The political spectrum

[Blues Man]

Are you saying im living in a fake anarchist society that i imagined? lol

You are not living in an anarchistic society

 

[TNHarley]

I guess since I support capitalism, I am living in a dreamworld but it isnt prsacticed anywhere, so it doesnt actually exist

 

[Harpy Eagle]

Not all social contracts involve a government

Of course they do, even if it is not a formal government. A group of elders making choices for the society is a government

 

[TNHarley]

That wiki says that there was an egalitarian political structure therefore there is no anarchy.

You understand that means no one person has more power than another, right?

 

[Blues Man]

why is it people dont read their own shit when it proves them wrong??

it says right there in your link that its political disorder,,

how can there be disorder if it doesnt exist??

What is the most common factor ?

No government, no authority

When people say there was anarchy is the senate because it became disorderly, that is more of a euphemism because the order and the authority is still present in any government body is it not?

 

[Blues Man]

You understand that means no one person has more power than another, right?

Doesn't matter.

If there is order imposed then there is no anarchy.

If no one has more power than another then murder is accepted.

If this society has any laws at all it is not anarchistic.

 

[Blues Man]

I guess since I support capitalism, I am living in a dreamworld but it isnt prsacticed anywhere, so it doesnt actually exist

Capitalism in its purest form does not exist.

It's like when people use the word socialism to describe a government program.

 

[TNHarley]

Of course they do, even if it is not a formal government. A group of elders making choices for the society is a government

Anarchist social contract : Do onto others
Where is the govt in that?

 

[TNHarley]

Doesn't matter.

If there is order imposed then there is no anarchy.

If no one has more power than another then murder is accepted.

If this society has any laws at all it is not anarchistic.

Who said that was an order or law? You simply made that up.

 

[TNHarley]

Capitalism in its purest form does not exist.

It's like when people use the word socialism to describe a government program.

I just said that.

 

[progressive hunter]

Who said that was an order or law? You simply made that up.

thats all they can do is make shit up,,

 

[Harpy Eagle]

Anarchist social contract : Do onto others
Where is the govt in that?

More fairy tales that have never exited in human history.

In reality the anarchist social contract is "Do onto others before they do unto you"

 

[TNHarley]

More fairy tales that have never exited in human history.

In reality the anarchist social contract is "Do onto others before they do unto you"

More lies

 

[TruthNotBS]

Not always

By what authority will social contracts be enforced and your rights recognized and protected, if not by a government authority?

 

[TNHarley]

By what authority will social contracts be enforced and your rights recognized and protected, if not by a government authority?

Yourself. Your entire community.

 

[TruthNotBS]

Yourself. Your entire community.

Yourself? You're the police, judge, and executioner? Are you like "Judge-Dread", going around hurting people if they break their contract with you? There are no official legislative bodies, no courts of law, or police in your anarchist society? What if there are people who don't recognize your property rights, that are only recognized by you and not everyone in your anarchist society? Whose going to protect you from me, the cult leader, who has almost half (40%) of the community considering him their guru and king?

 

[TNHarley]

Yourself? You're the police, judge, and executioner? Are you like "Judge-Dread", going around hurting people if they break their contract with you? There are no official legislative bodies, no courts of law, or police in your anarchist society? What if there are people who don't recognize your property rights, that are only recognized by you and not everyone in your anarchist society? Whose going to protect you from me, the cult leader, who has almost half (40%) of the community considering him their guru and king?

Doesnt sound like an anarchist society at all.

 

[TruthNotBS]

Doesnt sound like an anarchist society at all.

Anarchist "society" is an oxymoron. To have a society you need to have a system in place, that can establish the rules for social contracts, and the ability to enforce and protect them and your rights. If you don't have that in place, it's the law of the jungle. Might makes right. You have chaos, no law and order.

 

[TNHarley]

Anarchist "society" is an oxymoron. To have a society you need to have a system that can establish the rules for social contracts, and the ability to enforce and protect them and your rights. If you don't have that in place, it's the law of the jungle. Might makes right. You have chaos, no law and order.

Wrong

 

[TruthNotBS]

Wrong

How am I wrong? Explain.