Lewdog
Gold Member
- Apr 26, 2016
- 23,939
- 3,196
According to who?So you're saying it is ok for one party to use their position as the majority to put out a misleading memo that references classified information they know can't/shouldn't be released to the public as part of a propaganda campaign, but it isn't ok for the other party in the same committee to try and refute/prove the other memo was bullshit?
There was ZERO redacted from the Majority Memo other than blackinking the classification at the top of the pages. That's how I was taught to write UNclassified summaries of classified material. First one was done right.
And you can dispute original sourcing WITHOUT divulging secrets. Minority just didn't want to..
The Trump Admin? Or the FBI?
No. It is partisan censoring and it is dispicable to anyone genuinely interested in the truth.
Don't get your comment.. I stated facts.. There was NOT A WORD redacted from the majority report other than the Classification stamp at the top of pages.. Now the GRASSLEY memo had PLENTY redacted from it. So the system for declassification is WORKING.
The way it works is that there has to be agreement from the classifying agency and ANY agency who's sources were used. So it's NOT as you suggested Trump OR the FBI that decides. It's BOTH.. In fact the FISA court might even have been consulted --- since they are the CENTER of this..
Not partisan censoring. It's either TRULY classified or it's not. Although a LOT of this is ONLY classified to keep it from the people and press in the 1st place. Not because undercover agents are gonna die or collection systems compromised..
Yeah except the FBI said the Republican memo shouldn't be released and Trump did it anyway. So how is that considered the system working? Seems to me everything is ok to be released by Trump as long as it helps him out.
OF COURSE the FBI wouldn't want all this out in public... Lemme rephrase that --- THe LEADERSHIP of the FBI would make outrageous claims about it being "harmful to national security" to prevent the INTITIAL release... They were clearly bluffing..
The rank\file are CHEERING on the necessary investigation and cleansing.
Anyways -- Here's the test. We've got your leftist buds squealing that the COMMITTEE voted unanimously to release the Minority Report.. That's true -- BUT -- It's subject to FBI/DOJ/Whitehouse redaction and approval..
ANY of those 3 --- PLUS about 3 or 4 possible OTHER agencies can read and comment. It's NOT up to just ONE of any of them.
What's keeping them honest is that the public is watching. And if claims are made that stuff REMAINS classified simply because it's embarrassing or damaging to EITHER the FBI or the WHouse -- that -- won't -- stand.. Enough folks have now read it to prevent "classification abuse"... Which is the ONLY grounds on which Trump can act alone...
Ok so the new litmus test is the system works as long as Trump, you, and the party you support thinks the information in a document is ok to be released?
...and as long as you like the people running the agencies you just said should decide if information should be released.
Do you see the issue here?