Faun
Diamond Member
- Nov 14, 2011
- 124,353
- 81,000
- 2,635
Democrats passed GSE reform in the House in 2007 and in the Senate in 2008. Bush signed it into law.I'm sure you're familiar enough with Senate to know how it functions. The only procedure available in the hands of the minority party to block a bill is to filibuster.If Republicans had actually blocked those, then it would be reasonable to say the majority party Democrats failed to pass them because the minority party blocked them. That works that way for both parties regardless who's in charge.Again.......
Republicans controlled the Congress. You can't blame Democrats because Republicans wouldn't do their job.
I find it interesting how this perception of "doing their job" changes when it's liberals claim republicans have gotten in the way when Harry Reed failed at his job in passing a stronger economic jobs bill in creating more jobs to help strengthen the economy. .... or blaming republicans of hindering the ACA vote. Yet the democrats were the party in charge of it all, who could pass whatever they wanted and send it to the desk of Obama, I'm sure.
I can only hope you're capable of comprehending that's not what happened regarding GSE reform as the minority party Democrats did not block any GSE reform bills. Though they were on the wrong side of the issue, it was Senate leadership who wouldn't allow any GSE reform bills to be put to a vote by the full Senate.
You can't blame Democrats for that.
The problem is, you are not aware of the process that actually took place in the senate in trying to create meaningful legislation to place that strict oversight on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
Hearing of the Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee - "Regulatory Reform of the Housing Government-Sponsored Enterprises"
Hearing
By: Richard Shelby
Date: April 21, 2004
Location: Washington, DC
This morning the Committee concludes its series of hearings on reforming the regulatory system for Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the Federal Home Loan Bank System."
The Committee has conducted a comprehensive set of hearings on the Housing GSEs, and we have heard testimony from a range of witnesses representing different perspectives in the Housing GSE reform debate.
Following today's hearing, the Committee will begin to consider legislation to create a new regulatory structure for the Housing GSEs. As evidenced by the hearings, there are a number of difficult issues to confront and resolve. I am hopeful that consensus will develop. With cooperation and consensus, I am hopeful that this Committee can pass a meaningful bill--- and I am only interested in producing meaningful regulatory reform.
Source: U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs
DEMOCRATS ON THE COMMITTEE - 13
- Christopher Dodd(Conn.), Chairman
- Tim Johnson (S.D.)
- Jack Reed (R.I.)
- Chuck Schumer(N.Y.)
- Evan Bayh (Ind.)
- Robert Menendez(N.J.)
- Daniel Akaka(Hawaii)
- Sherrod Brown(Ohio)
- Jon Tester (Mont.)
- Herb Kohl (Wisc.)
- Mark Warner (Va.)
- Jeff Merkley (Ore.)
- Michael Bennet(Colo.)
REPUBLICANS ON THE COMMITTEE - 6
• Richard Shelby (Ala) - Ranking Member
• Robert Bernetti (Utah)
• Jim Bunning (KY)
• Mike Crapo (Idaho)
•. Mel Martinez (Fla)
• Bob Corker (Tenn)
This clearly shows that a vote along party lines in allowing the committee to agree on any strict legislative action would quickly die in the senate without the bipartisan support it needed to move forward. So yes, it was blocked by Democrats.
I think that the responsibility that the Democrats had may rest more in resisting any efforts by Republicans in the Congress, or by me when I was President, to put some standards and tighten up a little on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.” – Former President Bill Clinton (D-AR), September 25, 2008
Perhaps your information in placing the responsibility on Republicans "not doing its job" was based by a source unfamiliar with the investigative hearings and legislative process at the time, or its from a biased news source that was looking to spin and politicize such action for political gains during an election year?
That didn't happen.
Even though Democrats were wrong on the issue, they didn't block any any GSE reform bills. They didn't have to. Senate leadership is where those bills were blocked.
If you followed the evidence of the procedure of the committee, they were looking to put a regulations bill in place from the Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee. I don't see where Democrats have allowed such regulation legislative action to continue. Unless you have such evidence through a link to the contrary, that democrats allowed such regulator legislation to continue, you do really have anything at all supportive to your argument. Government records of the proceedings cares a bit more weight than a news article
But you know I'm talking about years prior to that. When such legislation was desperately needed. Democrats were wrong on the issue but Republicans were running the government.