Official Usmb Mafia Game #5: A Game Of Fire And Ice (day 6)

[ScarletRage]

You can quote the same response over and over. I will tell the truth again.

Scum House tries to kill Rosie. Shield swaps the target. Scum House targets John Doe and kills him. That is what should have happened.

It is similar to the roleblock.

 

[ScarletRage]

Besides, it is not like Mertex knew Rosie was Macho from what I am reading. If she was vt and had suspicion on her, she should take a bullet for Rosie. A PR steals grandma.

Answer my question, lying scum.

Melodrama...now that is lying scum.

 

[Wolfsister77]

My understanding is Macho was never mentioned. Mertex also would not tell me who she protected, if anyone.

 

[House]

You can quote the same response over and over. I will tell the truth again.

Scum House tries to kill Rosie. Shield swaps the target. Scum House targets John Doe and kills him. That is what should have happened.

It is similar to the roleblock.

Wrong. Macho prevents protection IN ANY WAY.

Scummity scum!

 

[ScarletRage]

My understanding is Macho was never mentioned. Mertex also would not tell me who she protected, if anyone.

Mertex was a cop. Don't you mean investigated?

 

[ScarletRage]

You can quote the same response over and over. I will tell the truth again.

Scum House tries to kill Rosie. Shield swaps the target. Scum House targets John Doe and kills him. That is what should have happened.

It is similar to the roleblock.

Wrong. Macho prevents protection IN ANY WAY.

Scummity scum!

The shield is not protection in terms of the macho modifier. The attack never hits rosie.

 

[Grandma]

Grandma where is your vote? About how many votes on Mertex?

post 2242
Official USMB Mafia Game 5 A Game of Fire and Ice Page 113 US Message Board - Political Discussion Forum

2 or 3 votes, I think.

Rosie hinted that if Shaitra's result were Town, then Rosie would have voted for Mertex.

 

[Wolfsister77]

My understanding is Macho was never mentioned. Mertex also would not tell me who she protected, if anyone.

Mertex was a cop. Don't you mean investigated?

Mertex had the shield ability she stole from Shaitra but wouldn't say if she used it or not or on whom if she did. Rosie investigated Shaitra but died so we don't know the result.

 

[House]

You can quote the same response over and over. I will tell the truth again.

Scum House tries to kill Rosie. Shield swaps the target. Scum House targets John Doe and kills him. That is what should have happened.

It is similar to the roleblock.

Wrong. Macho prevents protection IN ANY WAY.

Scummity scum!

The shield is not protection in terms of the macho modifier. The attack never hits rosie.

Wrong. It (Shield) can't be USED on Macho. Period.

 

[ScarletRage]

Why doesn't town announce who she used it on? Answer: She did not.

 

[Grandma]

Mertex was a cop. Don't you mean investigated?

Rosie was the Cop. Mertex vaguely hinted at having a PR.

 

[ScarletRage]

You can quote the same response over and over. I will tell the truth again.

Scum House tries to kill Rosie. Shield swaps the target. Scum House targets John Doe and kills him. That is what should have happened.

It is similar to the roleblock.

Wrong. Macho prevents protection IN ANY WAY.

Scummity scum!

The shield is not protection in terms of the macho modifier. The attack never hits rosie.

Wrong. It (Shield) can't be USED on Macho. Period.

Nope. I have been playing for years. Rosie wasn't protected. The kill was prevented from happening at all if sheild was used. If your version is accurate, why wouldn't Mertex just say she used it?

 

[ScarletRage]

Mertex was a cop. Don't you mean investigated?

Rosie was the Cop. Mertex vaguely hinted at having a PR.

Damn typos.

 

[ScarletRage]

Grandma can you approximate a vc for me?

 

[Wolfsister77]

Why doesn't town announce who she used it on? Answer: She did not.

Yeah, this bugs me a lot with regards to Mertex besides the fact she knew Rosie had an investigative PR.

 

[House]

You can quote the same response over and over. I will tell the truth again.

Scum House tries to kill Rosie. Shield swaps the target. Scum House targets John Doe and kills him. That is what should have happened.

It is similar to the roleblock.

Wrong. Macho prevents protection IN ANY WAY.

Scummity scum!

The shield is not protection in terms of the macho modifier. The attack never hits rosie.

Wrong. It (Shield) can't be USED on Macho. Period.

Nope. I have been playing for years. Rosie wasn't protected. The kill was prevented from happening at all if sheild was used. If your version is accurate, why wouldn't Mertex just say she used it?

Of course Rosie wasn't protected, that's what I've been hammering into that concrete skull of yours. SHE COULDN'T BE PROTECTED.

Bodyguard = protection; Macho prevents protection; ergo, bodyguards can't take a cop's place in an attack.

DUH!

 

[House]

(a macho cop's place)

 

[ScarletRage]

Why doesn't town announce who she used it on? Answer: She did not.

Yeah, this bugs me a lot with regards to Mertex besides the fact she knew Rosie had an investigative PR.

1) Mertex steals shield over immunity. This suggests a PR claim over VT.
2) Mertex under suspicion fails to use shield although it would clear her name and greatly aid us in catching scum.
3) Mertex fails to save an outed PR.
4) Tonal mismatch.
5) I was shot and I pushed Mertex yesterday.

 

[Grandma]

It'll take a few minutes.

House - No one but Rosie knew that she was a MACHO Cop.

Mertex has had more than enough time to say that she used the Shield on someone. Hell, all she had to do was name anybody and say "Oh gee, that person and I are both alive, I must have picked the wrong person to protect." In other words, Mertex could have told a bullshit story. She did not, instead shge started arguing.

 

[ScarletRage]

You can quote the same response over and over. I will tell the truth again.

Scum House tries to kill Rosie. Shield swaps the target. Scum House targets John Doe and kills him. That is what should have happened.

It is similar to the roleblock.

Wrong. Macho prevents protection IN ANY WAY.

Scummity scum!

The shield is not protection in terms of the macho modifier. The attack never hits rosie.

Wrong. It (Shield) can't be USED on Macho. Period.

Nope. I have been playing for years. Rosie wasn't protected. The kill was prevented from happening at all if sheild was used. If your version is accurate, why wouldn't Mertex just say she used it?

Of course Rosie wasn't protected, that's what I've been hammering into that concrete skull of yours. SHE COULDN'T BE PROTECTED.

Bodyguard = protection; Macho prevents protection; ergo, bodyguards can't take a cop's place in an attack.

DUH!

And I am hammering that a shield isn't protection much like a roleblocker.

If Mertex is this patron saint you paint her to be, where is her outrage? Why isn't she pushing this debate to the forefront.