Who Are The Palestinians? Part 2

[Hollie]

What legal or ethical reasons are those? That only majorities should have rights to self-determination, sovereignty and independence?

So, for example, the Catalans, as a minority, are prohibited from having rights to self-determination, sovereignty and independence?

A Jewish minority being granted 56% of land in a proposed nation where they cumulatively own less than 5% of the land??? To the obvious extent that they were not a 'dependent minority' they are not entitled to state 'independence" You're hilarious

56%?? How many times is with its' Palestinian majority Jordan bigger than Israel? How many times?

Knock-knock - do Indians own most of the land in the US?

Jordan is irrelevant to historic Palestine

Why because it has a Palestinian majority?
Because it's 100% Palestinian Arab state, where Jews were not allowed to live?

Arabs received much more than half the land already.

Typically you bottom-feeders assume that this level of flipping psychology is fool-proof---all the more pathetic...indeed the minority of Jews are permitted to 'live' in Palestine as was the case---NOT TO RAVAGE THE MAJORITY POPULATION AND STEAL FROM AND EXPEL 800,000 NATIVE PALESTINIANS...any questions Gestapo-girl???

Did you know that punctuation was a Joooooo invention?

 

[P F Tinmore]

It doesn't say Israel or Jewish state.

It doesn't HAVE to, remember? That was the ENTIRE point of this line of the questioning. The territory was already a State in 1923. You have already established that.

What the Mandate agreement does then, is define that State and outline provisions for the government of that already existing State -- and that was the reconstitution of the Jewish national home with a Jewish government.

Then what about all of the Palestinians who became citizens in 1925?

 

[Ventura77]

P F Tinmore

If you are trying to argue that Israel is a State and that it was created from the existing rights of the Jewish people to a national homeland but that it SHOULD have incorporated all of the Arabs into that state -- that is an entirely different argument. Pick your poison and stick with it.

Tinmore...she is a propagandist...she works from pre-scripted material written expressly for the internet...even the act of engaging these snakes in debate is a losing proposition because---as I have demonstrated---even when they are confronted with unalterable facts they reply with double-doses of bullshit

 

[Hollie]

P F Tinmore

If you are trying to argue that Israel is a State and that it was created from the existing rights of the Jewish people to a national homeland but that it SHOULD have incorporated all of the Arabs into that state -- that is an entirely different argument. Pick your poison and stick with it.

Tinmore...she is a propagandist...she works from pre-scripted material written expressly for the internet...even the act of engaging these snakes in debate is a losing proposition because---as I have demonstrated---even when they are confronted with unalterable facts they reply with double-doses of bullshit

I didn’t find any facts in your link to “failedmessiah.com”. As you have demonstrated, you’re fact-less.

 

[Shusha]

Then what about all of the Palestinians who became citizens in 1925?

What about them? They would have lived nice, enjoyable, peaceful lives in Israel if they hadn't been violently hostile.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Then what about all of the Palestinians who became citizens in 1925?

What about them? They would have lived nice, enjoyable, peaceful lives in Israel if they hadn't been violently hostile.

BS, virtually all of them were unarmed civilians at home.

 

[Shusha]

BS, virtually all of them were unarmed civilians at home.

Oh give me a break. Like the Gazans of today? Just innocent unarmed civilians.

 

[P F Tinmore]

BS, virtually all of them were unarmed civilians at home.

Oh give me a break. Like the Gazans of today? Just innocent unarmed civilians.

Oh jeese.

 

[Hollie]

Then what about all of the Palestinians who became citizens in 1925?

What about them? They would have lived nice, enjoyable, peaceful lives in Israel if they hadn't been violently hostile.

BS, virtually all of them were unarmed civilians at home.

Link?

 

[Shusha]

BS, virtually all of them were unarmed civilians at home.

Oh give me a break. Like the Gazans of today? Just innocent unarmed civilians.

Oh jeese.

Are you arguing that the resistance is over and there are no more attacks on Israel from Gaza? When did that happen?

And you are also arguing that there has never been any resistance?

 

[P F Tinmore]

BS, virtually all of them were unarmed civilians at home.

Oh give me a break. Like the Gazans of today? Just innocent unarmed civilians.

Oh jeese.

Are you arguing that the resistance is over and there are no more attacks on Israel from Gaza? When did that happen?

And you are also arguing that there has never been any resistance?

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

 

[Shusha]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

The British disarmed the Palestinians and expelled all their leaders in 1939. They had almost nothing. That is how Israel could expel 300,000 people in a few months. The Palestinians were defenseless.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

The British disarmed the Palestinians and expelled all their leaders in 1939. They had almost nothing. That is how Israel could expel 300,000 people in a few months. The Palestinians were defenseless.

Then how do you think they rose up again in 1947 against the Jews after the UN partition?

Or how do you think about the British actually fighting on the side of the Hashemite Kingdom and training them as well in order to attack Israel in May of 1948?

How did all of those weapons find their way to the Arabs?

(Uhmmmm, could there have been any "contraband")

 

[Ventura77]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

The British disarmed the Palestinians and expelled all their leaders in 1939. They had almost nothing. That is how Israel could expel 300,000 people in a few months. The Palestinians were defenseless.

...by April of 1948 the number of expelled Palestinians had reached 800,000...the victors were quite frank and candid about the scavenger Zionist Jews who opportunistically took property and land abandoned by Arab Palestinians fleeing for their very lives...the Jew cowards re-wrote this episode as 'Israel's War for Independence' ...when we reflect on the salient fact that no 'dependent Israel' existed the sheer weight and scale of these vulgar lies rises to the surface like shit...

 

[Ventura77]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

The British disarmed the Palestinians and expelled all their leaders in 1939. They had almost nothing. That is how Israel could expel 300,000 people in a few months. The Palestinians were defenseless.

Then how do you think they rose up again in 1947 against the Jews after the UN partition?

Or how do you think about the British actually fighting on the side of the Hashemite Kingdom and training them as well in order to attack Israel in May of 1948?

How did all of those weapons find their way to the Arabs?

(Uhmmmm, could there have been any "contraband")

a far better question is how were the native population expected to defend themselves against thieving Jew pirates and terrorists whose numbers---estimated at 125,000---clearly exceeded the combined Arab forces of Syria and Egypt?

 

[Hollie]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

The British disarmed the Palestinians and expelled all their leaders in 1939. They had almost nothing. That is how Israel could expel 300,000 people in a few months. The Palestinians were defenseless.

Then how do you think they rose up again in 1947 against the Jews after the UN partition?

Or how do you think about the British actually fighting on the side of the Hashemite Kingdom and training them as well in order to attack Israel in May of 1948?

How did all of those weapons find their way to the Arabs?

(Uhmmmm, could there have been any "contraband")

a far better question is how were the native population expected to defend themselves against thieving Jew pirates and terrorists whose numbers---estimated at 125,000---clearly exceeded the combined Arab forces of Syria and Egypt?

A better question still is why are you Arabs-Moslems still whing like petulant children for losing a war you initiated?

 

[Hollie]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

The British disarmed the Palestinians and expelled all their leaders in 1939. They had almost nothing. That is how Israel could expel 300,000 people in a few months. The Palestinians were defenseless.

...by April of 1948 the number of expelled Palestinians had reached 800,000...the victors were quite frank and candid about the scavenger Zionist Jews who opportunistically took property and land abandoned by Arab Palestinians fleeing for their very lives...the Jew cowards re-wrote this episode as 'Israel's War for Independence' ...when we reflect on the salient fact that no 'dependent Israel' existed the sheer weight and scale of these vulgar lies rises to the surface like shit...

Another of your plagiarized tirades.

 

[Ventura77]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

The British disarmed the Palestinians and expelled all their leaders in 1939. They had almost nothing. That is how Israel could expel 300,000 people in a few months. The Palestinians were defenseless.

Then how do you think they rose up again in 1947 against the Jews after the UN partition?

Or how do you think about the British actually fighting on the side of the Hashemite Kingdom and training them as well in order to attack Israel in May of 1948?

How did all of those weapons find their way to the Arabs?

(Uhmmmm, could there have been any "contraband")

a far better question is how were the native population expected to defend themselves against thieving Jew pirates and terrorists whose numbers---estimated at 125,000---clearly exceeded the combined Arab forces of Syria and Egypt?

A better question still is why are you Arabs-Moslems still whing like petulant children for losing a war you initiated?

It must be of no minor benefit to your tiny brain to literally invent history...on one side we had an unarmed civilian population...on the other well-armed Jewish terror groups---Irgun...Haganah...Stern Geng...Lehi...can you do the math idiot?

 

[Ventura77]

Deflection. We were discussing 1948.

So you are arguing that there was no resistance by Arabs in 1947/1948? They were all peaceful, unarmed civilians?

The British disarmed the Palestinians and expelled all their leaders in 1939. They had almost nothing. That is how Israel could expel 300,000 people in a few months. The Palestinians were defenseless.

...by April of 1948 the number of expelled Palestinians had reached 800,000...the victors were quite frank and candid about the scavenger Zionist Jews who opportunistically took property and land abandoned by Arab Palestinians fleeing for their very lives...the Jew cowards re-wrote this episode as 'Israel's War for Independence' ...when we reflect on the salient fact that no 'dependent Israel' existed the sheer weight and scale of these vulgar lies rises to the surface like shit...

Another of your plagiarized tirades.

Another of your tired delusions...IQ?