I'm sure he will answer that God is not subject to the laws he requires of us. And, he would be correct. But, why? Depends on what brand of Christianity you ask for their doctrine. The most common answer would be that "God" is spirit and thus not tempted with a physical body. But, who were the 3rd of Heaven that were cast out? Did they have bodies when they followed Lucifer? They were spirits as well because they did not nor have ever been given a physical body. They obviously sinned without a physical body. That means that "sin" requires knowledge to sin. Other than that, it's just a "mistake." That means that if God is a spirit body personage, he could also sin. But, that could not be so. God is God because he is perfect and said he will lead us back to him for he knows everything about the entire universe. He could not guarantee to save us if he did not know everything and I mean everything. And, certainly not if he could also sin. So, what is the answer. The answer is simple and is in the resurrection of the just. Paul speaks of the resurrection in First Corinthians Chapter 15 where he speaks of a kingdom, glory a mansion where there is no corruption, the Celestial glory or kingdom. And, to reach this, our bodies have to reunite with our spirit bodies in a Celestial resurrection and obtain the Celestial Kingdom or Glory. One of his many mansions. Well, we know that Jehovah came down off His throne, gained a physical body in Jesus Christ. He atoned for our sins and was Celestially resurrected and has no corruption and therefore cannot sin.
Now, the challenge then becomes what about Jehovah before he came down and was resurrected. If you are Christian and believe that the Father and Son are the same person or spirit, then you cannot claim God could not have sinned prior to coming to the earth and being resurrected. To rectify this challenge, the Father and Son would have to be separate and distinct personages. Even more so, the Father would therefore have to be a resurrected being as well into an incorruptible body. Therefore, as man is now, God the Father once was. As God is now, Man may become. Oh yes! Your question proves Mormon Doctrine true and correct if Christianity is the true religion. IN the great council in heaven, Father gathered all his spirit children together, including Jehovah and Lucifer. He explained His plan to give all of his children an opportunity to have all that he has including a physical resurrected body. It's called, the Plan of Salvation or Happiness. Lucifer didn't like the fact we would have to descend to the earth, receive a body, go through all sorts of hardships and experiences, then die, then our spirits go to paradise or hell to await the judgment day and resurrection. And, that most would probably end up in the other two lower levels of Heaven, Terrestrial and Telestial (Stars). So, he said no thank you to making a covenant with Father in Heaven and support His Plan of Salvation. He also stirred up anger and a third of the hosts (spirit children) followed Lucifer and were also cast out never to receive salvation. Lucifer became Satan. On the other hand, Jehovah said that he would follow Father in Heaven and Father in Heaven gave him a position of being the Son of God, with power and authority to be instrumental in the beginnings of the redemption of future mankind. Jehovah and Michael organized the universe under the direction of Heavenly Father and prepare worlds for His spirit children to reside on. Earth was specially made because that is where Father would provide a Savior from sin, Jehovah who would become Jesus the Christ. The remaining two-thirds followed Jehovah and we are that part.
Father in Heaven came from a universe and went through the same things as we are going through. He died and was resurrected and received his mansion, the universe we live in. And, with our mother in Heaven our intelligence which has always existed, receive spirit bodies, much finer of material than physical earthly bodies. Now, we have the same opportunity as Father in Heaven to have all the happiness and salvation He has. So, both the Father and Son are physically resurrected beings perfect and incorruptible without sin. We are made spiritually and physically in their Image going through out testing of our faith. They have given us prophets and apostles to communicate this information to us throughout the ages. And, we have two things to also help us, The light of Christ (our conscience) and The influence and possible gift of the Holy Ghost. The Holy Ghost is a spirit still. So, we are made in Father's image and are working to become sinless in the resurrection.
If you read and comprehend the actual content of the Holy Scriptures.....you will logically deduct that Man is indeed made in the image of God. God is a Spirit, and must be worshiped IN SPIRIT and TRUTH (John 4:24). Thus...........it cannot be mankind's physical appearance that reflects the image of God.....as God is a spirit Being, Spirits do not have flesh and blood (Luke 24:39)So we are all sinners while God is not. Doesn't that contradict that we are made in his image?
How then is man made in the image of God? God breathed man's Spirit into the physical body that was made up from elements common to the earth (by majority CARBON BASED elements) -- Genesis 2:7
The scriptures define death as THE SPIRIT (Life) leaving the body, ".........For, as the body without the Spirit is dead......so faith without works is also dead" -- James 2:26
When a person dies.........the flesh goes back to the dust from which it came, but the Spirit returns to God, its creator....to judge by laws that define SIN. (Eccl. 12:7)
All men are born perfectly without sin in their life, as Jesus states that the kingdom of God/Heaven is reflected in the life of a Child. (Matthew 18:3) N.T. The Old Law (O.T.) declares basically the same thing ..........the sons of men do not inherit sin from their fathers, each soul is responsible for their own decisions/judgments that lead to sin (Ez. 18:20).
This begs to ask the question........if all men are born into sin, as some religions teach and call it "original sin" (which is not found in any text in the Holy Bible).........was Jesus born (born of a woman, born under the law -- Gal. 4:4) with Original Sin? If not why not?
The Apostle states that sin entered the world by the free will choices made by one man (ADAM).......men must ACT to choose sin before sin can be imputed upon man (Romans 5:12) Sin is defined as the breaking of God's law..........one must break these laws in order to be charged with sin (1 John 3:4)
How then is man LIKE GOD as stated in Genesis? That is made clear with no ambiguity, God is God because He knows the difference between Good and Evil, being omniscient, God always chooses righteousness over evil...man, became like God when man garnered the ability to choose between Good and Evil..........man is not omniscient (all knowing) so God declared,
"And the Lord God said, Behold........the man is become as one of US (the Godhead), to know good and evil, now least he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life and eat and live forever....." -- Genesis 3:22 God removed Adam and Eve from the Garden He had prepared for them, from that time forward......man was cursed to earn his living with the sweat of his brow. (Genesis 3:19).....and to DIE.
Can anyone image a person such as Hitler...........being gifted with immortality? The free will sin of Adam brought physical death to all mankind (Romans 5:12-21).........the sin free life of ONE MAN (Jesus Christ) purchased eternal life of man's spirit through His sacrificial blood......Jesus took the sins of the world upon His sin free body (1 Peter 2:24, 1 John 2:2, John 1:29)