candycorn
Diamond Member
Let's just look at history to prove how wrong the OP is
1992 - George Bush Sr.'s closest, more conservative, opponent? Pat Buchanan. Buchanan vs. Bill Clinton?
1996 - Bob Dole's closest, more conservative, opponent? Again, Pat Buchanan. Other conservative-er competitors, Steve Forbes and Alan Keyes.
2008 - McCain's more conservative competition? Romney, Huckabee, Alan Keyes, Duncan Hunter, Tom Tancredo, Sam Brownback. Which of those guys beats Obama in 2008?
2012 - Romney's more conservative competition? Rick Santorum, Herman Cain, Newt Gingrich, Rick Perry, Michelle Bachmann,
see any winners in that crowd?
See any winners in any of the aforementioned conservatives?
Again... You are asking me to give you examples of people who could have beaten Obama when no one beat Obama! I've already said, Conservatives lacked a voice! That means, they did not have a candidate who could win... and they didn't win. I don't get the point of this exercise...I am supposed to give you a name of someone who could have won but we already know who won and who could have potentially won by the results.
No.
You're supposed to support your thesis.
You brought it up....
There were at least 4 conservatives in the field, Gingrich, Perry, Paul, and Bachman. They didn't get a single delegate as I recall. They didn't win a single primary either if I recall.
Rick Santorum was about as conservative as the four I mentioned (I put him aside because he did win some states) and he was drubbed.
But your thesis seems to be that if any of those 5 elevated to the General Election, this groundswell of discontented voters would have risen up out of nowhere and elected them when the guy who beat them was taken to the woodshed by Obama?
You seem to be very confused. Maybe it's all that extra splooge going to your bimbo brain? You seem to be making my "thesis" into some idiotic argument that I never made. I clearly stated that the GOP did not have a strong conservative voice, that Conservatives lacked a strong voice.... Are you not registering my words here? The Conservative candidate who could have beaten Obama did not exist, did not run, wasn't an option for voters. I can't make a case for someone who didn't exist, didn't run or wasn't an option.
Yes, Rick Santorum was more conservative than Mitt Romney! He didn't win the primary so we don't know how well he might have done against Obama. We can't re-live the past so there is no way for us to confirm speculations on this, it's just a futile gesture that means absolutely nothing at this point. In both 2008 and 2012, the GOP nominated a moderate instead of a Conservative and they lost. If they do it again in 2016, they will lose again.
Newt Gingrich is about a strong a conservative voice as there ever has been. Santorum won 11 primaries. And you think someone running to his right would have won more?
Rest easy.