P F Tinmore, et al,
Yeah, you are quite today.
(COMMENT)Your assertion was that "The British Mandate was not a state. It was a temporarily appointed administration."
Which is 100% correct. Palestine did not belong to Britain/Mandate, or the LoN, or the UN. If it was they could have just ceded it to Israel. Mission accomplished. However it was not theirs to give away and they did not.
Your statement was right, but the inference was wrong. You need to read the entire response I gave. Including: "Your hidden(unspoken) implication was that the State of Israel could not be a successor state because the British administration under the Mandate was not a "state." WRONG... "
(COMMENT)So, whose land was it. Remember, you yourself said in an earlier post that the land was not up for grabs.
Military control does not mean ownership.• 2359 hrs 14 May 1848: The territory was under the control of the Mandatory.
Appointed government does not mean ownership.• Midnight 14/15 May 1948: Transferred to the UNPC (Successor Government).
Resolution 181 was not implemented. There was no territory transferred to Israel by resolution 181.• Midnight 14/15 May 1948: Israel Declares Independence (self-determination) on that territory outlined in GA/RES/181(II).
There again, there were no Partition Plan Boundaries.• Morning 15 May 1948: Palestinian Irregulars and Arab League Forces attack. Boundaries outlined in the Partition Plan become fluid.
The armistice lines were specifically not to be political or territorial borders. They did not define any Israeli territory.• March/April 1949: Armistice Agreements and lines draw relative to the FEBA.
Are you implying that Israel acquired Palestinian land from Palestine's neighbors? Interesting legal concept.On the establishment of the individual Armistice Agreements, Israel was sovereign and independent; and occupying territory acquired while in pursuit of retreating Arab Forces --- with the remainder of the territory occupied by the respective Arab League states.
Most Respectfully,
R
No they acquired it the same way Jordan, Syria and Iraq did, from the LoN mandate the land was part of. You confuse yourself with mandate and mandatory