Is the Occupation of the West Bank Morally Justified?

[irosie91]

You just keep standing idly by like the German citizens did.

what is remarkable about German citizens not getting into theological discussion?

 

[ding]

What is unjustified about a nation liberating its land?
Go on set a standard that you yourself don't defy.

So it was a lie that Israel made a preemptive attack to defend themselves?

Are you saying their firing the first shot was all about taking back their land?

 

[rylah]

Ummmm... it was Christians who gave it back.

And it were them who were kicked out...

 

[ding]

what is remarkable about German citizens not getting into theological discussion?

Rosie, the comment was about not following one's conscience.

 

[irosie91]

If only you examined your conscience as closely.

You have provided a good example of THE
SUBJUNCTIVE in a nonsense statement

 

[ding]

And it were them who were kicked out...

That's stupid. The state of Israel only exists today because of the goodwill of Christians.

Israel's occupation of Palestine is not morally justified.

 

[ding]

You have provided a good example of THE
SUBJUNCTIVE in a nonsense statement

You should worry about your conscience more.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

That's is stupid. The state of Israel only exists today because of the goodwill of Christians.

Israel's occupation of Palestine is not morally justified.

Have you explained yet who Israel should hand any territory?

 

[irosie91]

Give me a break. When the US defeated Mexico we gave back Mexico.

And Israel isn't liberating Palestine. They are subjugating them.

subjugating whom?

 

[ding]

Have you explained yet who Israel should hand any territory?

Palestine. Isn't that who Jordan deeded the title to?

 

[ding]

subjugating whom?

The inhabitants of the occupied lands that aren't Israeli settlers.

 

[rylah]

So it was a lie that Israel made a preemptive attack to defend themselves?

Are you saying their firing the first shot was all about taking back their land?

Israel was already attacked prior to that,
our grandparents dug mass graves in preparation, for themselves.

 

[irosie91]

Palestine. Isn't that who Jordan deeded the title to?

no Jordan did not hold the deed

 

[ding]

Israel was already attacked prior to that,
our grandparents dug mass graves in preparation, for themselves.

They dug their graves after they were attacked?

 

[irosie91]

The inhabitants of the occupied lands that aren't Israeli settlers.

what are the "occupied lands" and what are
"israeli settlers" ?

 

[Indeependent]

Give me a break. When the US defeated Mexico we gave back Mexico.

And Israel isn't liberating Palestine. They are subjugating them.

The Palestinians will really appreciate being pushed into Gaza when Jordan is given the land and kicks them out.

 

[ding]

no Jordan did not hold the deed

Who do you think did?

 

[Indeependent]

They dug their graves after they were attacked?

The Arabs were broadcasting their impending attack on the radio.

 

[ding]

The Palestinians will really appreciate being pushed into Gaza when Jordan is given the land and kicks them out.

Give back the land and let's find out.

Because Israel has no moral argument to continue their occupation. It's not their land.

 

[ding]

The Arabs were broadcasting their impending attack on the radio.

The initial occupation isn't in question. The continued occupation is.