Reincarnation, a universe that has always existed. Got it.per interpretation ...
the heavenly religion of antiquity - the triumph of good vs evil - as prescribed to a&e for their self determination and admission to the everlasting as an equal, their request is required as that is the judgement made as which was their triumph before admission is allowed.
- your scenario would be reincarnation at best. no sinners will pass the pearly gates.