Who Are The Palestinians? Part 2

[P F Tinmore]

The Palestinians want all of Palestine? Oh my!

Well, technically, the Arab Palestinians only want part of Palestine. The part that should have been under the sovereignty of the Jewish People. I don't see them whining a whole bunch about getting Jordan back.

They weren't kicked out of Jordan.

 

[P F Tinmore]

The Arabs-Moslems want their mini-caliphate to be Jew free and kuffar free. That defines the history of Islamist fascism.

No they don't.

I agree. They don't necessarily want Palestine to be Jew-free. They just want the Jewish people to return to dhimmi status. That is, they want to ensure that Jews are prohibited from certain rights -- rights to self-government, rights to sovereignty, rights to worship in their holy places, rights to self-defense, rights to equality.

Where do you get this shit?

 

[Shusha]

They weren't kicked out of Jordan.

They weren't kicked out of Israel, either. There are millions of them in Israel.

But irrelevant. You say they want "ALL" of Palestine. Now you admit they only want the part of Palestine where the Jewish people are. Uh huh. We know.

 

[Shusha]

The Arabs-Moslems want their mini-caliphate to be Jew free and kuffar free. That defines the history of Islamist fascism.

No they don't.

I agree. They don't necessarily want Palestine to be Jew-free. They just want the Jewish people to return to dhimmi status. That is, they want to ensure that Jews are prohibited from certain rights -- rights to self-government, rights to sovereignty, rights to worship in their holy places, rights to self-defense, rights to equality.

Where do you get this shit?

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights and post daily from that point of view; from public statements from Fatah and Hamas; from the literal, actual fact that Muslims worldwide blow a hissy fit if a Jew moves his lips in his own holy place.

 

[fanger]

I think the word your looking for is "settlements"

Israeli settlements are civilian communitieshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_settlement#endnote_desc inhabited by Israeli citizens, almost exclusively of Jewish ethnicity,[1][2] built predominantly on lands within the Palestinian territories, which Israel has militarily occupied since the 1967 Six-Day War

 

[P F Tinmore]

The Arabs-Moslems want their mini-caliphate to be Jew free and kuffar free. That defines the history of Islamist fascism.

No they don't.

I agree. They don't necessarily want Palestine to be Jew-free. They just want the Jewish people to return to dhimmi status. That is, they want to ensure that Jews are prohibited from certain rights -- rights to self-government, rights to sovereignty, rights to worship in their holy places, rights to self-defense, rights to equality.

Where do you get this shit?

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights and post daily from that point of view; from public statements from Fatah and Hamas; from the literal, actual fact that Muslims worldwide blow a hissy fit if a Jew moves his lips in his own holy place.

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights

Never said that.

Links?

 

[Shusha]

The Arabs-Moslems want their mini-caliphate to be Jew free and kuffar free. That defines the history of Islamist fascism.

No they don't.

I agree. They don't necessarily want Palestine to be Jew-free. They just want the Jewish people to return to dhimmi status. That is, they want to ensure that Jews are prohibited from certain rights -- rights to self-government, rights to sovereignty, rights to worship in their holy places, rights to self-defense, rights to equality.

Where do you get this shit?

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights and post daily from that point of view; from public statements from Fatah and Hamas; from the literal, actual fact that Muslims worldwide blow a hissy fit if a Jew moves his lips in his own holy place.

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights

Never said that.

Links?

Less than an hour ago you wrote: Palestinians want all of Palestine.

Where is the right to Jewish sovereignty in that?

 

[P F Tinmore]

No they don't.

I agree. They don't necessarily want Palestine to be Jew-free. They just want the Jewish people to return to dhimmi status. That is, they want to ensure that Jews are prohibited from certain rights -- rights to self-government, rights to sovereignty, rights to worship in their holy places, rights to self-defense, rights to equality.

Where do you get this shit?

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights and post daily from that point of view; from public statements from Fatah and Hamas; from the literal, actual fact that Muslims worldwide blow a hissy fit if a Jew moves his lips in his own holy place.

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights

Never said that.

Links?

Less than an hour ago you wrote: Palestinians want all of Palestine.

Where is the right to Jewish sovereignty in that?

The Jews have the right to go to someone else's country, kick them out, and pig the place for themselves.

Can you document that?

 

[Sixties Fan]

I think the word your looking for is "settlements"

Israeli settlements are civilian communities inhabited by Israeli citizens, almost exclusively of Jewish ethnicity,[1][2] built predominantly on lands within the Palestinian territories, which Israel has militarily occupied since the 1967 Six-Day War

And Arab settlements are communities inhabited by Arabs, be it in Israel or in the PA territories - A and B, where these Arabs settled since the Arab invasion of the 7th Century.

Judea and Samaria were inhabited by Arabs only after the 1948 expulsion of all the Jews from their homes and lands where they have been the indigenous people living there for over 3000 years.

TransJordan has been a Muslim-only Monarchy and then Country since 1925, after the Arabs expelled all the Jews from their homes and lands, where the Jews also used to live for over 3000 years.

Poor, poor Arabs, if they do not get their way THEY are the victims
and NEVER the victimizers.

 

[Sixties Fan]

I agree. They don't necessarily want Palestine to be Jew-free. They just want the Jewish people to return to dhimmi status. That is, they want to ensure that Jews are prohibited from certain rights -- rights to self-government, rights to sovereignty, rights to worship in their holy places, rights to self-defense, rights to equality.

Where do you get this shit?

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights and post daily from that point of view; from public statements from Fatah and Hamas; from the literal, actual fact that Muslims worldwide blow a hissy fit if a Jew moves his lips in his own holy place.

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights

Never said that.

Links?

Less than an hour ago you wrote: Palestinians want all of Palestine.

Where is the right to Jewish sovereignty in that?

The Jews have the right to go to someone else's country, kick them out, and pig the place for themselves.

Can you document that?

Stop repeating your mantra. Tiresome.
The Jews went back to THEIR country, and legally acquired sovereignty over it. Unlike the Arab invaders who never built a country at all, before or after the British Mandate.

In your world, the Arabs can "PIG" all they like

 

[fanger]

Where do you get this shit?

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights and post daily from that point of view; from public statements from Fatah and Hamas; from the literal, actual fact that Muslims worldwide blow a hissy fit if a Jew moves his lips in his own holy place.

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights

Never said that.

Links?

Less than an hour ago you wrote: Palestinians want all of Palestine.

Where is the right to Jewish sovereignty in that?

The Jews have the right to go to someone else's country, kick them out, and pig the place for themselves.

Can you document that?

Stop repeating your mantra. Tiresome.
The Jews went back to THEIR country, and legally acquired sovereignty over it. Unlike the Arab invaders who never built a country at all, before or after the British Mandate.

In your world, the Arabs can "PIG" all they like

"legally acquired sovereignty over it." from whom?

 

[Hollie]

I agree. They don't necessarily want Palestine to be Jew-free. They just want the Jewish people to return to dhimmi status. That is, they want to ensure that Jews are prohibited from certain rights -- rights to self-government, rights to sovereignty, rights to worship in their holy places, rights to self-defense, rights to equality.

Where do you get this shit?

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights and post daily from that point of view; from public statements from Fatah and Hamas; from the literal, actual fact that Muslims worldwide blow a hissy fit if a Jew moves his lips in his own holy place.

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights

Never said that.

Links?

Less than an hour ago you wrote: Palestinians want all of Palestine.

Where is the right to Jewish sovereignty in that?

The Jews have the right to go to someone else's country, kick them out, and pig the place for themselves.

Can you document that?

You're still floating the nonsense that a "country of Pal'istan" existed?

Can you support that?

 

[fanger]

Where was israel created?

The Balfour Declaration was a November 2, 1917 letter from British Foreign Secretary Arthur James Balfour to Lord Rothschild that made public the British support of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

If Palestine never existed, then israel must be a bastard child

 

[Hollie]

Where was israel created?

The Balfour Declaration was a November 2, 1917 letter from British Foreign Secretary Arthur James Balfour to Lord Rothschild that made public the British support of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

If Palestine never existed, then israel must be a bastard child

Could you please limit your participation to plagiarizing from Juan Cole?

 

[fanger]

Where was israel created?

The Balfour Declaration was a November 2, 1917 letter from British Foreign Secretary Arthur James Balfour to Lord Rothschild that made public the British support of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

If Palestine never existed, then israel must be a bastard child

Could you please limit your participation to plagiarizing from Juan Cole?

Why would you want that, droopy drawers?


Donations
Thank you to all of my supporters for your generosity and your encouragement of an independent press! Checks to

Juan Cole
P. O. Box 32509
Los Angeles, CA
90032
Israel/ Palestine | Informed Comment

 

[Shusha]

The Jews have the right to go to someone else's country, kick them out, and pig the place for themselves.

Can you document that?

No. The Jewish people have the right to sovereignty in their own homeland. Yes or no?

 

[fanger]

The Jews have the right to go to someone else's country, kick them out, and pig the place for themselves.

Can you document that?

No. The Jewish people have the right to sovereignty in their own homeland. Yes or no?

The Invention of the Jewish People - Wikipedia

 

[rylah]

Where was israel created?

The Balfour Declaration was a November 2, 1917 letter from British Foreign Secretary Arthur James Balfour to Lord Rothschild that made public the British support of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

If Palestine never existed, then israel must be a bastard child

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights and post daily from that point of view; from public statements from Fatah and Hamas; from the literal, actual fact that Muslims worldwide blow a hissy fit if a Jew moves his lips in his own holy place.

Well, from people like you who believe the Jewish people should be prohibited from certain rights

Never said that.

Links?

Less than an hour ago you wrote: Palestinians want all of Palestine.

Where is the right to Jewish sovereignty in that?

The Jews have the right to go to someone else's country, kick them out, and pig the place for themselves.

Can you document that?

Stop repeating your mantra. Tiresome.
The Jews went back to THEIR country, and legally acquired sovereignty over it. Unlike the Arab invaders who never built a country at all, before or after the British Mandate.

In your world, the Arabs can "PIG" all they like

"legally acquired sovereignty over it." from whom?

"And thereafter We [Allah] said to the Children of Israel: 'Dwell securely in the Promised Land. And when the last warning will come to pass, we will gather you together in a mingled crowd.'" [Qur'an 17:104]

 

[Shusha]

"legally acquired sovereignty over it." from whom?

Legally acquired it according to the laws and conventions and treaties of the time. Just like every other country.

 

[P F Tinmore]

"legally acquired sovereignty over it." from whom?

Legally acquired it according to the laws and conventions and treaties of the time. Just like every other country.

Links?