why are you trying to force her to have a child when she's neither mentally, physically (remember, they said it could endanger her life) or emotionally prepared to do it?

Like I said.................at the age of 11 or 12, did you have the physical, emotional, or mental strength to raise a child?

 

[S.J.]

Yanno......................all of you who think she should have the kid, should think back to when you were 11 or 12 years old.

Did YOU have the experience, the intelligence and the knowledge of how to raise a child at that age?

If not.....................why are you trying to force her into having the child?

Why are you trying to force her to have an abortion?

Why are you trying to force her to have a child when she's neither mentally, physically (remember, they said it could endanger her life) or emotionally prepared to do it?

Like I said.................at the age of 11 or 12, did you have the physical, emotional, or mental strength to raise a child?

I'm not trying to force her to do anything, but you sure seem to be.

 

[ABikerSailor]

Apparently, you want her to have the kid, even if she's not ready to do so.

 

[Uncensored2008]

The left weeps at the prospect of live human birth.

 

[AmyNation]

The left weeps at the prospect of live human birth.

No, at the prospect of an 11 year old rape victim dying trying to give birth.

 

[Katzndogz]

Give her a C-Section. The law forbids abortion. Or, change the law. It was just done in Ireland.

 

[Uncensored2008]

No, at the prospect of an 11 year old rape victim dying trying to give birth.

As sad as it is, 11 year olds give birth all the time,

If this were in Brazil instead of Chile - it wouldn't be news. If it were in Venezuela, it would be the norm.

 

[AmyNation]

In Brazil and Venezuela she would have the right to have an abortion if the pregnancy threatened her life.

 

[Uncensored2008]

In Brazil and Venezuela she would have the right to have an abortion if the pregnancy threatened her life.

Which means that American abortion promoters would ignore her and she would be off to have the baby as thousands of other 11 year olds do each year.

 

[AmyNation]

What?

Why are you referencing anything American? We are talking about the fact that an 11 year old rape victim cannot get a life saving abortion in Chile.

 

[Uncensored2008]

What?

Why are you referencing anything American? We are talking about the fact that an 11 year old rape victim cannot get a life saving abortion in Chile.

"Life saving" is nonsense the pro-abortion advocates have thrown out. The girl has a normal pregnancy - no different than any other.

Now I support abortion in the case of rape, but I am not in Chile and have no desire to force my views on them. American abortion promoters are using this case to push their agenda. IF the girl were in Brazil, she would be ignored, because she wouldn't be of use as a pawn for Abortion promoters.

In the 3rd world, 11 year olds have babies every single day.

 

[AmyNation]

So, you dispute the OP, in which doctors are saying her life and health are at risk?

Seems kind of odd to wait 13 pages to question the OP...