Why aren’t Palestinians welcome

[AzogtheDefiler]

What a stupid argument. Don’t pretend like I was making a post about DNA. People across borders have similar DNA everywhere. What exactly is the DNA of an American?! You’re arguments are getting dumber and dumber the more you scramble

“Palestine” is a former TransJordan they are Jordanians. Stop being so obtuse

 

[AzogtheDefiler]

Unfortunately, they kind of are. That's how wars work.

Slade believes the allies should have programmed their bombs and missiles to only kill military personnel in WW2

 

[AzogtheDefiler]

Unfortunately, they kind of are. That's how wars work.

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

View attachment 854830

That's because of the high profle. Palestinians have more voice.globally than Syrian Musims, for example.

 

[AzogtheDefiler]

That's because of the high profle. Palestinians have more voice.globally than Syrian Musims, for example.

Or is it because it’s the Jews? So if Israel attacked Syria, you don’t think there would be marches?

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

Or is it because it’s the Jews? So if Israel attacked Syria, you don’t think there would be marches?

Maybe somewhat. But I think a lot of people are mislabeling pushback from the left as antisemitism. People had been protesting the humanitarian crisis in Gaza for a long time before this happened.

 

[RodISHI]

Who has lived on that land for many decades? Many forced there when Israel pushed them off their ancestral lands.

View attachment 854536

Looks like a typical street thug if you actually want my opinion.

 

[Slade3200]

Unfortunately, they kind of are. That's how wars work.

Hamas could lose power and another governing body take over and they people would still be Palestinians... Correct?

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

Hamas could lose power and another governing body take over and they people would still be Palestinians... Correct?

That goes for any country or region. When prosecuting a war your own forces and civilians come first.

When Hamas sits on the roof of a civilian building and fires RPGs, Israel is well withing its rights and international law to destroy that building.

 

[Slade3200]

“Palestine” is a former TransJordan they are Jordanians. Stop being so obtuse

TransJordan was a part of Palestine. Jordan is now Jordan and its people are Jordanians. Palestinians are people that live in the West Bank and Gaza whom had been driven out of what is now Israel.


If you called those people Jordanians nobody would understand what the hell you're talking about, which is why you are using the term Palestinian in this very thread.

 

[Slade3200]

That goes for any country or region. When prosecuting a war your own forces and civilians come first.

When Hamas sits on the roof of a civilian building and fires RPGs, Israel is well withing its rights and international law to destroy that building.

Understood but thats besides the point I was making. If Hamas was removed the people in that region would still be Palestinians... Unless of course Israel concours it, takes power and absorbs them all as Israelites. Correct?

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

Understood but thats besides the point I was making.

No, it speaks right to it. Israel is at war with Hamas, and Hamas controls Palestine.

If Hamas was removed the people in that region would still be Palestinians.

And would still be fair game for target practice, if they are human shields for another group that declares war on Israel.

 

[AzogtheDefiler]

Maybe somewhat. But I think a lot of people are mislabeling pushback from the left as antisemitism. People had been protesting the humanitarian crisis in Gaza for a long time before this happened.

Except they keep chanting “from the river to the sea”

Death to Israel

 

[AzogtheDefiler]

TransJordan was a part of Palestine. Jordan is now Jordan and its people are Jordanians. Palestinians are people that live in the West Bank and Gaza whom had been driven out of what is now Israel.


If you called those people Jordanians nobody would understand what the hell you're talking about, which is why you are using the term Palestinian in this very thread.

Palestine is a region not a country. Real Palestinians if you want to go there are Jews

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

Except they keep chanting “from the river to the sea”

Death to Israel

Indeed. Lots of them. But at this point, we do have to take into account that many of those chanting it in Gaza were born into horrible conditions they perceive as beng caused by Israel.

That's not an excuse. It's a explanation.

 

[Slade3200]

No, it speaks right to it. Israel is at war with Hamas, and Hamas controls Palestine

I never contended that point

 

[Slade3200]

And would still be fair game for target practice, if they are human shields for another group that declares war on Israel.

We aren’t talking about fair game for target practice: we are talking about whether the term Palestinian is fake or not

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

I never contended that point

And unfortunately that means the war is also against Palestine. Hamas controls Gaza, and gazans harbor them and support their leadership.

 

[Slade3200]

Palestine is a region not a country. Real Palestinians if you want to go there are Jews

Ok then now we are getting to the root of it. You think Jews are the real Palestinians so you don’t like that the Arabs have claimed the label. Why couldnt you just be honest about it from the start ?

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

We aren’t talking about fair game for target practice: we are talking about whether the term Palestinian is fake or not

It's fine by me to use that term. That's how they self-identify. That's how the world identifies them.