toomuchtime_
Gold Member
- Dec 29, 2008
- 20,031
- 4,946
- 280
In fact, we do try to effect change in Saudi Arabia and there has been some significant progress in recent years. Similarly, we use our influence in Egypt, but with the Muslim Brotherhood still so active, progress is slower there. China and Myanmar are beyond our influence, and of course Iraq was also at that time..l,
Pretty much everyone has, and decent people have decided that if we allowed Sadam's depredations to continue because it served our political purposes, we would be complicit in his crimes. You are suggesting we should forget all our talk about human rights whenever it suits our political purposes.Iran is not fighting wars with countries, it is fighting wars to take over countries. Today, Iranian backed militias are so powerful in Iraq that Iraq may turn into another Lebanon. Iran is using its militias there to stock pile weapons the Iraqi government doesn't even know about.
Iran was attacked by Iraq with our urging. So my question stands. What wars?
Here is one of the problems with regime change ...Iraq was a counter balance to the aspirations of Iran.
Oops.
Iran and the Saudi’s counter balence each other’s ambitions. Has anyone thought that through yet?
If that mattered, why don’t we act on the human rights violations of Saudi Arabia? China? Myanmar? Egypt? That argument doesn’t fly.
We did not think it through at all, that was the tragedy. That was why Bush Sr. Stopped short of regime change.
In fact, we did that, and then Saddam invaded Kuwait and threatened Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states so that he was threatening to gain control of most of the ME's oil, and we had to intervene to protect the global economy but still we said, let him slaughter the Kurds and Shi'ites as long as our oil is safe, but Bush41 foolishly allowed the UN to take control of the truce with Iraq and then Saddam used his oil to bribe officials in Kofi Annan's office and to persuade Syria to open an outlawed pipeline while the UN had put Syria in charge of enforcing the very sanctions it was breaking.
Bush 41 was foolish? Looking at the aftermath of the invasion of Iraq, do you really think so?
The question was, should we allow Saddam to murder as many people as he wants to and to corrupt the UN or should we put a stop to it? Morally, the war was justified, but most of us today think the price was too high and we are applying that same thinking to Iran, but we should not pretend we have the high moral ground to stand on by making this decision. We are putting America first and saying to hell with the Iranians.
I may be cynical but I don’t think the people who put together the argument for this war gave a damn about human rights abuses. Witness the curious indifference to it elsewhere in the world.
Yes, Bush41 was foolish. The UN had never been given a task as big as taking charge of the truce with Iraq, and it failed miserably. Instead of the UN controlling Iraq as it was charged to do, Saddam was controlling the UN, and the slaughter went on with no prospect of ever abating. Regime change in Iraq was morally right, and bu the time Bush43 left office, Iraq was in a better place than it ever could have reached without US help until Obama pulled the rug out from under them to improve his chances for reelection.
You are not so much cynical as a political partisan no amount of suffering and death could persuade you to rethink a political point you had committed to. Certainly the Democrats like Clinton, Biden and Kerry who supported the war were only thinking that being tough on national security would help them in their political careers, and some Republicans thought that they were continuing America's promise to make the world safe for democracy, but others who had seen the reports about Saddam slaughtering whole Shi'ite villages or destroying their water supply and making them homeless and of tens of thousands of Kurdish women and children in concentration camps after their husbands and fathers had been murdered by Saddam understood that what we were seeing was right out of nazi Europe and were moved to support the war. Not everyone is as indifferent as you are to all this suffering and death.