s there a bigger story behind the Bergdahl exchange?

Mebbe Bowe's a chip off the old block...
:cuckoo:
Bergdahl’s father now under scrutiny himself
June 8, 2014 — In 2011, during his long five-year vigil, waiting helplessly at home while his son was held by Taliban extremists half a world away, Bob Bergdahl made a personal video for the Pakistani government that he hoped would be delivered to his boy, Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl.
“These are my thoughts. I can remain silent no longer,” the father began. He stood in a black shirt, his bushy blond beard worn long, the kind sported by most militant men in the war-racked region. In the three-minute video, he mentioned several high-ranking Pakistani generals by name, thanking them for their sacrifices. Then he went on to thank the Taliban forces that were holding his son. “Strangely to some,” he said, “we must also thank those who have cared for our son for almost two years. We know our son is a prisoner, but at the same time a guest in your home.” He then addressed his son, sending his love and assuring him: “We’ve been quiet in public. But we haven’t been quiet behind the scene.”

That video, along with other social media postings the 54-year-old Bergdahl made after his son was captured near the Afghan-Pakistani border in 2009, have come under greater scrutiny in the wake of the Obama administration’s controversial prisoner swap, in which the U.S. secured the 28-year-old sergeant’s release by freeing five Taliban leaders held at the U.S. military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. Back home, critics are demanding that the U.S. Army prosecute the younger Bergdahl for deserting his post before his capture, as has been claimed by other soldiers in his unit. But the father is now under increased public scrutiny as well. Bob Bergdahl, many say, was waging his own undeclared war at home.

Over the years, residents of this small resort town in the shadow of the Sawtooth Mountains watched as he slowly changed over the long months of his son’s ordeal. Always private, the conservative Presbyterian everyone knew as the local UPS deliveryman further retreated into his shell. He’d moved to Idaho with his wife, Jani, after dropping out of the University of California, Santa Barbara. Bowe and his sister, Sky, were born there. The elder Bergdahl learned Pashto, the language of his son’s captors, studied Arabic and immersed himself in the stories of other Americans held abroad. He began growing his hair and beard in solidarity with his son — its length and unruliness reminders to Wood River Valley residents of how long his son had been in captivity.

Few mentioned the beard, knowing its significance. “Bob delivered packages to our office and most everyone’s offices,” said Hailey Mayor Fritz Haemmerle, a local lawyer who has known Bergdahl for 30 years. “You’d see him doing his job, but you never knew what to say. It’s one of those touchy subjects, like when someone dies. What do you say to the family? It’s not an easy conversation to have. “The change in Bob’s visage told the story. And it was a drastic change.”

MORE

See also:

Former soldiers recount trying search for missing POW Bowe Bergdahl
June 9, 2014 ~ When Anchorage-based Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl went missing at a lightly fortified outpost in southeastern Afghanistan in 2009, soldiers he left behind say it upended their deployment mission from one of turning Afghans away from the Taliban into a dangerous and fruitless rescue operation.
“Everybody’s improving their own areas, improving the villages around them, making life better and making it easier for us to leave — we started the engine, we walk away,” said Nick Tabaczka, then a staff sergeant in Blackfoot Company (the same unit as Bergdahl) and now a University of Alaska Anchorage student. “When all this happened, everything changed.” “After Bergdahl disappeared, we started doing our rescue missions back to back,” said Kenneth Nall, then a private and now a stay-at-home dad. “That’s when people were starting to get hurt all the time, because we had pushed so many more soldiers in theater to look for this guy.” Nall himself was badly injured when his Army vehicle struck an improvised bomb in the search for Bergdahl.

The first jubilant moments when Bergdahl was released by the Taliban on May 31 in a swap for five Guantanamo prisoners quickly turned sour and political. Some in Congress objected to the swap. Members of Bergdahl’s Second Platoon, interviewed in national media, in some cases in arrangements made by Republican strategists, described Bergdahl as a deserter. The former soldiers said at least two Anchorage-based soldiers were killed in action because of him.

With the issue simmering on the national stage, four former soldiers from Bergdahl’s company, including three from the platoon that split duty at Outpost Mest with Bergdahl’s platoon, agreed to an interview last week. They said they wanted to express solidarity with the soldiers from the Second Platoon, at least on the point that the Army should investigate Bergdahl as a deserter who endangered his fellow soldiers and should be held to account in a court-martial if the facts warrant. But they also said they had no interest in getting involved in the partisan politics surrounding Bergdahl’s release and said they were happy he can now come home — even if his destination is a brig and not his hometown of Hailey, Idaho.

The four, Tabaczka, 34, from Manistee, Mich.; Nall, 35, from Lubbock, Texas; former Sgt. Johnathan Rice, 27, from Daytona Beach, Fla.; and former Spc. Ryan McNeely, 27, from Buchanan, Mich., all remained in the Anchorage area as civilians after leaving the Army’s 4th Brigade Combat Team (Airborne), 25th Infantry Division, based at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson. They served in the Brigade’s 2009 deployment to Afghanistan with the 150-soldier Blackfoot Company of the 1st Battalion, 501st Parachute Infantry Regiment. Rice approached the Anchorage Daily News / Alaska Dispatch last week to express his opinions on Bergdahl’s release.

'They had lost their man'
 
Obama giving five top echelon Taliban leaders in trade for a hostage is insane. Think about WWII and trading 4 of Hitler's cabinet members and one Rommel for a hostage.

Because that's the equivalent to what Obama did. One is a mass murderer of Afghan civilians. By virtue of this over the top trade's bizarreness there has to be more to it.

Or at least I hope there is. Because if not it means this administration is more royally fucked up than any of us thought.

Pardon my french there but this is really whacked out.
 
Last edited:
Obama giving five top echelon Taliban leaders in trade for a hostage is insane. Think about WWII and trading 4 of Hitler's cabinet members and one Rommel for a hostage.

Because that's the equivalent to what Obama did. One is a mass murderer of Afghan civilians. By virtue of this over the top trade's bizarreness there has to be more to it.

Or at least I hope there is. Because if not it means this administration is more royally fucked up than any of us thought.

Pardon my french there but this is really whacked out.

You forgot to mention Reagan's missile trade.
 
Obama giving five top echelon Taliban leaders in trade for a hostage is insane. Think about WWII and trading 4 of Hitler's cabinet members and one Rommel for a hostage.

Because that's the equivalent to what Obama did. One is a mass murderer of Afghan civilians. By virtue of this over the top trade's bizarreness there has to be more to it.

Or at least I hope there is. Because if not it means this administration is more royally fucked up than any of us thought.

Pardon my french there but this is really whacked out.

Republicans have NOTHING to offer the middle class.
 
Obama giving five top echelon Taliban leaders in trade for a hostage is insane. Think about WWII and trading 4 of Hitler's cabinet members and one Rommel for a hostage.

Because that's the equivalent to what Obama did. One is a mass murderer of Afghan civilians. By virtue of this over the top trade's bizarreness there has to be more to it.

Or at least I hope there is. Because if not it means this administration is more royally fucked up than any of us thought.

Pardon my french there but this is really whacked out.

Republicans have NOTHING to offer the middle class.

Democrats had two years to make the middle class strong, but social issues were more important. Get some new talking points.
 
Sure there is a bigger story. Republicans have NOTHING to offer the middle class.

Which if true would be much better then the destruction that the democrats have offered the middle class for the last 8 years they have been in power. How you can blame the minority party for what the majority has done is anyone's guess.
 
Obama giving five top echelon Taliban leaders in trade for a hostage is insane. Think about WWII and trading 4 of Hitler's cabinet members and one Rommel for a hostage.

Because that's the equivalent to what Obama did. One is a mass murderer of Afghan civilians. By virtue of this over the top trade's bizarreness there has to be more to it.

Or at least I hope there is. Because if not it means this administration is more royally fucked up than any of us thought.

Pardon my french there but this is really whacked out.

Republicans have NOTHING to offer the middle class.

Democrats had two years to make the middle class strong, but social issues were more important. Get some new talking points.

The last time Democrats had control of Congress was the last two years of Ford and the first two years of Carter.
 
Sure there is a bigger story. Republicans have NOTHING to offer the middle class.

Which if true would be much better then the destruction that the democrats have offered the middle class for the last 8 years they have been in power. How you can blame the minority party for what the majority has done is anyone's guess.

The Democrats have 60 or more votes in the Senate and a majority in the House?
 

Forum List

Back
Top