A Reasonable Solution To The Gay Marriage Debate

[Montrovant]

Sodomy is illegal people are arrested for doing it.

Not in the US as far as I know.

You were saying?

Man Charged With Sodomy, Child Molestation | FOX2now.com

Elmore County man charged with sodomy, child sex abuse | Crime | Wetumpka News

More details emerge after pastor charged with sodomy, child porn - KFVS12 News & Weather Cape Girardeau, Carbondale, Poplar Bluff

Guyton man charged with solicitation of sodomy, enticing a child - WTOC-TV: Savannah, Beaufort, SC, News, Weather & Sports

Jack man charged with rape, sodomy | Dothan Eagle

The Sullivan Independent News » Sullivan Man Charged In Sodomy Case

Man charged with sexual abuse and sodomy of teenager | Crime Beat

Man Arrested On Sex Offense, Sodomy | News | Upper Marlboro News

You are correct. I thought that the Lawrence decision invalidated sodomy laws, but apparently some states either ignore that decision or feel it is narrow in scope.

I would point out, though, that every case you linked involves more than just consensual sex between adults. They all involve minors or rape. They weren't even all homosexual sex. So, hopefully, there aren't many adults being charged just for having consensual sex.

 

[bigrebnc1775]

Not in the US as far as I know.

You were saying?

Man Charged With Sodomy, Child Molestation | FOX2now.com

Elmore County man charged with sodomy, child sex abuse | Crime | Wetumpka News

More details emerge after pastor charged with sodomy, child porn - KFVS12 News & Weather Cape Girardeau, Carbondale, Poplar Bluff

Guyton man charged with solicitation of sodomy, enticing a child - WTOC-TV: Savannah, Beaufort, SC, News, Weather & Sports

Jack man charged with rape, sodomy | Dothan Eagle

The Sullivan Independent News » Sullivan Man Charged In Sodomy Case

Man charged with sexual abuse and sodomy of teenager | Crime Beat

Man Arrested On Sex Offense, Sodomy | News | Upper Marlboro News

You are correct. I thought that the Lawrence decision invalidated sodomy laws, but apparently some states either ignore that decision or feel it is narrow in scope.

I would point out, though, that every case you linked involves more than just consensual sex between adults. They all involve minors or rape. They weren't even all homosexual sex. So, hopefully, there aren't many adults being charged just for having consensual sex.

Sodomy is still sodomy no matter the age. Sodomy is what type of act?

 

[WinterBorn]

Sodomy is still sodomy no matter the age. Sodomy is what type of act?

Private?

 

[bigrebnc1775]

Here's a teenager being charged with sodomy

Eufaula men, teen charged with sodomy | Eufaula Tribune

 

[bigrebnc1775]

Sodomy is still sodomy no matter the age. Sodomy is what type of act?

Private?

Sodomy is what type of act?

OH and brother and sister acts of love are also private do we allow that?

 

[WinterBorn]

In Lawrence v. Texas, the US Supreme Court held:

"Held: The Texas statute making it a crime for two persons of the same sex to engage in certain intimate sexual conduct violates the Due Process Clause. Pp. 3—18."

LAWRENCE V. TEXAS

 

[Montrovant]

Here's a teenager being charged with sodomy

Eufaula men, teen charged with sodomy | Eufaula Tribune

Again, there's a minor involved.

The point I'm making has to do with the Lawrence decision and the fact that some states and courts have interpreted it to be narrow in scope. They feel that it does not invalidate sodomy laws when they involve minors, or sex acts in public, only those done in private between consenting adults.

 

[WinterBorn]

Sodomy is still sodomy no matter the age. Sodomy is what type of act?

Private?

Sodomy is what type of act?

OH and brother and sister acts of love are also private do we allow that?

If you would like to show me where the SCOTUS has ruled in favor of incest, I would be happy to read it.

I notice you didn't answer my question. Are you in favor of making oral sex between consenting adults (or married couples) illegal?

 

[WinterBorn]

Here's a teenager being charged with sodomy

Eufaula men, teen charged with sodomy | Eufaula Tribune

Again, there's a minor involved.

The point I'm making has to do with the Lawrence decision and the fact that some states and courts have interpreted it to be narrow in scope. They feel that it does not invalidate sodomy laws when they involve minors, or sex acts in public, only those done in private between consenting adults.

It seems as though bigrebnc wants the gov't to monitor activities in people's bedrooms. I have no doubt he would volunteer for such duty. lol

 

[bigrebnc1775]

Private?

Sodomy is what type of act?

OH and brother and sister acts of love are also private do we allow that?

If you would like to show me where the SCOTUS has ruled in favor of incest, I would be happy to read it.

I notice you didn't answer my question. Are you in favor of making oral sex between consenting adults (or married couples) illegal?

Why do I need to answer your question since you want answer mine?

Is their any Supreme court ruling that gives gays right to marry?

 

[bigrebnc1775]

Here's a teenager being charged with sodomy

Eufaula men, teen charged with sodomy | Eufaula Tribune

Again, there's a minor involved.

The point I'm making has to do with the Lawrence decision and the fact that some states and courts have interpreted it to be narrow in scope. They feel that it does not invalidate sodomy laws when they involve minors, or sex acts in public, only those done in private between consenting adults.

It seems as though bigrebnc wants the gov't to monitor activities in people's bedrooms. I have no doubt he would volunteer for such duty. lol

So you support brothers and sisters marring each other?

 

[WinterBorn]

Here's a teenager being charged with sodomy

Eufaula men, teen charged with sodomy | Eufaula Tribune

From your link:

"The Barbour County Sheriff’s Office announced the arrests late Friday morning in a press release. Deputies first learned of the alleged crimes on Feb. 28 when they received a report that a Eufaula child had been sexually assaulted and that there were multiple suspects involved."

Can you show us any arrests that do not involve children or rape?

 

[WinterBorn]

Sodomy is what type of act?

OH and brother and sister acts of love are also private do we allow that?

If you would like to show me where the SCOTUS has ruled in favor of incest, I would be happy to read it.

I notice you didn't answer my question. Are you in favor of making oral sex between consenting adults (or married couples) illegal?

Why do I need to answer your question since you want answer mine?

Is their any Supreme court ruling that gives gays right to marry?

Or rather, I am not answering yours because you refuse to answer mine? Since I did pose my question first.

Also, my question is relevant to the views on sodomy.

 

[bigrebnc1775]

Here's a teenager being charged with sodomy

Eufaula men, teen charged with sodomy | Eufaula Tribune

From your link:

"The Barbour County Sheriff’s Office announced the arrests late Friday morning in a press release. Deputies first learned of the alleged crimes on Feb. 28 when they received a report that a Eufaula child had been sexually assaulted and that there were multiple suspects involved."

Can you show us any arrests that do not involve children or rape?

But it's a teenager who's being charged with sodomy does it give the age of the child who was sodomized? The child could have been a teenager also.

 

[bigrebnc1775]

If you would like to show me where the SCOTUS has ruled in favor of incest, I would be happy to read it.

I notice you didn't answer my question. Are you in favor of making oral sex between consenting adults (or married couples) illegal?

Why do I need to answer your question since you want answer mine?

Is their any Supreme court ruling that gives gays right to marry?

Or rather, I am not answering yours because you refuse to answer mine? Since I did pose my question first.

Also, my question is relevant to the views on sodomy.

I have asked you since this discussion of same sex marriage started. So do you drag your knuckles like you drag your feet?

 

[WinterBorn]

Again, there's a minor involved.

The point I'm making has to do with the Lawrence decision and the fact that some states and courts have interpreted it to be narrow in scope. They feel that it does not invalidate sodomy laws when they involve minors, or sex acts in public, only those done in private between consenting adults.

It seems as though bigrebnc wants the gov't to monitor activities in people's bedrooms. I have no doubt he would volunteer for such duty. lol

So you support brothers and sisters marring each other?

I see that you are back to changing what I say into what you wish I had said.

Unless you can show where I said anything in favor of incest, I think you are guilty of not only twisting my words, but making up what I said. And weren't you the one refusing to continue a discussion with me because you claimed I did that?

Hypocrisy is a lousy debate technique.

 

[bigrebnc1775]

It seems as though bigrebnc wants the gov't to monitor activities in people's bedrooms. I have no doubt he would volunteer for such duty. lol

So you support brothers and sisters marring each other?

I see that you are back to changing what I say into what you wish I had said.

Unless you can show where I said anything in favor of incest, I think you are guilty of not only twisting my words, but making up what I said. And weren't you the one refusing to continue a discussion with me because you claimed I did that?

Hypocrisy is a lousy debate technique.

Nothing has changed especially your refusal to answer a comment.

 

[WinterBorn]

Here's a teenager being charged with sodomy

Eufaula men, teen charged with sodomy | Eufaula Tribune

From your link:

"The Barbour County Sheriff’s Office announced the arrests late Friday morning in a press release. Deputies first learned of the alleged crimes on Feb. 28 when they received a report that a Eufaula child had been sexually assaulted and that there were multiple suspects involved."

Can you show us any arrests that do not involve children or rape?

But it's a teenager who's being charged with sodomy does it give the age of the child who was sodomized? The child could have been a teenager also.

Since the article referred to one as a "teenager" and one as a "child" it is a reasonable assumption that the child was much younger.

And the word "assault" doesn't have any bearing on it?

Again, show us links to arrests made that do not include children or rape.

 

[WinterBorn]

So you support brothers and sisters marring each other?

I see that you are back to changing what I say into what you wish I had said.

Unless you can show where I said anything in favor of incest, I think you are guilty of not only twisting my words, but making up what I said. And weren't you the one refusing to continue a discussion with me because you claimed I did that?

Hypocrisy is a lousy debate technique.

Nothing has changed especially your refusal to answer a comment.

Fine. I do not support brothers and sisters marrying each other.

And your answer to my question?

 

[WinterBorn]

So you support brothers and sisters marring each other?

I see that you are back to changing what I say into what you wish I had said.

Unless you can show where I said anything in favor of incest, I think you are guilty of not only twisting my words, but making up what I said. And weren't you the one refusing to continue a discussion with me because you claimed I did that?

Hypocrisy is a lousy debate technique.

Nothing has changed especially your refusal to answer a comment.

I didn't say anything changed in the discussion. I called you out on a blatant lie or at least making a claim that I said something I did not.

You know, like you had a hissy fit claiming I did?